Working draft. It states what the project intends so that a lawyer can turn it into a license. It is not yet in force. Until it is, contributors share material on the understanding that these are the terms being drafted.
Why not just an open game license
An open game license answers one question: may other people reuse the rules and the text? That is not enough here, because Game-Changers is more than a game file. It is a peerticipatory game show with a community around it, and it has to avoid the fate of many open games, which are published, downloaded and then left to die.
A prompt that someone wrote or was commissioned to write gets played. Recordings and documentation follow. People in different places take it to their own struggles, in their own languages, with their own narratives and strategies. Each performance has performers, a jury of peers, a facilitator, someone documenting, maybe an artist whose image is on the card, a curator who composed the edition, an organiser who hosted it and a moderator who made it safe to share. All of that, with its metadata, becomes a set of parallel galleries of discourse, people and performances, which can be read side by side and connected, so that people in different places can find each other.
An open file holds none of that, and a license that only says "copy this, keep the credit" leaves out most of the people who keep the game alive. This one is inspired by the commons licenses and by open game licenses such as Mörk Borg's, which is generous to third parties and rules out NFTs altogether. It departs from them in three ways. It is tied to the platform that holds the archive. It names every role, not only the author. And it asks what a funding mechanism does rather than what it is called, so a token can be a credit and not a speculative asset.
Underneath all this is literacy: practice in recognising empty futures and taking them apart, saying why they are wrong, and proposing alternatives and ways to reach better ones. The game is where people practise this together. The commons is where they find others doing the same, and it is meant to make it easier for networks of networks to form. It is one way to weave them, not the only one.
What it covers
Three layers, each with different rules.
- Materials. Cards, playing fields, buzzwords, prompts, artworks, translations, annotations, rules variants, edition configurations.
- Records. Everything about how the materials were used: edition records, performances (moves, scores, transcripts, recordings) and the metadata that links them, such as who did what, where, when and in what language.
- The platform. The software has its own open source license and is not covered here. This license covers what is stored and shown through it.
The roles, and credit for every one
Everyone who has a role in an edition or a material is credited in the record, and the credit travels with the material wherever it appears on the platform.
| Role | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| Players, as performers | Who played, on which side, which card on which field, and their recorded moves |
| Peerticipants (the jury) | That they took part, and their scores in aggregate. Individuals are not named unless they choose to be |
| Card and field authors | Author of each prompt, field or buzzword, and its source |
| Researchers | Who wrote commissioned prompts, which one was chosen, and from what research |
| Artists | Who made each artwork and any variations |
| Translators | Who translated or localised, and into which language |
| Curators | Who composed the edition and the choices they made |
| Organisers and hosts | Who convened and hosted the session |
| Facilitators | Who ran the table, as master of ceremonies |
| Commentators and interpreters | Who commented on the moves and told the failure stories |
| Documenters and archivers | Who recorded, transcribed and logged it |
| Moderators | That the material was reviewed, and when. Not their individual decisions, which are kept in a moderation log |
| Supporters | That they made an open release possible, where they chose to be credited |
How the record is made. The organisers or the archivers of an edition fill in the record, because they know who was there. Each person named can see their entry and ask for a correction, for another name, or for a pseudonym. Disagreements go to the moderators. A person who is not credited, or is credited wrongly, can have it fixed. Credit may be a pseudonym and may be changed later.
The terms
1. You may
Print, perform, record, translate, adapt and combine the materials into new cards, decks, boards, editions, books, films, games and other works, and use them in workshops, classes, assemblies, festivals and publications, in any language and for any struggle.
2. You must
- Credit every role as the record shows it, and keep the credit and the link to the original when you reuse a material.
- Share alike. Share what you make from commons materials on these terms.
- Keep the lineage. Mark a changed card, field or edition as a variation of the original, and cite what an edition is built from, so that the connections between galleries remain.
- Record your edition. When you run an edition built from commons materials, fill in the edition record: who played and who did the other roles, which materials were used, where and when. You are asked to offer the record to the archive. You are never required to publish recordings or names of people who do not want to be shown.
- Keep the notice that the material is under this license.
3. You may not
- Claim exclusive rights over commons materials, or over records of how they were used.
- Remove or alter credit, or credit someone against their wish.
- Use technical measures, paywalls or access tokens to restrict others from using materials under these terms.
- Present anyone as endorsing your use.
- Use the records to profile, track, target or sell data about the people in them, or to identify a person who has asked not to be identified.
- Use the materials to harass or endanger people.
4. People in performances and recordings
Performances put real people in public.
- Consent first. A recording, transcript or photo is shared only with the agreement of the people in it. Players and facilitators agree to what is shown. Audience members are not identified.
