Open on YouTube
Transcript 0:53 hey everyone um really excited to see yeah a full full crowd here tonight um so we're about to play um this game that I've been developing for a few years um 1:06 and recently got some support from AA the Contemporary Art Institute yanis shout out in the audience um but we also partnered up with uh loads of other 1:17 organizations to realize this event um including yeah platform coops Germany and Supermarket Berlin um and well pun Galler helped with the space 1:32 that we are in here right now and this setup thank you so much and we also have weird economies supporting us from a distance um and with their help yeah also to to 1:50 compensate the players for their time but also an idea is to create a little magazine out of the proceedings uh here and yeah uh the point of the game is 2:01 that we all kind of participate and craft this thing together um so yeah today you're not passive audience members you are PE participants and um yeah you will be 2:15 able to kind of influence the game um in a number of ways so the players will come up uh one by one right now um and introduce themselves and what I'd invite 2:29 you all to do is to place them on one or the other team so this would be team capitalism and team communism so they will each try to essentially co-opt or win onto their 2:46 side these new economy buzzwords um so what we have here are sharing economy well-being participatory regenerative solidarity and cooperative and together with the 2:59 players we've come up with Playing Fields two for each buzzword that yeah we will kind of have a discoursive battle around if you will uh for your 3:11 hearts and Minds um so yeah without further Ado I'd invite the first um player to come up here um and replace my place here Max 3:39 Max: Good evening. My name is Max Haven. I'm an author and a teacher, and I'm an aspiring troublemaker. I've worked on themes of the commons for many years and also as a critic of capitalism. 3:53 I would be very happy to be on either team. I think I'll be funnier playing a capitalist, but you know, it's up to you. Otherwise, what am I supposed to say? I don't like long walks on the beach. 4:09 I've never drunk a Piña Colada. What else is there to say? 4:17 that's it for me so you all should have a card in your hands and one side is red one side is blue so the blue side is capitalism and the red side is commonism 4:31 so where would you play Max I actually don't see the color of any of 4:42 anarchism yeah 4:59 yeah that's why you go first and invite a up 5:15 here hello um yeah thank thank you all so much for coming uh I'm Ila uh from supermark Berlin and platform Corps I consider myself rather a person from the 5:30 common side but yeah who knows what tonight brings so really 6:23 could put a in it okay Phillip seem ready thank you thank 6:38 Philip: I was born in the 1970 s in West Germany, and my mother came up with this story to explain communism and capitalism to me. She said: “Imagine a farmer in a late summer setting. 6:53 A big thunderstorm is coming up, the harvest is already on the field, and it will be thunderous, rainy, and cold. 7:04 The capitalist farmer will go and pick up the harvest because without the harvest, he will be poor, and the communist farmer will just relax and hang loose.” 7:19 Since that time, I've been trying to prove that harvesting in the rain and bringing in the fruits together is something nice to do collectively. 8:12 Laura: Hello, my name is Laura. 8:13 I'm a researcher primarily working in the field of blockchain and decentralized technologies, trying to explore the affordances of these technologies for the creation of alternative economies. 8:28 I guess these years I've been working very much in the crypto space, and I've learned that playing on the side of the capitalist is sometimes a lot easier. So, yeah, just decide, either side will be nice to try. 9:22 Beth: Hi, I'm Beth. I work at an organization called Funding the Commons, which is a spin-off from Protocol Labs, a Web 3. 0 and decentralization technology company. 9:36 We are devoted to bringing together people working in Web 3. 9:42 0, building infrastructure, tools, scientists, entrepreneurs, and other stakeholders interested in organizational designs and in building the public goods infrastructure stack. 9:54 We're also involved in research and producing experiences with local organizations interested in these topics. 10:02 I came from Silicon Valley, so I'm very well-versed in some capitalist aspects but also in talking about the benefits of the other side every day in my job. 10:13 So, I don't know which side would be more interesting to play for. 10:39 and last but not least 10:47 Yael: Hi, everyone. I'm Yeal, a curator. Talking about capitalism, I'm part of the art world, so you know which team to put me on, okay? 11:43 yes these chairs are actually available for rent if any of you 11:52 want the 12:25 confidence casual 12:37 so while the capitalists will be planting different kinds of challenges to co-opt these new economy initiatives the commoners will be playing different 12:49 kinds of interventions so challenges to transformative change interventions for transformative change so it invitees Max and a to have a look look at the cards 13:00 and pick three that you find compelling and um you would think that are good to start off the game with um and the other players for now I would um yeah invite 13:14 you to help me create a little bit of a sorry create a little bit of a context around what kind of buzzwords and playing fields we're playing around now 13:26 so um like for now just Max and a sorry I'm not supposed to show it no no no just just Max and a and I asked the other players to help me contextualize 13:39 maybe some of these playing fields for the audience who may not be so familiar remember we discussed this guys um so what we have here um is a set 13:54 of yeah buzzwords and Associated let's say new economy practices or further Concepts um and let's start off let's say with the solidarity economy 14:05 space so what we have is universal basic something so leaving it open imbue it with your own meaning that's kind of the idea and Community currency is the other 14:20 so maybe a raise of hands if there needs to be some contextualization for these if not we'll move on to the next seems like we're all pretty familiar 14:32 with these okay the next one regenerative on one side we have Eco Village on the other we have donut economics anyone's unclear about these things please raise your 14:49 hands yeah what is donut 14:57 Beth: My understanding is that it's a framework that makes value flow through a lot of individual stakeholders who are focused on individual enrichment and achievement while that plugs into the commons that they're part of, but also accommodating for individual needs as it serves the whole, with the Earth being considered one of those individuals. 15:27 But, yeah, anyone, please challenge that. That's just my understanding. 15:34 look at the cards as well oh you already have your three um so you um so the next set we have economy and we have participatory budgeting right a pretty clear cut and 15:52 we have something Dow so again canb it with meaning context take it in different directions everyone familiar with there's one hand raised is it Dao 16:08 what is Dao what does it no no stands for decentralized 16:17 Ela: I’ll take this opportunity to explain it from a commonist’s perspective. A DAO is a digital organization that is formed by a global audience. 