Knowledge commons

The funding model and the Game Commons Peer Production License

How artists get paid, where the rest of the money goes, who decides, and the terms everything shared here falls under.

The Game Commons is built on a simple wager: people will give time, thought, performance and artistic work if they are recognised as part of a commons, and not as owners of scarce assets. The money therefore does not produce dividends. It produces capacity. Value goes back into the commons to keep it going.

Where money comes from

  • Open patronage of card artworks: supporters pay for new artwork to be released to everyone, or give to a card that carries an existing artwork.
  • Commissioned editions made for research programmes, activist networks or municipalities. The institution funds the work, and unless a contract says otherwise the materials return to the commons.
  • Print editions, including book and game bundles, sold through bookshops and museum shops. The game stays free to print yourself.
  • A numbered founding run of the printed game. Production starts when 101 orders are in, and what is left after the cost of making it gives the commons its first seed money.
  • Event licensing and hosting for larger formats that need facilitation and documentation.
  • Donations and crowdfunds to the pool, for people who want to support the infrastructure without attaching their money to one card. Each monthly session also ends with a collection for the pool, passed round like a hat at a festival.

Three kinds of artwork, three ways money moves

A card's artwork reaches it in one of three ways, and each moves money differently.

  • Free to use and print. Public domain, CC0, CC BY and other open terms. Nobody is owed anything, and what people give to such a card goes to the platform and the commons pool.
  • An existing work that is not free, put on an existing prompt with the artist's agreement. The artist can claim a share of what people give to the card, from 1% to 50%, or name the initiative behind the work to receive it. The rest is split evenly between keeping the platform running and the commons pool. An artist who claims 1% turns the card into a fundraiser for the commons, and one who asks for more can still take at most half. This is where supporters with money to spare can give to the commons without choosing a project.
  • New work, by a community member or a commissioned artist, put up for open patronage. Up to the artist's goal it is split 80/10/10, and beyond it follows the rule below. This is where most of the money reaches the artist, so it is where people who want to pay artists can start, including funding new artwork for cards that have only a free or borrowed one.

Open patronage, step by step

  1. An artist makes an artwork for a card and names a rate. That is the goal. It says what it pays for, for example two weeks of studio time. The rate follows the work and what it is for: a photograph may ask for less than a digital render, but does not have to.
  2. Supporters give any amount, in BREAD or euros by card or bank. In this prototype one BREAD is one euro and every figure is simulated.
  3. Money is held until the goal is reached. If it is not reached within 60 days it is returned, or the supporter can move it to another artwork.
  4. When the goal is reached the card and artwork are released under the license below and join the official community gallery of cards, free for everyone and ready to go into decks. Supporters are credited on the card page. They do not own anything.

Up to the goal

Every payment is split:

Share Goes to
80% the artist, until the goal is met
10% the platform, to keep it running
10% the Game Commons pool

Beyond the goal

Support does not have to stop when the artist is paid. A card people care about can keep attracting support, and that support should go somewhere useful. Beyond the goal:

  • The artist chooses their share, between 1% and 50%. They set it when they list the artwork, so supporters know what they are giving to.
  • The remainder is split evenly between the platform and the pool.

By default the share is exactly a third, so beyond the goal every 30 BREAD splits into 10 for the artist, 10 for the platform and 10 for the pool. With a share of 30% instead, ten BREAD would be three to the artist and three and a half each to the platform and the pool. Support beyond the goal is capped at 20% of the rate, like a tip: on a rate of 360 BREAD, up to 72 BREAD more can come in. After that the artwork is fully supported. A payment that crosses the goal is split in two parts: the portion that finishes the goal at 80/10/10, and the rest at the artist's chosen share.

This is a bounded reward and uncapped contribution. The artist's first payment is a fair wage for the work. Past that point, giving shifts from buying an asset to feeding a public good. It stops a card from turning into a speculative collectible, and it stops the commons from relying on a few heavily supported artworks, because what is left over funds the next commissions. The upper bound of 50% keeps an open release from becoming a sales channel. The lower bound, 1%, means the artist has no obligation to take anything.

What the platform share is for

The platform's share pays for maintenance. The platform bears the fees of card and bank payments out of its own share, so what an artist is promised arrives in full. The share is public, and what it is spent on is published.