- Withdrawal. A person can withdraw their agreement, and the platform removes or anonymises their part going forward. Copies others already made under these terms cannot be recalled, which is why consent comes first.
- Risk. A public record can expose people to harassment or policing. A group may keep sensitive details, names or recordings within itself and share only the method. Sharing the method is enough to meet the duty to share back.
- Authorship. Performers are the authors of their moves. By agreeing to the recording they license the move on these terms. Scores belong to the record, as the audience's reception, and are not a verdict on a person.
5. Artists, and open release
Artists keep their copyright and license their artwork on these terms. An artwork funded through open patronage is released to everyone when its goal is reached, and the credit for the artist, the card and its supporters is recorded. Artists may offer several interpretations of the same prompt, and all of them stay in the gallery.
Money past the goal follows the funding model: the artist keeps the share they chose, between 1% and 50% (a third by default), up to a further 20% of the rate, and the rest splits evenly between the platform and the commons pool.
Existing work lent by an artist. An artist may lend a work they already made as the background of a card, with their permission written down. Someone else may offer it for them, and then the artist is asked first. They choose the terms: open, so that the artwork is free for everyone like any released card, or for this card only, so that it appears on the card in the game, in the archive and in printed editions of the game, but the image itself is not re-licensed and nobody may reuse it on its own. Either way the artist is credited on the card, the record keeps the permission, its scope and its date, and the artist can ask for the loan to end for new copies. An artist who keeps the artwork free may still offer a print of the card, or the original, for sale or auction to fund a project of their own, and the money goes to them. An artist who does not give the work away may instead claim a share of what people give to the card, from 1% to 50%, and the rest goes to the platform and the commons pool. A work whose artist has not agreed is not used.
Rights come in layers. The rules, the mechanics and the card text are open under the terms above. Commissioned or lent artwork carries the artist's own terms, which may be narrower, and the card says which. The names and logo of Game-Changers are not covered, and anyone may say that their work is compatible with Game-Changers without implying it is an official edition.
6. NFTs and other ledgers
NFTs, tokens and public ledgers are not banned here, and they are not a way to enclose anything. The test is what they do.
Allowed. A ledger or token may record that an open release happened, who made it possible, and under what conditions. It may be held as a credit, a receipt or a proof of support. It may be used to route payment through the funding split, and to open a place in conversations about the future of that card, for example proposing a variant or taking part in a commissioning discussion.
Not allowed.
- Exclusive rights, scarcity or limited editions of a commons material, or any access that depends on holding a token.
- Resale or royalty promises, speculative marketing, or pricing that rewards early buyers.
- Governance weight that depends only on money. Influence follows participation: playing, judging, writing, translating, documenting, hosting, curating.
- Anything that stops the card or artwork from being free for everyone once released.
Also. Every record that is on a ledger is kept off it too, so removing a token never removes credit. People can credit by name, pseudonym or not at all. The mechanism should use low-energy infrastructure. If a ledger is not needed to do the job, it is not used.
The aim is to show that the same technology can be used as a commons tool.
7. Parallel galleries and connecting people
- Variants, translations and local editions are shown next to the original, linked through their lineage.
- An edition is placed on the tree of editions only with the consent of its makers, who can ask to come off it. It names the version it is based on. To count as a branch at least half of the minimum set of challenges and interventions for its board is new, its own, which the platform counts from the credits of the cards. Wildcards and fields do not count. The cards with no special credit in the original deck are Rok Kranjc's, from his research and interviews around 2017 to 2019, and carry the terms above like every other card.
- People may opt in to being contacted by others working on the same material, so that the networks the game is meant to build can form. Nobody may harvest contact details from the records.
- Hosts of local editions may add their own context and keep their own space, as long as the credit and lineage stay.
8. Commercial use
Peer production licenses limit commercial use to those who give something back. This license does the same.
- Free for non-commercial use, and for cooperatives, non-profits and other organisations that are owned or governed by the people who use them: workshops, classes, assemblies, festivals, libraries, community and artist-run spaces.
- Other commercial users (a company that sells the materials, or a product or service built on them, for profit) pay an agreed share of the revenue from that use into the Game Commons pool. They still credit, share alike and keep the lineage. The share, and what counts as revenue from the use, are set by the commons' own decision process and published.
- Print editions the project sells and editions it is commissioned to make are not affected: the materials in them return to the commons.