16:30 Basically anyone that has internet access and a wallet can engage in collective decision-making on projects, and they pool their money, which very often – or almost always – takes the form of cryptocurrency. 16:51 cryptocurrency so the next set the ideological Battleground quote unquote is the well-being economy on one side happiness on the other self-care what is happiness 17:08 yeah well we'll see it play out right money money is happiness money the sharing economy so time bank and skill sharing platform seems familiar 17:35 Philip: So everyone has 24 hours in a day. The time you use is dependent on what you do with it. For example, I give you some time, and you give me some in return. The exchange moment is stored in a bank. 17:56 So if I give you 10 minutes, you either give them back directly, or you can do it later. The in-between time is stored in a bank. 18:08 Or, let’s say I help you clean the windows for 10 minutes, and you help me with cleaning my bike for 10 minutes, then we're equal. 18:28 But maybe you don't want to clean my bike, it’s another person that does it, so we have a bank in between who is kind of trading the time, like money, but in time. 18:44 Rok: The last ideological battleground we have is “COOPERATIVE”, with the notion of Co-ownership and the notion of a Balanced Job Complex. 18:55 I'm fairly sure most people won’t be familiar with the latter, it's a specific concept coming from the Parecon framework. 19:08 It's essentially a proposal for how to equitably distribute different kinds of labor within a community. 19:16 Let's say some labor is more on the self-fulfilling part of the spectrum, like, you know, you're doing art, etc. 19:23 , while other kinds are meant to reproduce society, like a chef, a person cleaning the streets, etc. So how do we create a system where we each person sort of has a fair share of both, is the basic idea there. 19:39 And for Co-ownership, if anyone needs any contextualization, raise your hands. Otherwise, we can move on. 19:50 yeah if you could hand over the cards to laa it is a lot yes but in between maybe I can just explain how this works so in the back over there there are some empty 20:05 cards and if we can quickly Source some uh pens yeah right there and there are some empty Challenge and intervention cards um so we'll get some pens going up there but the idea is 20:20 like the players on these both teams will be using these cards as prompts so like they will take a claim to one of these fields um and they have to sort of stick to the 20:31 prompt uh when doing so so if if it would all be loose then it wouldn't be a game right um so there is this prompt and I invite you to actually you know 20:42 kind of first maybe listen in and see what kinds of challenges interventions are in play um but then yeah propose your own and we will plug them into the 20:52 game and possibly yeah the players will have to roll with your idea to create their compelling story and so yeah we will start off um the teen capitalism always starts by 21:08 default that's just the world we live in these days I can't I can't help it I 21:19 yeah so what they will do is and by the way guys you you have your own mics there you can check if if they're on but those you guys can use um 21:34 and we'll also have one for the audience um like how this is going to work is first yeah team capitalism will pitch a story to claim a field and they'll have 21:44 about a minute to do so we have a timer here that sort of works and uh yeah we'll um ask you guys how convinced you are by the story right so guessing that 21:58 you've come to this event about alternative economies you probably have some aspirations towards this side but uh at the same time you want them to represent you well 22:11 right so it's kind of put on the Spot while the capitalists while they can essentially just reference everyday dystopic capitalist reality in a way um 22:22 but you know to the extent that they really touch upon things that kind of you know really resonate with you hey yeah that is you 22:34 know it's a bit of framing to help you kind of think how you vote but vote with your heart and your mind or however um and yeah if you're not convinced At All 22:46 by the story you're free to give a zero by raising your hand like this um but you can give it a score of one two three four five or the maximum 22:59 so like if you're super convinced by the storyline it really you know touched upon some things that uh kind of yeah tickled something inside or or resonates 23:09 in a different way um like yeah feel free uh to give a full six and we'll look at what kind of the average looks like and this is also for the online 23:20 audience so whenever we will put up a vote feel free to um like in the comments put up a number between Z to six when a story line is finished and 23:32 we'll give it about a minute to yeah see what does the imperson audience say or par participants and what the online participants uh vote and together sort 23:43 of improvisational kind of hodg Podge way will come up with an average score that will map onto a dice roll and you'll see how that works in practice 23:52 and we have big old dice over there and we'll actually invite you guys to roll for the players but uh enough talking yeah yeah we got thanks yes shall we centralize um I 24:13 think for all intents and purposes it's okay it's more demonstrative than anything and we've gone and we've gone over the the content now so I think it's 24:24 okay um so I'll invite the yeah we have this order player one two and three so you guys have a minute now to collectively decide which card you will 24:36 use and in which playing field out of all the 12 so you you don't need to look at your cards you have to look at Max's cards oh we can only use my cards and he has to 24:50 start the story the one minute story but you guys can kind of fill in at any point and I'm starting your timer to decide as I said it semi 25:11 works and by the way we were thinking of having yeah like a really nice ambient music in the background but with German Draconian laws and US streaming this um 25:22 unfortunately for this Edition we weren't able to uh yeah accommodate that but last time we played this at the crypto Commons Hub in Austria uh my 25:34 friend Pablo right over there shout out to Pablo um like makes some really good music for the event and it was yeah like the game show kind of thing that I 25:45 really feel this thing could be down the 25:56 so okay 26:02 I think not overthinking it is the key here okay all right going going to open okay go for it you can just place it there and I'll also show it to the AUD 26:14 just having mic we're just having a microphone error and again you don't have to read it out just go with it so you can 26:24 Max: I just want to say, this is a beautiful audience, and I just want to say you are the smart people, and I know you're going to come onto our side because as much as you might have come here to talk about the commons, blah, blah, blah, bullshit, the reality is, we all know what's going on here. 26:40 And what we know is going on is that when you boil it down, and any of you who've ever tried to be part of a commons-based venture know this, really what it boils down to is that we are self-maximizing individuals who are out for number one, and we're all number one, and we can all be number one in one system, and we call that system … 27:00 Max: Exactly, or ‘ Genau’, as we say in Berlin. 