Game-Changers is played between two teams who argue for opposing positions by performing short moves from prompt cards. An audience scores each move. A die decides whether the move lands. The board is a map of contested ideas, and the team holding more of it at the end wins. Every session is an experiment, a temporary social architecture for collective thinking, so treat the rules below as a structure that works and leave room to vary it.
This manual builds on the Playbook, Setup and Facilitation Guide and adds what the platform changes: a shared card by default, different ways to draw, players choosing their own starting cards, and board-size recommendations. It uses "first team" and "second team" so it fits any edition. In the example edition they were Liberal Abundance and Radical Abundance. Other popular pairings are Capitalism vs. Commonism and Green Growth vs. Degrowth. Curators can try new flavours of opposing forces, such as Exocapitalism vs. Mycoeconomics, and the two teams could also hold different views within one ideology instead of strict opposites. The Variations section below says how that works, and how to run the game with players who are not commonists at heart.
What you need
- A facilitator (the "soft GM"), a timer, and a place where the board is visible to everyone.
- Two teams of two or three players, and an audience. Online or in a room both work.
- At least one person in the audience, or more, ready to tell the story of a failed move (see below).
- A mirror: someone who follows the game on the platform and documents it (see below).
- An edition: a board, three decks (Challenges, Interventions, Wildcards) and two team names. Play can create an example edition for you, or you can make one in the edition builder.
- A way to score: hands, cards, a poll or the mobile app. Anything that lets everyone give a number from 0 to 6.
- A die (or the wheel on screen), and some way of marking claimed fields.
Who is at the table
- Players perform the moves.
- Peerticipants, the audience, score every move and may respond. They can also write cards, and tell the story of a failed move. These are the rules of peerticipation: the audience is part of how the game is played, and the game is not complete without it.
- The facilitator, who can also be the master of ceremonies, keeps the game moving and looks after the room.
- Commentators, also called interpreters, comment on the moves as they happen and are called on especially after a failed move, to tell the failure story. In official sessions the curators choose them.
- The mirror documents. This is a person using the platform alongside the game, ideally one who is not playing. The mirror reproduces the game as it happens, so that it can be added to the archive afterwards.
One person can take more than one of these, but the first sessions go better with a different person for each.
The mirror
The mirror opens Play, ticks I am mirroring a game played somewhere else and follows along. They need a little set-up before the game:
- Build the edition the game uses: the board, the three decks, the two teams. If the game has custom playing fields or custom cards, add every one of them first, with its author, so that whatever is played can be picked. This is most of the work, and it is worth doing the day before.
- Start the mirrored game and give your name. Nothing is dealt, because the real hands are on the table: for every move you pick the card that was played from the deck, the field, who played it, and then enter the audience score and the die.
- The mirror's table keeps the time each move took, and the failure stories, and shows the log.
- Record the session on the side: audio, video, or just an edited transcript. The facilitator or the mirror can also press Start session on Play at the start and Stop session at the end. Every card played, score, roll, lightning round and wheel spin is then time-stamped, and the draft carries the times. Play can record audio on the device from the same instant, if everyone at the table agrees, or you can say how many seconds earlier your own recording started, so that the times line up with it.
- When it is over, send the game in: the table exports the draft session, the setup with every card and field, the recordings you link and your notes. Moderators check it, and after moderation it is worked into the platform as an edition, with the performances tied to the cards, and everyone credited.
A mirror can also document a game afterwards from a recording. The mirror is credited on the edition.
Setup
Teams and players
Each team stands for a broad ideological or discursive position. The polarity should feel real enough to produce friction and loose enough that people can play with it. Each team has two or three players. Two-player teams make for faster, tighter exchanges. Three-player teams allow more discussion and improvisation.
Choose players the way you would curate a panel. You can invite people directly, run an open call and select, or let the audience or a community nominate players and vote on who should be on which side. A player can also state a preference for a side, or be invited to one for their experience or another reason; the vote then settles the rest. The act of choosing teams already sets the stage for how the community defines the field of debate. Layers of peerticipation describes the options in detail.
