Knowledge commons

Layers of peerticipation

The dials a curator can set to share authority over an edition, from curated by one person to steered by a community.

Peerticipation means taking part as a peer: able to change the premise as well as to act within it. A curated session can be open in some ways and closed in others, and each choice is a political choice about who shapes what can be said. This page lists the dials, how much each one hands to the community, and what the platform does today to support it.

A curator, or a group of curators, sets every dial before the call opens and publishes the settings on the edition page, so everyone knows what they can influence. Choosing a tighter setting is fine. Pretending a tight setting is an open one is not.

The dials

1. Theme and playing fields

What is the session about, and which battlegrounds are on the board?

  1. Curated. The curator decides.
  2. Options. The curator offers a few themes and the community votes.
  3. Proposed. Anyone proposes themes or fields, moderators cluster and filter them, and the community votes.
  4. Contextual. The theme comes from the community or the event the edition belongs to, such as a conference programme, an assembly or a movement's strategy.

The themes the platform shows are examples of what curators can offer. A curator can reword a pair or push it further, to something like Exocapitalism vs. Mycoeconomics, and try other opposing forces. The two sides need not be strictly opposed ideologies either: a future edition could set two different views within one ideology against each other, for example two readings of degrowth or of the commons. The game manual describes how to run it, and how to run the game with players who are not commonists at heart.

In the platform: the Commons pool has a theme vote on example pairs, which is how options would work for later sessions. The theme of the opening session is set by the curators and is not voted on. The program shows it.

2. Players and teams

Who plays and on which side?

  1. Invited. The curator chooses everyone.
  2. Split. The curator chooses some, the community chooses the others. For example the curator picks four of six players and the community picks two.
  3. Open call. Anyone can apply or be nominated and the selection is by vote, with an eye on the balance of the table (gender, geography, experience, position).
  4. Nominated and sided. Everyone gets a few votes, which say both who should play and which team they should be on.

Which side. Whatever option is used, a player can state a preference for a side, and the curators can invite someone to a side for their experience or another reason. The community can then vote on who plays which side for the players who have no preference or invitation. Choosing sides is part of the framing: it says who is expected to argue for what.

Balance of the table. At a table of six there are at least two women, at least two men and at least one non-binary or gender-diverse person, and the sixth seat is open to anyone. These are minimums, not quotas and not a test: nobody is asked to prove anything, and people describe their own gender or say nothing. Women and men include trans women and trans men. With six seats every seat counts, so we count whole seats and not percentages, and a guaranteed place for non-binary and gender-diverse people keeps them from having to compete for a single leftover one. Across a larger pool and over many sessions the benchmark is 40:40:20, the targets used for boards and leadership teams in Australia and New Zealand (Champions of Change Coalition, Chief Executive Women, Global Women, a South Australian government position statement on boards) and, for events, the guidelines of the Politecnico di Torino (each gender between 40 and 60%, the least represented never below 30%). Sexual orientation is never asked, recorded, guessed or balanced on: a game should not sort people by who they love, and in data protection law it is a special category of personal data. Women can be queer, and so can anyone else; queer voices come in through the open nominations, the themes and what people choose to say in their own bios. The minimums are reviewed after the first sessions, when we can see who sat at the table.

Balance across a season. Not every session has to meet a formula, but the official series does over time. Across a season of twelve sessions, seventy-two seats, the aim is that at least 40% of the seats go to women, at least 40% to men and at least 10% to non-binary and gender-diverse people, that at least 40% go to people who speak from a racialised, Indigenous or colonised community, and that at least 40% go to people who live and work mainly outside Western Europe and North America. One person can count in more than one of these. These are targets for the season and not quotas for individual seats, and they are met by how seats are filled, never by asking a person to stand for a group. No seat carries a label.

Here is how. The curators' four seats are the balancing seats: before each session the curators see the running totals for the season, only the totals, and fill the gaps from a pool that comes through the networks of guest curators from different regions. The community's two seats are voted from a shortlist that the moderators keep balanced against the same totals, so every name on it is a fair choice. Every player is paid, sessions are captioned and interpreted where needed and run at hours that work in more than one time zone, because a target without that only moves the problem somewhere else. Self-description is voluntary, asked after the session in an anonymous form and kept as totals, never next to a name. Sexual orientation is not asked at all, and racial or ethnic origin is, in data protection law, a special category that needs a person's explicit consent. The totals are published after each season, with what we changed because of them.