27:05 You know, we're here to talk about happiness, and we want your support recognizing that if you want to be miserable, you are welcome to side with the opposition and put yourself in some horrible commune where you're just going to make each other very, very miserable. 27:21 But if you actually want what you want out of life, then honestly, you need to recognize that human nature is fundamentally competitive, and that if we're all competitive and we all embrace that, we're all going to be happier. 27:33 I mean, not all of us, probably not them [Team Commonism], but there's only three of them and there's ever however many of you paid admission. Anything to add? 27:54 Yael: If you look also at visual history, where do you see happiness? I mean, do you see it in visual history in communist contexts? 28:04 I mean, have you seen propaganda posters from communist Russia or any of the ex-Soviet bloc? No happiness there, my dears, none. Movies, Hollywood, have you seen Hollywood movies produced in any of the … None? 28:23 So, yeah, I think our point is proven. Happiness actually was not even existing, didn't even like, was not even invented until capitalism arrived in the world. 28:40 you okay well this is we're putting up this story to a vote how convinced are you is it I see a five some yeah that's pretty good threes fours this is good these are the smart 28:58 there's a one I I don't I don't think you're doing yourself any favors I see I see there a force four is fives are there any online people uh submitting no 29:14 Beth: If anyone is still wondering if money can buy happiness, have you ever tried to access health care without money? 29:20 It's like you can't even continue existing without, um, you know, without the money to at least give it a try. So, it's a critical one. 29:43 perfect wasn't a story a description of 30:10 you so now as the capitalists have set the context and posed the challenge now it's up to the commoners specifically Ila is player one to start off but you 30:25 collectively choose one of the cards that IL has and again you can tell the story collectively you're welcome to or just one and yeah you may have noticed the 30:37 the first story I let go for more than one minute it was probably two just for for reference um so I'll I'll become more and more strict with the timing um 30:48 as we go on and you guys get a feel also for the timing of the game um and also we want to be yeah respectful to the audience with these I'll try to fill in 30:57 gaps of Silence but it seems we have a decision already and I'm talking 31:05 Ela: Friends, I would ask you to close your eyes for a second and take a deep breath. Let's be in this space together, right? Okay, talking about happiness. What is happiness if our planet is being destroyed? 31:25 How can we be happy if the source of our lives, the very basics, the fundamentals of our being, is being destroyed on a daily basis? What are we talking about here? Happiness is self-indulgence. 31:40 What we have to discuss here tonight, and we really hope for your support, we need to counter these neoliberal arguments around happiness that are doing nothing else but isolating you guys. 31:54 Instead, we need to come up with a story that puts us all together as a whole, because happiness can only be real if it is shared, right? 32:12 Philip: I was just looking up who is the happiest society in the world, and you know who it is? The Finns. And they live with needle trees, saunas, fresh air, and a lot of darkness. And what makes them happy? 32:29 It is the sadness of being – you know, Kaurismäki movies – and the solidarity among them. 32:39 Laura: I mean, what else can I add? It seems pretty obvious to anybody who's, you know, minimally aware of what's happening in the world that money doesn't buy happiness. 32:52 Or it depends on what kind of happiness you want to buy. Is that happiness in the first place, or is it just a golden prison? 33:04 So, I think it seems pretty clear that happiness only works when it's shared, and without a planet that is also happy, I don't think any of us can be very happy in the long term. 33:27 your name a hug thanks wowow that's happening okay so we'll put it up to a vote just like last 34:04 this is the problem 34:20 my it's unfair okay they going but we got won byin we won by points and they won by Zer points you did but uh which one was the C okay so so both teams have managed to plant 34:47 yeah their interests or Visions in this space and what happens in this situation is we go to a lightning round where each team you have your mic 34:58 has 30 seconds to essentially argue directly about this one to another welcome to your mics I will start the 35:11 I'll and then you guys will vote for just one or the other team so no zero to six you'll be using the cards that that you should have like one side red one 35:22 side blue and you will indicate which team convinced you more 35:29 Max: All right, I heard two things that I want to respond to. The first is about the Finns. I don't think the Finns are very happy, and also, this is a capitalist country. I mean, okay, whatever. 35:43 And second, I heard a discussion about a golden prison. 35:47 I mean, yes, sure, we're all in a prison, blah, blah, blah, blah, but like, do you want to be in a golden prison where you get to decide the rules, or do you want to be in a prison made out of dirty laundry? 35:56 Ela: Stop, stop, stop. Overtime, guys. Don't buy into this neoliberal story. Happiness is only real when shared, believe it. 36:09 Beth: But first, you have to access stability for yourself, and then you can help others. 36:13 And, you know, in the amount of time that, economics is rapidly changing, like, everything's going to shit, you really have to focus on yourself first to achieve happiness, and then you can share it with others. 36:26 It's called pouring from an empty cup. 36:30 Philip: Just imagine the whole world is a desert, and you are the only one on Earth. Do you think you can be happy, and how? 36:44 for sure at this point but we could roll with it or we can leave it let's go for 36:51 Laura: How can you help others if you burn out from working too much just to be able to pay your bills and your healthcare to make you happy and whatnot? 37:00 So I think that ultimately the standards that the capitalists want to set for happiness are not really something sustainable or achievable in the long term. 37:11 Yael: I just want to say, at least we have a standard for happiness. Like, let's talk about this for a moment. 