Assemble the board
A board is built from buzzwords and playing fields. A buzzword is an overarching signifier, such as Sharing, Circular, Regenerative or Smart. Each buzzword anchors two playing fields: concrete sites of practice, policy or speculation such as Platform Cooperative, Time Bank, Universal Basic Something or Participatory Budgeting. A field can fit under more than one buzzword, which is where the fighting starts.
To choose them, the organiser can propose a draft list, the players can change or add to it, and the audience can vote before the event or live in the room. The order does not matter, as long as each team has at least one field it can argue from with conviction or irony.
Board size and duration
The times are what the documented sessions actually took, with moves that run long, seconds between phases, extra lightning rounds, Trojan Horse and Co-optation plays, audience responses and failure stories. They leave out introductions and the discussion afterwards. A game with strict one-minute timers and nothing going wrong is faster, and the right-hand column gives that figure.
| Buzzwords | Playing fields | About | With strict timers | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | 4 | 40 minutes | 30 | Demos, plug-ins, one-to-one duels |
| 3 | 6 | 55 minutes | 45 | Workshops and "learn while you play" |
| 4 | 8 | 75 minutes | 60 | The sweet spot for public events |
| 6 | 12 | 110 minutes | 90 | In-depth or internal community sessions |
For reference: the panke.gallery session played 12 fields in about 110 minutes, with 20 moves, two lightning rounds and four spins of the wheel. That is about 5 to 6 minutes per move, and about 9 minutes per field. An online session of 6 fields ran longer, because of the discussion between moves. Plan for your own room, and put your own timings in the record: every game the platform records keeps the time each move took, and these figures will be refined from them.
The most balanced flow is six to eight fields with two or three players per side: long enough for arcs to form, short enough to keep energy high. The platform marks 3 and 4 wedge boards as recommended.
Lock in
If a team holds both fields of the same buzzword, it locks that wedge in. Two things follow. A Co-optation or Trojan Horse token used against a locked-in field has to win a flip first: flip the token, and icon side up means the lock gives way and the attempt goes ahead, blank side up means the lock holds and the token is lost. And if the team still holds both fields when the game ends, each of them scores 2, so the wedge is worth four points instead of two. Locking in at the last minute counts the same as locking in early, and a lock that is broken scores nothing extra. In Play, a locked-in wedge shines in its team's colour.
--- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 4 | 2v2 | 2 | 2 | one after each of the first two cards played | 8 | | 4 | 3v3 | 2 | 2 | none | 8 | | 6 | 2v2 | 3 | 1 | one after each of the first four | 11 | | 6 | 3v3 | 2 | 2 | one after each of the first three | 11 | | 8 | 2v2 | 3 | 2 | one after each of the first six | 14 | | 8 | 3v3 | 3 | 2 | one after each of the first three | 14 | | 12 | 2v2 | 3 | 2 | one after each of the first eleven | 19 | | 12 | 3v3 | 3 | 2 | one after each of the first eight | 19 |
Shared cards sit face up for the whole team, and any player on it may use each one once. You can set the number to zero, or to any number.
How many cards. A team plays about one and a quarter cards for each field in a typical game, and about one and a half in one game out of ten, because failed moves and responses use cards too. The standard hands hold about one and two thirds cards for each field, so a few more than the board needs: a team rarely runs out before every field is settled, and a game that goes long still can. These numbers come from counting the moves of many simulated games. The deck keeps its minimum of two cards for each field, which covers every hand above. In the variation where a token needs a shared card, each token spends one, so the setup adds one shared card to the standard (two at 12 fields).
Draws. After a team plays a card, it may draw a new one. You choose how often: none, after the first play, after the first and second, and so on up to keep drawing, where a team draws after every card it plays for as long as the deck lasts. The Playbook does not say who gets the new card. Play gives it to the teammate with the fewest cards, which is the player who just played unless hands are uneven, so hands stay level.