A branch can crowdfund itself

Open patronage can also fund a branch of the game instead of a new commission. This is only for true branches: at least half of the minimum set of cards for the edition's board must be new, not from the archive. Only challenges and interventions count, and wildcards do not. A board needs two challenges and two interventions per field, so a six-field board needs 12 and 12, and a true branch has at least 12 of those 24 cards new. This is the same rule that makes an edition a branch on the tree. Fields can be the same or new and do not count.

By default what is given to a branch's cards is split in thirds:

  • A third goes to the branch fund. The branch's stewards ask for it and can choose any share from 1% to 50%.
  • A third goes to the platform, for open maintenance and development.
  • A third goes to the Game Commons pool, which pays for community projects, initiatives and events. A proposal from a creator or a curator counts for no more than any other.

An artist, or the initiative behind a picture, can claim a share of their own from the same whole, from 1% to 50%. So the share of a photograph can go to the initiative it shows and not to the photographer. The platform and the pool always keep at least 20% between them. The same split is meant to apply to sales of the branch's cards, printed or digital, once the shop sells them.

The first case is the Radical vs. Liberal Abundance Edition. Keir Milburn and Bertie Russell are the co-stewards of its branch. They receive its fund and work out how to pass it on: they register initiatives on the platform and pay them from the fund, with the accounts public. Initiatives could be local playthroughs, sessions with local green parties, printed sets, translations or an open record of what was learned. Other people can give to those initiatives directly too, and each can be listed in the Game Commons pool as an example of what to support. The ask on each of the edition's cards is the co-stewards' ask for the fund. Like an artist's rate, it follows the cause: a photograph may ask for less than a rendered illustration, but it does not have to. For Radical Abundance the hope is work that helps local green parties, whom the Abundance team is helping to write programmes on a social-ecological commons transition and on public-common partnerships. See the proposals.

What maintenance covers

Maintenance is everything that keeps the commons running, so that the game can be played, documented and shared. It is more than servers. The platform's share pays for the always-on costs first. The pool tops it up and pays for the rest by proposal.

  • Technical care. Hosting, backups, security, bug fixing, upgrades, accessibility, interface translation, payment fees, and publishing the code so that anyone can host a copy. Done by developers and system administrators.
  • Moderation and care. Reviewing submitted cards, artworks, releases and recordings, consent and withdrawal requests, corrections to credit, the moderation log, the safety of people who appear in recordings. Done by moderators.
  • Documentation and the archive. Transcripts, timestamps, captions, metadata, edition records, review of machine-made output, and keeping the archive readable for the long term. Done by documenters and archivers.
  • Official sessions. The recurring anchor editions, such as the monthly online battle: the curators' work, facilitation (a facilitator who is also the master of ceremonies), commentators who interpret the moves and are called on especially after failures, a technical host and stream, players' fees where they are needed, captioning or interpretation, a documenter, and the commissioned researcher and artist of the month. The facilitator and the commentators are part of the curation and are paid too, at a working rate of 240 euros per session for a facilitator and 150 for a commentator, a little less than the researcher (300) and the artist (360). Done by curators, facilitators, commentators, players, hosts, researchers and artists.
  • Stewardship and administration. Accounting and public reports, legal review of the license, insurance if needed, coordination, onboarding, community calls.
  • Translation and localisation. Keeping the interface, manuals and core decks available in more languages, and paying the translators who keep them current.

First steps, next, and stretch goals

First steps are what must exist before the shared platform can open and the first official session can run: a hosted and backed-up shared server with accounts; moderators and a review queue; real payments with the goal-and-return rule and a public ledger; the first official session, funded or not; documentation of the first sessions reviewed by a person; a lawyer's review of the license.

Next is what makes the commons usable by others: receiving sessions sent in by mirrors and building them into editions, votes counted across everyone and not one browser, applications to curate, to play and to ask the pool for a session, an AI label and a reviewed status for machine output, local tools tried on real recordings, more languages, and team clocks once tried at a table.

Stretch goals are ideas and not promises: other game commons hubs under the same license that exchange cards, artworks and editions with this one; self-hosted copies that can sync; a live scoring screen for audiences at physical events; print-ready decks and boards on demand; accessible versions with screen reader, audio description and sign language; a low-energy public ledger of credits and releases; and seed funding for sister games that follow the same principles. The Maintenance tab of the Commons pool keeps the same lists.