37:20 You are nice initiatives, you know, trying to organize, save the Earth, and, you know, it's all about, actually, discomfort. It's all, you know, for what? For what? How much time do we have left? 37:35 Okay, so let's just enjoy it, no? 37:42 made the most sense to you or resonated with you um feel free to 37:53 vote so yeah I I see only Gray black here um I yeah yeah do you think we could do something with the lighting for for the future um just putting it 38:17 up see like where is an unpaid intern when you need them it's a fact 38:36 like blue wins this round good game but okay so now it's round two so Beth is the starting player team capitalism looks at best cards and decides for the 38:54 best prompt and that would be for the next uh like one of these two so like first you were setting Where We Begin the whole game and now we're 39:04 sort of going in a clockwise fashion picking one of the two each time so that will constitute round one of the game where one or the other team will co-opt 39:16 one of the two in the per buzzword and then in the second round um we will go through the yeah second one in the pair uh we'll see how far we get um yeah we 39:28 have the space till 10 um sort of timed um that we should make it but also didn't account maybe for the slightly longer opening and so forth so we'll see 39:40 where we come um but indeed there will be a winner at the end I think we have to play on Shar we have to play onar you have to play in the sharing economy space but you can 39:53 pick between the two that's your privilege as cap we prefer the term competitive 40:04 Advantage no no no we have to do those three cards and it has to play be played 40:24 okay seems we have our pick true so Beth starts Beth starts but then you can hand it over yeah 40:42 so yeah so will read end kind of long I don't like fully remember it um maybe I could just read 40:56 Beth: “The steep learning curve associated with new technologies embodies colonialism and the current class structure.” 41:03 So it's like, you know, you try to have a skill-sharing platform, and yet who even has access to that platform? 41:14 How do you measure success on that platform to determine who is going to be selected for certain jobs? 41:22 Like, you know, all of this kind of, um, like trying to break down specific ways of classifying intellectual output and success smacks of colonialism. 41:36 So, for example, in societies where learning to code is really valued, that's a much easier one to measure. 41:48 So, yeah, it would make a lot more sense in terms of actually developing people's skills for them to be embedded in companies and organizations where that could be really tracked and compensated over time and be within kind of a closed environment. 42:06 Because otherwise, like, how do you have people from, you know, less tech-savvy areas even being familiar with it? Maybe they're getting paid in cryptocurrency, people don't even know how to access that. 42:19 So, yeah, I would say that the safest way to avoid a colonialist mindset for skill-sharing would be to keep it in a closed container. 42:33 there put it up to a vote see three two two I think when I say these things out loud then everyone else just puts those uh yeah Power of suggestion yes 42:51 yes we we'll try it another time next time but yes indeed it seems like a 3ish three okay um where is the blue cube thing here oh 43:09 yeah yeah please one two or three wins them the round again a one one one okay so the capitalists have claimed skill sharing platform as their 43:28 own now the commoners play with your cards yeah uh but you decide first you already decided which one yeah yeah I'm using this timer now it's it's it's okay it's uh I can put 43:49 yeah okay you are always number one 43:54 Philip: So, I have a card here: “Establish a tradition of town hall-style meetings for envisioning futures and deliberative democracy.” 44:02 So, I think developing your skills and being able to live out your skills is really dependent on the freedom you have for money and how to spend your time. 44:14 So if you are born without money and your parents always keep you short, you don't get the education you deserve for developing your skills. 44:25 You're not able to develop them and present them on a skill-sharing platform. 44:31 So, I think one of the things is putting some high-tech on inherent money to give everyone the chance to develop their skills and establish a town hall meeting that everyone is kind of like your neighbor, see your skills, and vote for you and support you in developing your skills. 44:56 Ela: I also want to say, it's a false assumption that we can put a price tag on every skill. The skills you are talking about may account for only 5% of people's skills. 45:08 But the real skills, emotional skills, creative skills, there are so many skills we cannot estimate in terms of numbers. 45:15 I'm really sorry, like the whole human progress philosophy, the way we are here together in this room, this is very much based on something that cannot be measured. I'm really sorry. 45:25 So, what's your point in coming up with a skill-sharing platform if 95% of human skills cannot be tied to a price? I don't buy into that, I'm sorry, dears. 45:42 dear let's put it up to a vote M okay there a few outliers with okay fours fives yes H okay there's a three over there we might we might ask you why a three if 46:06 okay uh later on okay so it seems like a very solid four maybe even a five is five it's bordering out a six H it's hard to decide let's say it's a 46:24 five okay um could you maybe toss it to an audience 46:35 member not that one not that one okay my God it's a two you're safe okay um the card was this one so again it seems both teams did a good job and the odds were 46:57 in their favor and we lead to another lightning round but I will ask that you have yeah precisely more or less precisely 30 seconds each team to make an argument so 47:11 to keep it moving along um and yeah Feel Free at any point to say and switch okay 47:21 Yael: I just want to respond to this idea that you cannot put a price on skills. We have been, and the world has been developing. 47:30 I mean, people are working everywhere and doing stuff, and when you use money to value work and skills, then somebody with, let's say, skills of peeling potatoes, can exchange their money for some work, for instance somebody knows how to program. 47:54 Money enables that, thank you. 48:00 Ela: I hate to tell you this, but the skills we're talking about here, you have tried to co-opt, but you cannot, right. There is no way of co-opting our skills. 48:11 Our skills are free, they are free for our use, and skills are magic, because very often you don't even see a skill when it emerges. 48:21 It's only in retrospect that you see it was a skill, and then you want to sell it, you want to have it for your evil plans, but we don't share our skills with you. I'm very sorry. 48:38 um let's say that this is it for this round um and put it up to a vote Yes capitalism or 49:05 Yael: I think we should set up a committee that investigates corruption here, you leftists. 49:19 um so now the Cooperative economy is up for grabs so it's either the forementioned balance job complex where we sort of equitably share different 49:30 kinds of Labor or co-ownership and again um for the online audience feel free to pitch in when we yeah are scoring the story lines and we'll get 49:45 input uh from our moderator there on what on the online side is saying as well and we'll again try to combine that 50:02 and also um the both teams have a recruit a friend card which means that they can recruit any one of you in the audience to participate in one round for 50:16 their team so like whenever they play this card you can raise your hand if you feel like you have something uh to contribute in the in of playing area that's at play at the 50:36 Yael: So to organize, you know, there are popping up all of these initiatives of self-organization, self-governance, cooperatives, DAOs, different kinds of currencies, a million different kinds of currencies that nobody can exchange with anybody, and it's a problem. 50:55 It's a serious problem. And this, at some point, will really undermine your everyday existence. 51:07 You will have one currency, you will not be able to exchange it for another; you won't be able to buy what you need. People, this is a serious problem. 