A further variation is an endless supply: a team keeps drawing, and when its deck runs out the discards it holds are shuffled back in, so nobody runs out of cards. It suits long games and small decks. Play has it as an option, and it turns on keep drawing as well.
Another is letting the audience pick the new card. The card is not drawn at random: at the start of the team's next turn, three cards from the top of its deck are shown, the audience says or signals which one it would like the player to receive (a number, or one, two or three fingers), and whoever runs the table, the facilitator or the mirror, takes that one. The other two go back into the deck. The pick is made right before the turn, so the audience sees what the team is about to play with. At a table, deal three cards face up and ask. In Play, tick The audience picks each new card; the table can still draw at random for a single card. It changes only the cards drawn after plays, not the starting hands.
Who chooses. In the standard deal each player chooses two or three starting cards from their team's deck, as many as the table says, and the rest are dealt at random. In players choose their starting cards, everyone picks all of their starting cards (and the team picks its shared ones). Anything left empty is dealt at random. In a fully random deal everything is drawn blind. It is the fastest and the most chaotic.
Visibility. In open hands teammates can see and discuss each other's cards. This is best for public events and new players. In closed hands nobody sees a teammate's cards and the active player chooses alone. Some wildcards force closed hands for a while.
How a game plays
Who goes first
The first team opens. This reflects the usual asymmetry of political debate: the existing order tends to frame the terms before alternatives can even be articulated. If the second team gets ahead, the order starts to change. When it leads by one point it opens on a roll of 6, when it leads by two a 50:50 die roll decides who opens, and when it leads by three or more it opens automatically.
That is the standard. When there is no established order between the two teams, round one can be decided by a coin flip, or by a roll weighted by how much power each position has in the world. Both are described in Variations. Whichever way round one is decided, the team that opened it takes the part of the first team in the rule above: it keeps opening until the other team leads.
The anatomy of a turn
A turn takes about four to five minutes in practice. The times below are a guide, not a strict limit. Sessions are often better when a move is allowed to run while it is getting good, and newcomers need to warm up. Use the timer as a reference: look at the time a move took afterwards and see if you can bring it closer to the limit next time.
| Phase | Time | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Decision | about 30 seconds | The active team chooses a card and a field. They should already be thinking about it while the other team plays. |
| 2. Move | up to 2 minutes | The team performs. A speech, a pitch, a micro-performance or an improvised story, as long as it comes out of the card and tries to convince a (leftist) audience. One minute is a good target once a team is warmed up. The timer runs but does not stop the move. |
| 3. Audience vote | about 30 seconds | The audience scores how convincing, original or compelling it was, from 0 to 6. You can tweak what is being scored, such as realism, radicalness or rootedness in local struggle. |
| 4. Audience response (optional) | up to 1 minute | An audience member can answer with feedback, a question, a critique or an addition. A team can also spend one of its limited Feedback Request tokens to invite a comment, which is most useful when votes are split. |
| 5. Roll | about 10 seconds | The team rolls a d6. It succeeds if the roll is equal to or less than the average score. An average of 4 succeeds on 1 to 4 and fails on 5 or 6. |
| 6. Resolution | about 10 seconds | The facilitator announces the outcome, updates the board, and the next turn opens. If the move failed, the failure story comes next. |
Variation: team clocks
Another way to keep time, and not yet part of the standard rules. Each team gets one clock for the whole game, roughly two minutes for each move it will make, about one move for each field. The total is the same as with a limit per move, but the time now belongs to the team and not to the facilitator. The team decides when its turn has ended, and says so or signals it. In a live show that could be a big, shiny button. At a table with a mirror, it is a signal to the mirror, who ends the turn. Knowing when to stop is a skill, and so is the collaboration behind it: the players have to feel together when the move has said what it came to say.