The creator's share

I ask 20,000 BREAD as the creator, a small portion of the Game Commons fund. It acknowledges the thousands of hours I put into this project myself, and sticking by it for eight years in predatory conditions, holding on to the promises of games. It is my first game, and all my games since apply these commons principles. (Rok Kranjc)

Once it is paid, that is all: no further claim for the work done until then, and the whole fund goes to maintenance as such, and not to back pay. The stewardship group sets when it is paid and publishes it. The amount paid so far is on the Maintenance tab of the Commons pool.

The Game Commons pool

All of the pool's income pays for shared capacity:

  • the platform: maintenance, technical upgrades;
  • documentation and moderation work;
  • monthly commissions of one researcher, who writes several prompts, and one artist, who draws the prompt the community chooses, per session;
  • translation and localisation;
  • seed funding for community-led editions;
  • research-based deck development;
  • in some contexts, fees for players, facilitators and commentators.

The pool can also seed other games that follow similar principles, so the model can travel.

Other sessions can use the pool too

The pool is not only for the official monthly session. That is partly the point. Any session can ask it for support: a community edition, a seminar, an assembly, a festival, a school. A request says what the session is, who is involved and what it needs, such as a facilitator, captioning, a translator, a player's fee, a venue or printing. In return the session is documented in the archive with an edition record, and what it makes is shared under the license. Part of the pool is kept for first-time hosts and for places and communities the archive does not yet reach.

Who decides

The commons decides how the pool is used, gradually. At the beginning a small stewardship group does, and publishes what it spends. As the membership grows, more of the allocation moves to proposals the community votes on. Influence is tied to participation in many forms, such as playing, judging, documenting, translating, hosting and curating, and not to how much someone has paid. See the Commons pool for the prototype.

Safeguards

  • A rotating commissioning pool reserves part of the money for first-time contributors, under-represented places and community-built decks.
  • Soft contribution caps. Prolific creators publish freely. Funded commissions prioritise newcomers once someone has received a set amount.
  • Participation-weighted influence, so collectors do not dominate.
  • Remixability. Cards stay forkable. Visual reinterpretations, translations and annotations stay open. A creator cannot lock a prompt.
  • Support gives no veto over meaning. At most it opens a place in the conversation about that card's future.

The Game Commons Peer Production License

Everything in the commons is shared under one license. It is the social contract of the ecosystem and it works with the platform, which holds the metadata and the archive. The license has four purposes:

  1. Attribution. Every role is credited: performers, jurors, authors, researchers, artists, translators, curators, organisers, documenters, moderators and supporters, wherever the material ends up.
  2. Remixing and forking. You can reuse, adapt and recombine cards, fields, artworks and editions. Reuse is recognised as authorship.
  3. Return to the commons. What you make from commons materials, you share back under the same terms, so that the commons keeps growing.
  4. No enclosure. Nobody can take something from the commons and lock it away. Supporting an artwork never turns it into private property.

Where money enters, the license ties it to the same logic. Compensation is a part of contributing. It is not a reason to enclose what was contributed. NFTs and ledgers are not banned and are not a way to enclose anything: they may record a release, a credit or a proof of support, never exclusivity, scarcity or access.

In practice this means:

  • Providing credit is automatic. Cards, fields, artworks, editions and recordings keep their author, source and lineage, and a card shows where it came from. Each edition has a record of everyone involved, filled in by its organisers or archivers.
  • Parallel galleries. Variants, translations and local editions sit next to the original and are linked, so people using the same material in different places can find each other.
  • A card can be a variation of another, and the link is recorded.
  • Other games can interoperate. The terms are meant to work with other analogue and digital games, not only this one.
  • People who appear in a recording agree to it, and a group can keep sensitive material within itself.
  • Commercial use is free for non-commercial use, co-ops and non-profits. Other commercial users pay a share of their revenue into the pool.
  • AI. Nothing in the commons is used to train AI without its contributor's opt-in, and recordings, voices and likenesses never. AI-made artwork and AI-assisted prompts are labelled. Machine help with transcripts and timestamps is welcome when it runs locally and a person reviews it.