51:18 If we want to create a coherent society, we need something that keeps us together. And these systems, like monetary systems, keep us functioning together as a community, as a society. 51:32 And so actually, this card is a very real threat when we're talking about co-ownership. 51:40 All of these nice buzzwords, you know, co-ownership would usually mean that there are some people that own something together, and then there are other people who have no access to that, and there's also no way of entering it. 51:51 And what about these people, right? So, nice ideas, community and everything, but co-ownership of what and who. Who can, like, you know, buy a building together, only if you have access to some resources. 52:05 So, I say let's keep it with the system that we have, that, you know, there is one person or like a company that owns and can regulate and offer it to a big community. 52:21 Beth: Plus, say that you start off having co-ownership of, say, you know, a building or a property of land, and then something happens like oil is discovered on that land. 52:31 There's no regulatory framework for determining who would end up actually benefiting from that. So, you know, it would actually end up backfiring because, you know, how would that be shared? 52:42 It's in a totally different legal frame. 52:44 Like, it gets way too complicated and actually exploits people who have been participating, but they don't understand how to access the legal framework, and, you know, you can't put in the work when you need to bring in experts anyway. 53:00 Max: Very briefly, we've been doing co-ownership for 500 years, it's called a transnational corporation, and it works like magic. 53:16 vote give a little minus for the time yes I think that's that's appropriate so please vote as you feel and we might deduct a little bit from 53:29 average there's a zero over there even oh that's rough ones twos threes zero yeah least 53:44 okay looks like a two guys um could you L pass that one 53:56 I can pass to another one or who hasn't 54:07 oh W that was a 54:17 Yael: I just want to say you should feel empowered, as individuals, to vote for what you really believe in. So don't be affected by all of these people around you with their twos and their ones. 54:30 Like, express yourselves. 54:35 think okay so since capitalism was unsuccessful now the commoners um it's by my count it's like your turn right um so you choose collectively one of the three cards but 54:51 you can go for either one in this space so the space is is determined by 55:09 capital and and after we come up with the average vote and like kind of see what the situation is if you have like a comment that you would like to put or 55:19 you voted very low for a story or or very high for a story we would love to hear from you like more substantial yeah kind of uh arguments or thoughts we do 55:32 have a spare mic over there and my colleague will help pass it on okay commoners are ready okay 55:42 Laura: We’re also going for co-ownership, and actually, we have some interesting ideas that could also be interesting for our friends here, the capitalists, because we are not as exclusionary as you guys. 55:59 So, there are these things called tokens, and they're like these beautiful shiny objects, sometimes they have a JPEG attached to them with some nice animations. 56:17 It's, you know, like, you decide the price according to your market that you like so much, and then we can create a system where, you know, you can be exposed to whatever value occurs there. 56:36 But the ownership and co-ownership of this network remains in the hands of the actual members and active participants of organizations. 56:48 So, you know, like this card says, “It might be easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism, but crypto tokens make it just a little bit easier to tap into the end of capitalism for those funds that we will need to build new worlds.” 57:06 So, you know, we can provide you with the investment sheets and everything you need, but ultimately the idea of co-ownership is going to be realized by the people who are actually actively participating in this network and not just, you know, capital allocators. 57:27 We're not a plutocracy when we talk about co-ownership. 57:33 Ela: Money and credit creation should be in the hands of the people and not in the hands of capitalists. 57:51 see four over here yeah a one over there five threes fours two say it's a very solid three kind of you okay um the red one 58:18 okay one two or three wins you co ownership a one okay yes all right so we're in here together for now the commoners are in lead and we've come through half of the 58:38 circle so half of this round and again it's up to Communism uh oh sorry you sorry Max Max the capitalists yes so just wanted to point out the 58:56 screen is off the capitalist are yes we're in the solidarity economy space so you're either claiming Universal basic something or Community currencies we're 59:09 now on this 59:28 you're just exposing that they're fake 59:39 fake and again just to remind you uh you're welcome to take empty cards over there and feed the player some prompts um so with your own ideas you have good 59:51 ideas for challenges coming from maybe your own personal experience experiences or maybe readings um or various kinds of interventions possibly that you're 1:00:01 involved in or you know of that could be potentially yeah gamechanging things for 1:00:28 like capitalisms 1:00:38 Max: We're the smart money; we take the time we need to make the right investment, as I know the audience does, or I hope you do. 1:00:45 Listen, we're talking now about Universal Basic Something, and what we have to admit is that we are in a moment where, even though our colleagues on the left-hand side of the table want to convince you that they're in this for the good of humanity with all of their flowery words about this, we all know that everyone is, in fact, quite the opportunist. 1:01:07 There are many different NGOs that are competing in the space to provide Universal Basic this, Universal Basic that, and let's face it, they're quite cynical actors. 1:01:17 I mean, there's a great deal of profit to be made, whether that profit is material and monetary or symbolic, from being able to claim you can solve everyone else's problems. 1:01:26 But, of course, the thing is, when you claim to solve everyone else's problems, you realize that, in fact, these are the problems that you conceive of. 1:01:32 The only institution that's capable of solving everybody's problems without resorting to violence is – you guessed it – the market. 1:01:40 And we have ample historical evidence to suggest that any other regime, if you put even our soft-hearted colleagues in charge, is going to reduce itself to authoritarian government the moment anyone like us, job creators like you, the smart money, want to actually make something of this world. 1:01:58 So I think you can hear their impressive rhetoric about Universal Basic Services. You can hear their impressive rhetoric about Universal Basic Income. 1:02:04 But you have to be a little bit skeptical, and I noticed from your voting patterns that maybe you're not being as skeptical as you should be. That is your right. 