Time also becomes more clearly a currency. A move can take as long as it needs and spend the clock accordingly, or it can say a lot in a little. A line with enough punch might end a turn there and then, and it may well land. The audience knows what the time cost and scores what was said, so neither a long move nor a short one is better in itself. The best-known example so far is the perfect 6 that Sune won at the Regen Alliances Unconference with one line: "You know where you can stick those carbon credits" (listen to it). We will add other examples as they appear.
Play has it as an option. Both clocks show at the top and the one that is running counts down, and a bar under the move fills as the time goes. A clock that runs out stops nothing, so agree beforehand what happens: for example, the remaining moves are played in thirty seconds each. Wildcards that give or take time matter more here. Time Gift and Time Squeeze add to or take from the clock once, for the rounds they would have lasted: 20 seconds for two rounds is 40 seconds on the clock. It has not been tested much yet, so write down how it went.
Failure and success
- Failure. If the roll is higher than the average score, the move fails. The card is discarded and the opposing team may play on any unclaimed field. Then someone tells the story of why it failed.
- Success. The card stays on the board face up under the field. The field is claimed and the opposing team must respond in the same field. That is how power sets the agenda: once a claim is made convincingly, the other side has to react inside its frame. If the first team fails, nothing is owed in response: the second team may choose any open field, and if it succeeds there it keeps it, because the first team has already had its turn.
The failure story
A game needs at least one person, and more is better, who tells the story of a failed move. It is often an audience member, and it can be a player, a commentator or the facilitator. They say, in a sentence or two and based on what was said in the move, why it did not land. The score tells you which story it is:
- A high score and a failed roll (4 or more): the move was compelling and the die went the other way. Say what made it compelling and what it would have taken to land. The story is a recognition, and a consolation.
- A low score (2 or less): the move did not convince. Say what was missing, or what the audience did not buy.
- In between: a close call. Say what was almost there.
The failure story is feedback for the players, as much as a comment from the audience is. It also goes in the record of the move, with who told it. It is short. Skip it when the room is not in the mood, but do not skip it every time: it is where the audience's reasoning is heard.
Comments on any move
Failure is not the only moment for a comment. After any move, whether it landed or not, anyone can say something about it: a peerticipant, a commentator, or a player speaking in character. A comment is short and stays with the move in the record, with who made it and in which role. Play has a small box for it under the last move, closed until someone opens it. The failure story stays as it is.
Counter-move and lightning round
The responding team repeats the sequence: decide, perform, vote, roll. If the response fails, the first team holds the field outright. If it succeeds too, a lightning round starts.
In a lightning round both teams have about one minute in total to argue or perform. There are no turns and no moderation. They have to share the time or fight for it. The audience does not score this round from 0 to 6. When time is up they vote for one team or the other.
- If there is a clear, strong winner, that team is pronounced the winner of the field. The other team's card is discarded, and its point goes with it.
- If it is about 50:50, both cards stay on and the field is contested: each team scores one point for it. A contested field is unresolved tension, which is what democracy often looks like.
A contested field is not settled for good. It can be revisited later with a Trojan Horse or a Co-optation token, which come from the wheel (see below).
A full round, with a lightning round about a third of the time, a token play now and then, the wheel and a failure story, takes about nine minutes in practice. Strict timers and no discussion would make it six to seven.
The Wheel of Speculative Fortune
After every completed round (both teams have played and the result is clear), spin the wheel or roll a die:
| Roll | Effect |
|---|---|
| 1 | The first team draws an extra shared card from its pile. |
| 2 | The second team draws an extra shared card from its pile. |
| 3 | Co-optation token. The first team may retake a contested field, or one held by the other team, using a shared card. |
| 4 | Trojan Horse token. The second team may subvert or reclaim a field using a shared card. |
| 5 | Regular wildcard. A sudden event changes the conditions of play: a lost collaboration, a forced discard, less storytelling time. |
| 6 | Scenario wildcard. A large external shift whose outcome depends on who is in the lead: a policy change, a crisis, a mass movement. |
Using a token
A token is spent on your own turn, on a field the other team holds or on a contested field, together with one of your shared cards. The attempt is made with that card. In the stricter variation a token on its own is not enough: the team needs both the token and shared cards, and may use only those cards to make the Trojan Horse or Co-optation attempt. It makes the shared cards worth keeping, since every team draws them. The platform has this as a setting when you set up a game.