Other paths were possible and were weighed. Free for any use with share-alike only is simpler and the most open, but it lets a company profit from artists' and performers' work and give nothing back to the pool that pays them. Free for any use with a voluntary contribution asked for is friendlier in tone, but in practice little comes back and the pool and the artists carry the cost. The first path was chosen because the platform is funded by its community, and the commons should not be a free supply for those who are not part of it.
9. Artificial intelligence
The materials are made by people, for people, and the people in them have consented to be there. These terms follow from that. They cover five things.
Training. Commons materials are not to be used to train or fine-tune AI systems without the contributor's opt-in. Each artist, author and performer decides for their own contribution, and may ask for a fee, which goes through the funding split like any other support. Recordings, voices, faces and likenesses of people are never used for training, whatever else is agreed, because consent to be shown is not consent to be copied. Scores and metadata are not used to build profiles of people. Scraping the archive for training is a breach of these terms.
Other paths were possible and were weighed. Not allowed at all is the strongest rule but hard to enforce, and leaves no way for a contributor who wants to say yes. Allowed for prompts and card text only protects artists and performers but is hard to explain and to police. Allowed, with credit and share-alike on the resulting model is open in spirit but hard to apply to a trained model, and puts artists and people in recordings at risk. Opt-in was chosen as the one rule that follows each person's own choice.
AI-made artwork. Allowed, on condition that it is labelled as AI-made, with the prompt author credited and, where a person directed or edited it, that person credited as well. A label stays with the image wherever it appears. AI-made images stand in as placeholders and can be offered as renditions. A human-made rendition replaces an AI-made one as the default when votes are tied, and the platform invites people to make their own. An artwork carrying an AI label is not paid through open patronage as human artist's work, unless it is part of a human artist's own process and the artist says how. The current placeholders are AI-made and are marked as placeholders.
Other paths were possible and were weighed. Placeholders only, never funded protects the patronage money completely, but gives a thoughtful artist who uses these tools no honest way in. No restriction is simplest, but it would undermine what patronage is for.
AI-made prompts. A prompt is the author's statement and carries their name. A person may use a tool to help draft, shorten or translate one, and then they stand behind it as its author, and the card says it was AI-assisted. A prompt that no person has written or edited and answers for is not accepted into the open call, and cannot be the commissioned prompt of a monthly card, which is paid to a researcher for their research. Quotations and sources must be checked by a person.
AI-made processing of data. Machine help with transcripts, timestamps, subtitles, translations, summaries and tagging is welcome, because documenting a session by hand takes many hours. It must follow these rules.
- Local first. Recordings and transcripts are processed on the archiver's own computer or on infrastructure the commons controls. They are not sent to a third-party cloud service unless every person in the recording has agreed to that, and the recording is not used by that service for its own training.
- Marked as machine output. Machine transcripts and timestamps carry a mark (machine-made, not yet reviewed) until a person reads them against the recording and changes it to reviewed, with their name as the documenter. The people who speak can ask for a correction.
- Tools are part of the record. The edition record names the tool, its version and the model used, so that errors can be traced and the work repeated.
- No hidden identification. Speaker labels are the names or pseudonyms people agreed to. No voice prints, face recognition or emotion scoring.
- People stay the deciders. A tool may suggest tags, flag possible problems or draft a summary. It does not decide who is credited, what is moderated or what is published.
- Processing is not training. Running a tool on a recording does not give anyone the right to train on it.
- Low-energy and long-lived. Where there is a choice, the tool that runs on modest, older computers and has fully open code is preferred (see Local tools for documenting a session in the platform manual for what is known to work).
10. Contributors confirm that
- they wrote what they submit or have the right to share it on these terms, and have cited sources;
- the people shown or heard in it agreed;
- they say so if AI made or helped make it;
- they have read the license. Submitting to the commons is acceptance of it.
You may stop sharing new copies at any time. Copies released under these terms stay available under them.
11. Moderation and governance
Moderators may decline or remove material that breaks these terms, puts people at risk or is not the contributor's to share. Their decisions go in a moderation log, and the person affected can ask for a review. The license can be amended through the commons' own decision process, announced in advance. A release stays under the version it was released under, unless its contributors accept a newer one.
12. No warranty
The materials are provided as they are. Contributors and the project are not liable for how they are used.
Open points for review
- How the revenue share in section 8 is set and collected, and what counts as commercial use.
- How the opt-in for AI training (section 9) is recorded and passed on, and how an AI label is checked.
- Which jurisdiction's law applies, and whether to build on an existing license such as Creative Commons ShareAlike with added clauses for roles, people and ledgers.
- How moral rights, the right to withdraw and pseudonymous credit work across countries.
- Who can fill in an edition record when the organisers are not part of the platform.
- A short form to show beside a card, a recording and a submission screen.