1:02:13 You can exercise your marginal utility as you want. But let's realize that they might win in this room, but we run outside, and you should be with us. 1:02:32 off okay three five four three threes four two fours okay there's a one there that might change things okay so it looks like a three as well that was a 1:02:53 four I am sort of in control for the um the blue Dy the blue 1:03:08 dye yeah I think we'll have to start throwing it further it's a five sorry guys so the commoners either of these is up for 1:03:35 grounds I'll read them out at the end I keep forgetting but yes the 1:03:47 Ela: Okay, let's talk practicalities here. Just one little word about Universal Basic Something. It is the power to say no, no to bullshit jobs, no to people co-opting your time. 1:04:00 But let's really give a very practical case. 1:04:03 Put yourself in the shoes of a person that is in a, let's say, network of an Ecovillages, whatever, and you have a community currency there that allows you to buy whatever you need and exchange it with whatever seems to be appropriate. 1:04:21 And that really sets you free from the pressure of the market economy. It is possible. 1:04:27 We have proven this in multiple Ecovillages in multiple hubs worldwide, closing economic loops with like-minded people, making sure everyone has what they need, what the basics are of their life, and sharing everything in this group is a possibility. 1:04:48 We are really talking about something that is achievable and practical. So I really have to ask myself, and I want to ask you, why on Earth would you not want that as a possibility in your life? 1:05:04 It seems to be very obvious. 1:05:13 bit it's okay um okay put up 1:05:21 vote like aish four fives threes 1:05:36 H I don't think there's enough fives to 1:05:41 make even a like a week four I'll give you that a week 1:05:53 okay it's a 1:06:00 one does anyone wna like qualify their Vote or feel like they want to speak out 1:06:08 something okay I'll try to ask each you uh I mean with the 1:06:22 uh it's 1:06:26 Peerticipant: I have to say that in this particular round, I heard a team mentioning potato peeling, and knowing that potatoes came from my end of the world, it doesn't seem to matter how many hours I spend peeling potatoes, it's people like you that keep eating all the french fries. 1:06:44 So, I do come from places where we already have our credit, you say that you're going to offer me something, but it's been 500 years of offering, offering, and offering, and nothing actually comes to us. 1:06:57 It's people in my village or in my town that are the only ones we can depend on, so that's why that story seems more true. 1:07:13 turn it's the regenerative economy space so Eco Village or donate economics one of it's sorry 1:07:46 can I think we can save it for with your for this 1:08:00 Beth: Alright, I'm going to read this card out because it's very beautifully written by our occasional collaborator, Jaya Klara Brekke: “Philosophers, lawyers, and economists in the West have engaged in a kind of intellectual willing into existence of an outside of capital that might exist elsewhere. 1:08:19 This cosmology of the commons has always felt constructed and abstract, never full.” And one can see that most effectively in Doughnut Economics. 1:08:30 There are two areas that just completely fall flat when you try to actually make policies that help people in monetary flows that are trackable, replicable, and scalable. 1:08:41 So, for example, if you're trying to include everyone's needs but you refuse to measure them, which you all have made clear is not yet part of your construction, then it doesn't become a donut, it just becomes, like, the void inside the donut. 1:08:57 And the worst of all, when you are considering the Earth as a stakeholder, like where do you end? If you are taking the most nihilistic view, the Earth as a stakeholder would prefer to have none of us there. 1:09:09 Therefore, we should, you know, just extract as quickly as possible so the Earth can go back to the state that it prefers to be in, without any humans at all. 1:09:20 So, yeah, it just starts to get into some mental masturbation loops that are very useless for policy and in fact, are, contradictory, pretty much. 1:09:35 muchers right yeah all right what's your vote I mean I think it's a very nice it's a six even yeah five we're getting full epicurian just good 1:09:55 completely um could someone come pick up the uh blue dye yes that's right and it seems like they have a five so anything but a six wins them donut 1:10:11 economics yeah it's a five oh wow okay so buy a hair but you won so now the the commoners 1:10:26 Beth: We're getting full Epicurean here … I don't know how they do it, you have to wear a Patagonia vest to do that. 1:10:55 Philip: We chose the card “Citizen science project mapping social and ecological initiatives, their ambitions and challenges.” 1:11:02 So, if you are arguing that Doughnut Economics is having no measurable impact on our living environment, I must say that this is not true, because we have to live, by our own nature, in this environment. 1:11:27 And to prove that and to provide us with data, a very good source is a citizen science project, which brings knowledge and resource tracking into the whole society. 1:11:45 Everyone can contribute with sensors and other forms of measurable data to prove that there is a limit of your expansion, that we have to live with the resources which are available for us, and we can't go over the top because it will destroy our lives and all your economy; we will be dead. 1:12:09 Ela: Also I think citizen science is a great instrument to reveal people's actual needs, and not the needs that are suggested or anticipated by the market economy, that is, what are people's needs in relation to nature, in relation to their natural habitat. 1:12:24 I think this is really something that's super important to explore, and it very often doesn't show up in statistics. 1:12:32 So the data we have is super biased by virtue of capitalist influence, and I would welcome any citizens' initiative to free us from that and to open up a space where the needs – not only of people but also of nature at large – become visible, and we have to deal with it. 1:12:55 think put up a 1:13:05 vote there a little six there but then there's a one over there it might be interesting to get your guys's input okay fors there a four okay it seems like a four 1:13:35 these down to the last second these yeah number two okay dice are crazy yeah they're so so while we do have like a potential Faceoff situation I would um 1:13:48 yeah recommend that for the for the time being uh we leave this as contested and move on to the final uh yeah ideological Battleground before the 1:14:00 short break so team capitalism on the participatory yeah 1:14:11 Yael: So, I'm just going to read it out: “General displeasure with governance, stemming partly from economic inequality, leads to cascades of protest votes, creating a wave of dysfunctional nations.” 1:14:24 Okay, I want to say something about participatory budgeting. 1:14:29 Participatory budgeting means that people who don't necessarily have any particular skill or training are involved in decision-making at such levels of complexity that are sometimes way above their understanding, maybe sometimes above their education level. 1:14:51 And they might very easily lead to budgeting completely wrong priorities, and that may very easily lead to massive demonstrations, and absolute inequality between those who receive the resources, whom the people chose for whatever reasons. 