How a scenario wildcard plays out
A scenario wildcard is three cards: a general card (Automation, Covid, A new breed of rioters has stormed the government building) and two scenario cards, one for each team, such as the Capitalism scenario and the Commonism scenario, or the status quo and the struggle beyond it. The general card names the shift. Then the board decides which scenario happens. Count the score and roll one die:
| Who is ahead | First team's scenario | Second team's scenario |
|---|---|---|
| First team by 2 points or more | happens | |
| First team by less than 2 | 1 to 4 | 5 or 6 |
| Level | 1 to 3 | 4 to 6 |
| Second team by less than 2 | 1 or 2 | 3 to 6 |
| Second team by 2 points or more | happens |
So a team that is clearly ahead gets its own story, a narrow lead gives it four chances in six, and level gives each team an even chance. The scenario that happens is read out and played into the rest of the game: both teams have to deal with the world it describes. The platform rolls the die for you, or you can enter the one you rolled at the table.
Wildcard effects
A regular wildcard is a short story about a sudden event, plus one effect that changes the conditions of play. The effect comes from a menu of 23 mechanics. Most only run for a few rounds, and every one is something the table can do with what it already has: time, people, dice, scores, fields, tokens, cards and the story. The exact rule for each mechanic, with its numbers, is in the wildcard mechanics list; this is what they are for.
| Group | Mechanics |
|---|---|
| Time | Time Gift and Time Squeeze add or remove 10 to 60 seconds from a team's storytelling timer for a few rounds. |
| People | We're On Our Own forbids collaboration for a while. The Strength of Weak Ties protects a team against it. Phone-a-Friend brings in a person from the audience for one move. Pass the Mic makes every player on the team speak. |
| Dice and replies | Do-over lets a team reroll a failed move once. Right of Reply gives a team a short answer before the audience vote. |
| Scores | Momentum moves one team's next average score by one or two points. Power-Up and Power-Down raise or lower the average score of cards on a theme. Outlaw forbids a theme or a field. Immunity protects it from Co-optation and challenge. |
| Fields and tokens | Agenda Setting lets one team decide where the next move happens. Token Gift gives a team a Co-optation or Trojan Horse token. Field Shock makes one field harder or easier. Same Card, Other Field sends a move to another field. |
| Cards and hands | Switch-Up exchanges, swaps or picks cards. Sabotage takes cards from an opponent. Leak shows one team the other's cards. Visibility Shift opens or closes the hands for a while. Anyone's Card lets a team play a card from any teammate's hand for a few rounds, instead of only the hand of the player whose round it is. |
| Story | Event Thread changes nothing in the rules and puts the event in the story: for the next few moves, every move has to say how the event touches what it proposes. |
The event always happens in the world as well. Whatever the mechanic does to the rules, the teams have to work what has happened into their next moves, otherwise it is only a penalty. Read the wildcard's narrative out loud first, then the effect.
Choosing the effect. Every existing wildcard has a default effect and three other effects that could fit its story, so an edition or a table can swap one in. The default is shown first on the card's page. Wildcards you write yourself in the card maker get a menu of the mechanics: pick one, set the numbers, and its rule is written into the effect, which you can still edit. If none fits, you can propose a new mechanic. Moderators read the proposals and the good ones join the menu.