This is a plain-language summary. The working draft of the terms goes into the roles, people in recordings, ledgers and NFTs in detail. It is written for a lawyer to turn into a license, and is not yet in force.

What a supporter gets

Support is not a purchase of the artwork, which is free for everyone once released. It still has to give something back, so a supporter, with any amount, gets:

  • A supporter's copy of the card. A special version of the card with a supporter's badge in the corner, saved in their own gallery. It goes into their decks and into games with friends. If they order the printed card, the same badge is printed on it. It is a credit and a keepsake, not a scarce object: the card itself is free for everybody once the goal is reached.
  • Their name among the supporters on the card page, if they choose.
  • A discount on printed sets, from 5% for any amount, then 10%, 15% and up to 20% the more they give. A code carries it to the shop.
  • A better commons. Part of every sale of the game goes to the pool, so supporting an artwork and buying a copy both feed the same place.

Players can bring their decks to a table: in Play, a friend's backup or share file can be loaded, and their cards, decks and editions join the game.

Buying the game

You can always print the game yourself. For those who want a made copy, the shop offers the print-and-play files (free, pay what you like), a card edition, a modular edition with the laser-cut board, a pick and mix set made from the cards you saved, and an organisation edition, priced higher because individuals should not subsidise institutions. In the shop your saved cards become a list: start your set with them, or expand the one you have, with your supporter discount applied.

Where the money goes from a sale is stated beside the price. The cost to make and send it and the payment fee come first. What is left is split evenly between the platform and the commons pool, the same rule as support beyond the goal. A discount comes out of that remainder, never out of the cost of making the game, and the tiers are set so that a sale never falls below its cost. The prices and costs on the site are working figures until real quotes for printing, the board and postage exist.

The founding run

The first printed run is numbered, and it starts when 101 orders are in. Saying you are interested in the shop costs nothing and is not an order: when the shared version opens we ask you to confirm, and only confirmed orders count. The cards you supported carry your supporter badge, and your name goes on the credits sheet if you want it there. The run also pays for itself. What is left after the cost of making it is split between the platform and the pool, which is how the commons gets its first seed money. The files stay free to print for everyone, and a numbered copy is something to enjoy, not a claim on anything.

Printed cards whose artwork was shared freely by an artist who needs no fee are the simplest to make. They cost what they cost to make, and the whole margin goes to the platform and the pool.

Offering existing artwork, and benefit cards

Anyone can offer an artwork that already exists as the picture for a card, their own or someone else's. If it is someone else's, we write to the artist first, and nothing of theirs is shown unless they agree. The artist chooses the terms, open to everyone or for this card only, and whether to be credited only, to claim a share of what is given to the card (from 1% to 50%, the rest going to the platform and the pool), or to keep the artwork open to everyone and sell or auction a printed card, a signed copy or the original, with the money going to the artist or to a project they name. The money from a benefit sale goes to the artist. You can offer an artwork from the patronage page.

Passing the hat

Each monthly session ends with a collection for the pool, passed round the way a hat goes round at a festival, and the total is read out. It is small, and it is a way of being at the same table.

The first illustrated edition

The current cards have provisional artwork. The first fully illustrated edition would commission original artwork for most of the cards from a group of invited artists, in sets, and print the card and modular editions. It is a campaign of our own, run here with the same tools, and it opens only after real quotes are in, so the working budget can be published first. We borrowed what is useful from an earlier plan for a conventional crowdfunding page and left the rest. What we kept:

  • Artists are commissioned in sets, with a fair fee, not asked to compete. Nobody votes on which artist gets work.
  • Money past the goal pays the artists more first, before anything else. No stretch goals made of trinkets.
  • Support never buys a say. No pledge, however large, buys a vote, an editorial veto or a place in the governance. Patrons of a future expansion support its development and are credited, and decide nothing about what it says.
  • Different capacities pay different amounts. The free files are for everyone, the physical editions are priced near their cost, supporters give more, and institutions pay more.
  • The budget is public, including the labour of the people coordinating it, before the campaign and again after the edition has shipped.
  • What is promised is small and exact. The edition, the artwork, the open files and a working archive. The rest of the commons is built only if people use it.

What is not built yet

The money on this site is simulated, no one is paid, and BREAD is a stand-in. Payments, a real treasury, accounts and moderators arrive with the shared server. The design above is what they will implement.