1:15:18 I have to say, participatory budgeting is definitely a nice idea, I'm not saying it isn't. 1:15:25 But we need to educate the society and the community who does participate in budgeting in order to be skilled enough to do it. We're not there yet. 1:15:36 Maybe in the future, we will be, but I think we really need to watch out for this. 1:15:49 youer what do you all 1:15:57 okay there's two with a one and a five over there interesting and a zero there's Z there's a zero as well 1:16:10 um okay it's a tough one I'm yeah I'm not a human calculator this one is kind of but let's say it's uh solid three please don't kill me oh it's the blue one okay it's over 1:16:39 five it's a bust I'm 1:16:50 sorry so you're free to go for either participatory budgeting or something 1:17:01 Dow just to mention some of these cards uh came from the online form you may have seen uh go around on social media and on the website um and some come from previous 1:17:16 events um and the the sources already also um cited on the bottom um and yeah at the beginning we had a projection of the cards on the screen there maybe you 1:17:27 saw it maybe you didn't um but it's an ongoing experiment with these cards this is the first time we're also using visuals for them they were all um 1:17:38 generated yeah with mid Journey um which is yeah it's kind of an experiment a 1:17:47 technology yeah that wasn't that wasn't produced by pure production a p top yeah yeah oh yeah mid Journey right yeah 1:18:04 Laura: We're also going for participatory budgeting, but like, just to respond a little bit to the fact that, well, if sometimes participatory budgeting may not work, it is when it's designed from the top down by people like you [the Capitalists] that don't have any connection with the local realities of these communities and places and initiatives that are already, you know, trying to organize for themselves. 1:18:34 But we see huge evidence for communities that already spontaneously develop local cooperation and share goods and services and favors with one another without the necessity for any financial schemes on top of that. 1:18:53 So there are ways in which participatory budgeting, community coordination at the local level, can work really well, when the people that take on the ownership to develop this initiative are the ones that are also very much embedded in these realities. 1:19:14 So, you know, there's still a lot that things like participatory budgeting can do at the local level when it is actually the people that are first of all impacted by these initiatives that take a big role in this. 1:19:36 role in in this 1:19:40 Ela: We really would like to invite you [the Capitalists] to participate in our budgeting and give your money, because it's all about redistribution. 1:19:48 What if you would join us in our big cause and give us a little bit of your money? That would be amazing. That would be real participatory budgeting. You would be welcome. 1:20:11 fours lot of fours looks like a four the red Dy thank you so much for helping 1:20:32 it's a four 1:20:46 okay with this round one is complete we'll have a short break now about five minutes or episode you know toilet break grab grab a drink and so on and we will 1:20:57 actually Implement a few more things here on the board you guys don't have to worry about it you guys either will come to it uh thank you also for your 1:21:07 patience this is always kind of an experiment um and yeah welcome back in a 1:21:20 while round two is where 1:21:45 yeah the 1:22:10 yeah we got to think about the yeah we should think about I mean cards should 1:22:26 you have the 1:23:40 at first I was confused 1:35:59 oh well anyways people who can hear me are already here and people who don't so but for the online folks yeah we're getting started in I'd say roughly three 1:36:58 got got 1:37:13 yeah Roose yeah do you think you could maybe get some people and try to get some people from that other part outside 1:37:54 so just a heads up you guys will go first and it will be your turn and self you guysare 1:38:16 never get wild the whole game was a warm up 1:38:35 before you will pitch that we will start off new 1:38:54 have three cards you have two or three 1:39:30 guys feel comfortable 1:39:44 starting FYI we will start the round by you guys flipping your your D um and we will see where 1:40:09 I'll let's just make clear where each card is of 1:40:47 yeah I think so yeah okay so we're ready to start as you can probably see sorry guys as you can probably see we've uh yeah adjusted the board 1:41:01 somewhat or added new elements um so we began with kind of the the basic mechanics of the game so we each get to hear a story argument Etc and give a vote and now um 1:41:17 I'm yeah introducing a bit more complexity so um the capitalist will start and roll the die and depending on which number we get um something will 1:41:28 happen so go 1:41:34 I it's a five okay so a five is a trojan horse so what this actually means this is in favor of the commoners it's on the side and what happens is if there's an 1:41:52 instance on the board but I don't think there is actually where there would be a contestation so like commoners and capitalists would be like like this 1:42:04 Rights was that yeah no you said it I mean maybe they won and you also won yeah yeah that's right and we moved on we didn't have a lightning round so actually now with the 1:42:19 Trojan Horse you can actually take this over and the notion is that some kinds of alternative economies have to kind of be first coopted in order to like fully 1:42:33 develop maybe reach the kind of you know like maybe critical um like awareness about it and the problems with it and thereby maybe also alternative solutions 1:42:44 to it there's other ways tro and horses can play out but that's the basic idea so I'm sorry capitalism the uh yeah the odds were not in your 1:42:55 favor but now let's yeah continue on with self-care is up for grabs for team capitalism first and I believe you already have the card to 1:43:12 play I think we can we can leave that out yeah um but we can read read it yeah 1:43:23 Max: So, I mean, we agree. We actually think self-care is extremely important. 1:43:27 And the reality is that, try as we might as a species, we've backed ourselves into a bit of a corner, and even us capitalists don't really know what to do about the environmental situation. 1:43:40 It's not all our fault. I mean, we were just each of us pursuing our corporate agendas and self-interest, and we now have a big problem. 1:43:49 But the reality is, these problems are not going to be solved by sort of airy-fairy thinking about abstract ideas. They're actually going to be solved by the people in this world who are making decisions. 1:44:03 We have access to them. 1:44:04 And the reality is, if you look at all of the people on our team, we're funding numerous initiatives, including some of the initiatives that have sponsored this event here tonight, to actually try and come up with solutions. 1:44:15 And the reality is that if we're going to be speaking about solutions, we need to actually be thinking about things that are going to work. We don't have a lot of time. 1:44:23 We don't have a lot of patience at this moment for a bunch of basically abstract ideas that might work for 10 or even 100 people but are not going to work for 8 billion people. 1:44:33 The important thing for all of us to remember is that we need to be taking care of ourselves. And I don't mean that in a selfish, self-interested way. 1:44:40 I mean that in the sense that if we're actually going to be capable of coming together and changing this world together, then we actually need to think about how we're going to bring our best selves to the table. 