Experience elsewhere explains the shape. Rules that only require a diverse shortlist, such as the Rooney Rule in American football, have been criticised for producing interviews that are a formality, and some of the people they were meant to help did not want to be seen as hired for a quota. Stratified selection by lottery, which citizens' assemblies use to match a community in age, gender, place and background, shows that balance can come from how a pool is built and drawn. We use targets over a season, a wider pool, paid seats and the curators' balancing seats instead of a label on any one person. A lawyer should check the wording before it is treated as binding, since what counts as lawful positive action differs between countries.

In the platform: the player pool lists people who have played. Anyone can nominate someone new, and moderators check with the person before they are listed. Nobody appears without agreeing.

3. Cards

Who writes the prompts and who decides which ones get into the deck?

  1. Curated. The curator and invited authors write the deck.
  2. Open call. A window is open for anyone to submit cards. The curator chooses.
  3. Open call with a vote. The same window, and the community upvotes. The cards with the most votes join the deck.
  4. Live. The audience writes cards during play.

Every card keeps the name of its author. When a community card is drawn in a game it appears with its creator's name and the edition it came from, and its reuse is recorded. Cards that were upvoted but not chosen stay in the archive, available for other editions.

4. Judging terms

What does the audience score? Convincing, radical, plausible, rooted in a local struggle, surprising? The default is subjective. A curator can fix a criterion, offer a few and let the audience choose, or let a session's players ask for one. It changes the contest.

5. Commissions

Each monthly session commissions two pieces of work, paid from the commons pool:

  • A researcher of the session's topic writes several prompts on it, usually three to five.
  • An artist makes the artwork for the prompt that is chosen.

Which prompt gets the artwork is a choice too. The community can vote on the researcher's prompts, or the curator can choose, or the researcher can. The prompts that are not chosen are kept as text cards and can be commissioned in a later month.

The curator can pick the researcher and artist, or propose a shortlist that the community votes on, or open it entirely. Whoever is chosen is paid, which means labour on the platform is not treated as a favour.

6. The pool

How much of the Game Commons pool goes to what? The pool pays for commissions, translation, documentation, seed money for community editions and the platform itself. In the early phases a small stewardship group decides. As the membership grows, more of the allocation moves to proposals the community votes on.

7. Curation itself

Who curates? A curator, a guest curator, a collective, or the community. Rotating guest curators bring their own networks and framing. A curator can also give the community a seat in the curating team for one edition.

Rules of peerticipation at the table

The dials above are set before a session. These are the roles the audience has during it. They are part of the rules, and a game without them is missing a piece.

  • Score. Every audience member gives each move a number from 0 to 6, by a criterion the curator has set or the room has chosen. A lightning round is different: nobody scores it. When the minute is up the audience votes for one team or the other. A clear winner takes the field and the other team's card, and its point, is discarded. At about 50:50 both cards stay on, and the field can be revisited later with a Trojan Horse or Co-optation token.
  • Respond. Anyone can ask for the floor after a move to give feedback, a question, a critique or an addition, and teams can invite a comment with a Feedback Request token.
  • Tell why it failed. When a move fails after the roll, at least one person, usually from the audience, tells the story of why, from what was said. A high score that fails is a compelling move with bad luck. A low score is a move that did not convince. It is feedback for the players, and it is recorded with the move and the name of whoever told it.
  • Write a card. Audience members can write prompts during play. The card is credited to them.
  • Mirror. One person follows the game on the platform and documents it: the cards and fields in play (custom ones included, set up in advance), who played what, the scores, the dice, how long each move took, the failure stories, and the recordings. They send the game in, moderators check it, and it becomes an edition in the archive with every role credited.
  • Choose the next game. Between sessions, the community proposes themes and cards, picks players and shapes the next edition, as in the dials.

Timing is part of the rules of peerticipation too. A move is up to two minutes and the timer is a reference, not a stop. Newcomers can warm up freely, and a move can run when it gets heated. The platform records how long each move took, and the duration guide in the game manual is refined from those records.