The simulator. The Play simulator applies 13 of the 23 mechanics for you: it changes the timer (Time Gift, Time Squeeze), the score a move rolls against (Momentum, Power-Up, Power-Down, Field Shock), the cards and fields that may be played (Outlaw), the tokens (Token Gift, Immunity), who opens (Agenda Setting), the hands (Visibility Shift, Anyone's Card) and a failed roll (Do-over). The other 10 are rules for people, and Play keeps them on screen as a reminder for the table, with a Done button for when they have run their course. A panel called In effect now lists every effect with its card, the team it names, how long it lasts and what Play does about it. Effects that name a field wait for you to choose it. The team that "drew" the card is the one that played last in the round.
Scoring
Each card on the board at the end is worth one point to its team. Challenges (blue) count for the first team, Interventions (red) for the second.
| Field | Points |
|---|---|
| Claimed (one card) | 1 for its team |
| Contested (two cards) | 1 for each team |
| Unclaimed | 0 |
| Both fields of a buzzword held by one team (locked in) | 2 each: 4 instead of 2 |
Add up, apply the multipliers, and the higher total wins. The game can end when every field is decided or when time is up.
Audience-generated cards
Voting and responding are two ways to peerticipate. Audience members can also write a prompt card during play and hand it to the facilitator, who gives it to a team or a player, puts it on top of a draw deck or shuffles it in. Online, the same works through the chat. If it is played, the card is credited to whoever wrote it.
Credits and shout-outs
Cards are made by people, and playing one is a way of citing them. In Play, whenever a card is shown at full size, in a performance or when the wheel lands on a wildcard, its credits sit under it: who wrote the prompt, or whose words it quotes, who made the picture and under which licence, and for a community card the call it came from. Elsewhere the cards stay compact. In the log, Show the cards opens the cards of a move with their credits, and clicking a played field opens everything played on it, so anyone at the table can look at the art and see who is behind it. It is a small shout-out each time a card is used, the same credit the archive keeps, and it carries into the highlights at the end of the game.
The soft landing
Close with a short reflection. Optional elements, none of which change the official score:
- Peerticipant totals. The audience gives each side a score from 0 to 10 for how much it expanded their understanding or surprised them.
- Luck factor. A joke die roll to acknowledge chance.
- Narrative awards. Best storyteller, most unexpected move, crowd favourite.
When a game ends in Play, it does more than name a winner. It reads the moves for each side's average audience score, for how the dice treated each team against the scores the audience gave, and for how long the moves took. It lists the best-rated moves, and gives a few rewards to players whatever their team: Crowd favourite for the highest average from the audience, Most said in the least time, Dice on their side, Hard luck, and Voice of the room for whoever commented most. They comment on how the game went and do not change the score. Time is described, not graded: neither spending more of it nor less is treated as better.
Variations
The standard game is two opposed teams, six to eight fields, a first team that opens, and a hand of challenges for one side and interventions for the other. Almost every part of it can be bent to suit a room. Some changes are options you tick in Play, some are ways of staging a session, and two of them change who is at the table. Change one thing at a time, and write down how it went: every recorded game helps the next person who tries it.
What you can change in Play
These are on the New game screen in Play. They stack, and none of them changes how a move is scored.
| Option | What it does | Good for |
|---|---|---|
| Board size | 4, 6, 8 or 12 fields, within what the edition's decks can fill | The length of the game. See Board size and duration |
| Team size | 1v1, 2v2, 3v3, or any size from 1 to 8 | Duels and small rooms, or a big table with room for everyone |
| Starting cards, shared cards, draws | How big the hands are, how many cards a team holds together, and how fast hands refill. Draws can run on for as long as the deck lasts | More shared cards give a team something to decide on together. Constant drawing suits long games |
| Random deal, or players choose | Players pick their own starting cards from their team's deck, or take what they are dealt | Choosing for players who know the deck. Random for speed |
| Open or closed hands | Teammates see each other's cards, or nobody does | Open for public events and newcomers. Closed for tension |
| Tokens need a shared card | A Trojan Horse or Co-optation token is spent together with a shared card, and only that card is used | Making shared cards worth keeping |
| Endless supply | Hands refill after every card, and a deck that runs out is shuffled together again from its own discards | Long games, small decks, or a game where running out of cards would spoil it |
| The audience picks each new card | Instead of a random draw, three cards are shown at the start of the team's next turn and the audience chooses which one the player gets | Giving the audience a hand in the game, and a reason to follow the cards |
| A clock for each team | One clock for the whole game for each team, instead of a limit on each move. Wildcards that give or take time move the clock | Letting a group breathe while it minds its own time. See Variation: team clocks |
| Who opens the first round | The first team (standard), a coin flip, or by power in the world | Teams with no established order between them. See below |
| Mixed hands | Each team gets half of the challenges and half of the interventions | Two teams of one ideology. See below |
| Mirror | Documents a game played somewhere else, with nothing dealt | A record for the archive |
The optional extras of the soft landing are played at the table. Play does not keep them.