Bundles

The dials combine into a few recognisable setups.

Bundle Theme Players Cards Commissions
Curated Curator All invited Curator Curator
Curated with a voice Curator Curator picks most, community picks some Curator + community-upvoted cards Curator proposes, community votes
Community steered Proposed and voted Open call, voted Open call with a vote Shortlist, voted
Embedded From a community or event Nominated by the group Collected from the group The group decides

The opening session of the monthly series, online with the players and the audience taking part remotely, is a curated with a voice edition: the curators set the theme and the two teams, and the community has its say on the cards, the commissions and two of the six players. Its date is still to be announced. See the program.

Branches and the tree

Game-Changers grows by forking. Anyone can load an edition, use it as their basis, make it their own and share it. The tree shows which versions people use and fork the most, and where new branches grow, for example from research done in or for a social movement.

The trunk is the original deck. The cards with no special credit, the Base Game Edition, are Rok Kranjc's, from his research and interviews around 2017 to 2019. Every other edition is based on a version that came before it, and says which.

What counts as a branch. At least half of the minimum set of challenges and interventions for an edition's board has to be new, its own. A six-field board needs 12 of each, so 12 of those 24 cards. Wildcards and fields do not count. Below that it is a bud while it is growing, and a leaf when it is simply played with mostly borrowed material. A branch can be a book (any old or new book on ideological contestation, power, the analysis of capitalism or its alternatives), a side quest with a local co-op or movement, a movement's own research, one person with spare time who likes to research, or a meme edition of current events. It does not have to be played to exist: an edition nobody has played yet can still be found and appreciated. The first book branch is the Radical vs. Liberal Abundance Edition, built around the book Radical Abundance by Kai Heron, Keir Milburn and Bertie Russell (Pluto Press, 2025). At least half of its deck comes from the book and its writers: the book itself and its writers directly, each card with its quotation and page. Some cards are also inspired by Games Transformed, where the edition is first played, challenges and interventions alike. The rest comes from the archive. A branch can also have a fund of its own, paid by the support its cards receive, with initiatives and ideas for what to spend it on kept in the open. It is for true branches, where at least half of the minimum set of challenges and interventions for the board is new (see funding).

Consent. An edition goes on the tree only with the consent of its makers, and they can ask to come off it. Being on the tree is a way of being found and credited, never a requirement.

Reading the tree. A thicker stem has more growing from it. Leaves along the trunk are events where the game was played and nothing is processed yet. Dashed arcs join editions that share cards or players, so the picture is a tree for descent and a network for relations, closer to a brain than to an oak. Clicking a leaf or a node opens that edition. Clicking a stem shows the version it grows from, down to the trunk, which is the original deck. The tree is updated as sessions are processed and as people share their forks. The two views of a year and five years ahead are imagined: they show where the practice could go, and are not a forecast or a target for forks.

Memes and gaps. The game's elements can also be used on social media to meme current events: we have seen this before, with a card from the archive, or this is new, with a card of your own. When you write a card the card maker tells you if something like it is already in the archive. If nothing is, that gap is a good reason for a new card, and several such cards are a good reason for a new edition, which can start as a bud on the tree.

A branch can be forked in turn, and the fork brings its own material again. To start one, or to fork one, see the branches.

Principles

  • Many partial roles. People can take part at different intensities and in different capacities: play, judge, write a card, translate, document, give money, host. Nothing asks for everything.
  • Pay where labour is asked for. Open participation can turn into unpaid labour for the few who show up. Where the series asks for work, such as a researcher's prompt or an artwork, it is paid from the pool.
  • Visibility is power. Which cards appear on the front page, which edition is highlighted and what becomes a default are governance decisions. They should be traceable and not left to opaque ranking.
  • Respect risk. A public performance or a traceable record can expose people to harassment or policing. Everyone decides what to show, and a group can keep sensitive details or recordings within itself.
  • No capture. Support gives no veto over meaning, a curator does not canonise an edition for good, and a prolific author does not become the default voice. A share of commissions is reserved for first-time contributors.
  • Refuse the premise. A group can change the medium, or decline a premise it cannot recognise itself in.