Who opens: a coin or the power in the world
In the standard game the first team opens because, in real life, the existing order frames the terms first. That works when one team stands for that order. When neither does, as with two factions of one movement, someone still has to open, and there are two fair ways to choose.
A coin flip suits two sides of about the same strength, or a table that would rather not say which is stronger.
By power is for sides that are not equal and where it would be dishonest to pretend so. Ask the room to give each position a score from 0 to 6 for how much weight it carries today, outside the game, in the place or movement where you are playing, and take the average of each, as you do for a move. Then:
- Equal scores are a coin flip.
- Each point by which a team is ahead gives it one more chance in twelve of opening. Four against three is 7 chances in 12. Five against two is 9 in 12, three in four.
- A gap of six is certain: the stronger team opens.
Play does the roll when you choose By power and enter the two scores. At a table, roll a twelve-sided die, or a six-sided die and a coin (heads is 1 to 6, tails adds six). The weaker team still opens now and then, so the game does not feel settled in advance, and the stronger one frames the terms more often, as it does outside the room. From the second round on, the team that opened the first round keeps opening until the other leads by one point (it opens on a roll of 6), two (a 50:50 roll) or three (it opens).
Two teams of one ideology
Some of the most useful arguments happen between people who want the same thing and disagree about the road: two readings of degrowth, municipalists and platform co-ops, reform and rupture, or a question on which a movement is divided, such as the status of Taiwan. The game can hold that. The two teams are not enemies, and the table does not need a villain. It uses the same board, the same decks, the same wheel and the same scoring.
Setting it up:
- Name the teams after the two positions, and write one plain sentence for each, for example Reform (change it from inside, step by step) and Rupture (break with it and build another way). Make an edition with those two names in the edition builder. Each team holds its own line in every move, even if some of its players lean the other way.
- Mix the hands. In the opposed game the first team plays challenges, which name what blocks the way, and the second plays interventions, which name what to do about it. Here neither team owns a kind of card. Each gets half of the challenges and half of the interventions, shuffled together, with no card in both teams. Tick Mixed hands in Play. At a table, split each deck in two at random and give each team one half of each.
- Decide who opens. There is no existing order to give the first move to, so use a coin flip or the power in the world.
- Play the move as usual: choose a card and a field, perform, the audience scores, a die. What the card does is now for the player to say. Playing a challenge means: this is what stands in the way, and it is what my line is built to deal with. Playing an intervention means: this is what to do, and it is what my line proposes. Either way, the move works best when it shows why this road is worth taking, and not only why the other is wrong.
- Setting the ground and responding work as before. A team that lands a move claims the field and has set the ground: the other team has to answer in the same field, inside the frame the first one drew. The answer is where the disagreement shows. It can meet a challenge with its own reading of the problem (it is not that, it is this) or with what it would do about it, and it can meet an intervention with an alternative or with a challenge (it will not hold, because). If both moves land, the lightning round asks the audience which road convinces them more, and a 50:50 leaves the field contested, which in a movement is often the honest result.
- Wildcards play as usual. The scenario wildcards come with two outcomes written for opposed teams. Leave them out of the deck, or read the two outcomes as the established way and its challenger, and let the table decide which team gets which.
- Close the soft landing with a question for the room: what would you take from each road? The winner is the road the room moved toward, which does not make the other wrong.
It asks a little more of the facilitator, because friends can argue in a way opponents do not. Keep the failure stories kind and specific, and let the audience, not the facilitator, say which road it prefers.
Players who are not commonists at heart
The teams are positions, not identities. The game works best when people who do not already live by the commons are at the table: liberals, social democrats, greens, trade unionists, civil servants, entrepreneurs, people from other traditions of the left. They argue the case they are given, or their own, and their objections are real ones. The commons answers are stronger for having met them. You do not need to agree with the commons to play, and nobody is there to be converted.
What helps a guest:
- Say what the game is before it starts, in a minute: two teams, short moves from cards, an audience that scores them, a die. Nobody has to change their mind, and every move is a performance, so a player who says something they do not believe is playing a part.
- Use plain words. Say what the commons are (what a community looks after together, with its own rules), what enclosure means, and what peerticipation means, the first time each comes up. Keep a short glossary on the table. Skip the jargon that only insiders enjoy.
- Let guests choose a side, or play the one they would not choose. In a second game, swap.
- Pair guests with players who know the game on their team, and give them the clearest cards.
- Invite guests to write cards from what they know. The best of them can join the archive, credited.
Being friendly does not make the game neutral. The board, the cards and the question are about the commons: what they are, who they serve, who captures them. Guests are invited to test that, and the game does not water it down to be agreeable. A room that can disagree this openly and stay civil is itself part of what the game shows, including to other parts of the left.
Still to be worked out
- The political right at the table. The game is mostly played among people on the left. Whether and when to invite people from the right, with what safeguards and with whom to talk it through first, has not been settled. Until it is, such a game needs the agreement of the curators and a facilitator used to heated rooms.
- Editions built for two factions, with decks written for them, and wildcards and scenarios that do not assume an opposed pair.
- Letting the audience enter the power scores in Play directly, instead of the facilitator typing the average.
Facilitating
The facilitator is not a referee. They are a conductor of collective attention: part moderator, part hype-person, part philosopher. They:
- keep the tempo with a visible timer, and say when a move reaches the limit, but let it run if it is getting good. Do not cut a move off at the moment it gets heated;
- make sure the story connects to the card;
- ask for the failure story after every failed move, from the commentators or the audience;
- announce results and keep a visible record of the board;
- step in gently when the rules are unclear or the energy drops;
- notice when scores are split and invite someone to say why;
- check that the mirror has what they need, and that anyone being recorded has agreed;
- press Start session on Play when the game begins and Stop session at the end, if the table is timed this way, so every move gets its time.
Cheat sheet
- Teams and players chosen. Player 1 for each team named.
- Board built. Fields picked. Duration agreed.
- Decks ready. Cards dealt. Shared cards face up.
- First team opens (or the team the coin or the power roll picked), with the player whose round it is (Player 1, then 2, then 3). Decision (about 30) → Move (up to 2 minutes, a reference) → Vote (about 30) → Roll.
- Success claims the field and forces a response there. Failure discards the card, opens the board, and someone tells why it failed.
- Two successes: a lightning round (about a minute), then the audience decides.
- After every round: spin the wheel.
- Count the board. Both fields of a locked-in buzzword score 2 each. Close with a reflection.
- The mirror sends the game in.
- Someone stuck and without a first word? Play has "Stuck? Things you can say": four steps that fit any card and a few openers for each side. Fill the gaps with anything, even a guess.
Documenting the session
Every session should have a mirror: someone who documents it as it happens, or from the recording afterwards. A good record captures the scores, the dice, the time each move took and when it happened, the failure stories, the contextual notes and performance fragments, and the recordings. At the table, the mirror uses Play as above, with the session clock started, and the draft can be fixed in the review editor. Good documentation is what lets other people cite, replay and learn from what happened, and it is how a game becomes an edition in the archive.