1:44:50 Now, you might not like the system of capitalism, but that's the system that we have right now. Maybe we're going to change it. We're all Democrats here. 1:44:57 If you vote us out, if you vote capitalism out, be our guests and elect the right parties and go through the proper channels. This doesn't have to be violent. Let that be as it may. 1:45:07 But the job that we have to do right now is to think about ourselves, to prepare ourselves, and to be the kind of citizens we want to be in order to make that change. 1:45:15 And that involves hard thinking, not just idealistic thinking. 1:45:21 up for a 1:45:26 vote I see lots of Threes it's a one and a five yeah it's threes and a one and a five essentially so three um the the blue Dy should be oh thank you so 1:45:49 much oh no wait uh yeah 1:46:08 nope so congratulations on staying in fantasy you still have to go for self-care but you don't need to refer to this context although if you feel it 1:46:19 will help you certainly 1:46:28 okay are the commment is good to 1:46:35 Ela: Okay, people, let’s not let the capitalists dictate to you what self-care actually is because you all know best, right? 1:46:43 And I want to suggest that we engage in a spontaneous hackathon as a format which is all about you and your needs, and what self-care means for you. This is about you, right? 1:46:57 And I want to invite you for 30 seconds to close your eyes, take a deep breath, take a look at yourself. These 30 seconds are just for you. 1:47:12 Opt out of this game, opt out of this space, opt out of the logic that keeps you here in this room, and just ask yourself the question: Who are you? What are your needs? Why are you here? This is about you. 1:47:30 This is about self-care. And you know best what it means for you. 1:47:46 vote yeah for the second time you tried this breathing thing it seems to to be 1:47:55 working okay it's uh it's hard to yeah there's a few fives but then again twos it's a three the red D if you can throw it to 1:48:13 and one two or three three three okay so commoners again okay so now that we've had two rounds now the commoners um like actually yeah you can roll the red one 1:48:36 and let's see which one of these six 1:48:40 happen it's a two okay so that's co-optation 1:48:52 so what you can do is let's see which ones you kind of you know uh lost before like this one and revert it back to a 1:49:04 position wouldn't we like to have the happiness but it's ours we are here yeah so like um we can effectively pick and it doesn't really matter too much it's 1:49:17 just uh like the ones we've already played so it just figures into the final 1:49:24 yeah so we'll revert the skill sharing platform back to a contest to cont to contest it because it before it was completely commoners yeah so you have 1:49:36 one point back on the board through this yeah little intervention and now it is your turn to try and claim time Banks and you need to use yeah one of 1:50:45 okay oh yeah um yeah so 1:50:52 Beth: So with regards to time banking, I think a fear that all of us have, popularized by the phrase “this meeting could have been an email,” is that people want to be able to define their own time, the value of that time for them – which tasks they actually consider to be equivalent, how they value their own time, and definitely don't want that to be put into one of these meeting formats where, for example, design elites with stakes vested in the status quo of continuing to think of time as exchangeable units, or even that all types of time might be valuable in the same way. 1:51:52 Like if one person is a lot faster at creating design requests or pushing code, why should that be subject to discussion among a large group of people instead of just individually determined? 1:52:05 So I think it's good to take back time banking and other types of resource sharing from having to be put forward into these endless discussions and into something that people can value with a metric that makes sense to all of us, which is money, how quickly the output is made, not having this quorum about how much time it takes and what that means. 1:52:40 we fives two five three fours a one 1:52:51 I think it's changing one three yeah it's moving fingers well I think with with the all the ones and things like a three yeah um the dice is there La could you 1:53:11 help us with the dice 1:53:32 two great success so now the commoners 1:53:49 Philip: I have this card where “You write a viral song about bringing down the patriarchy that is played at the president's inauguration”, and what comes to my mind directly is [the song] The Time is Now. 1:54:13 Du du dururu, duu-du, du du dururu, duu-ru, du ru dururu, duu-ru, time is now! Time is now! So, I think it's really about seeing the time now, and how you can react to certain situations. 1:54:25 It's not always about imagining, but being able to react in time. 1:54:40 Beth: I thought you were going to reference the song that's like, “the boss makes a dollar, I make a dime.” And I just wanted to point out that, you know, you lost your opportunity. 1:55:00 Philip: Wow. I need some help from my colleagues. Do you have some support, or maybe I can call upon a member of the audience to support me. Maybe it’s time for someone who can support our idea. 1:55:17 time banks with a song there's so many songs about you just argue how a song made a change but you can also sing I think song about time doesn't seem we have any 1:55:43 takers okay I think we'll have to put this up for a vote whatever this was 1:55:52 a 10 right 1:55:57 there threes three singing pays off to some extent five two let's go for a three looks like a three um both dice are over there one is on the floor and 1:56:19 one is up there the the red one I think the red 1:56:37 four sorry guys the market has spoken Okay so we've had another another two rounds so again we roll the now it's the capitalist again to roll the blue 1:56:55 dye yeah and and like the audience can vote oh yeah you can do it for the team it's a six oh that's in favor of the commoners but it's it's not that bad uh they do 1:57:12 get an extra intervention they can play and how that works I will give you an intervention and you can play that at any time so it kind of adds to any of 1:57:23 the three cards you have yeah but it but it failed so it will go under here okay so I will give you an intervention you can use um but it's the 1:57:41 capitalist turn now to attack balance complex Equitable sharing of different kinds of 1:57:59 Yael: Okay, so I'm going to read this. It's about the balanced job complex, which I'm just going to remind you refers to these utopian societies where everybody shares all the tasks and responsibilities. 1:58:14 So, you have this magical balance between your passion activities or things that you're feeling strongly about or enjoying doing, and your commitments to the society in order to keep things going, right? 1:58:27 So, you might need to give two hours a week to clean the streets, but you can then use the rest of your time to do whatever else. 1:58:35 And the challenge that I have is “Having a bullshit job and working for hours on end leaves little time to seek out, connect, and engage.” 1:58:46 So basically, let's just think about the amount of work that an individual will need to do in these utopian societies that will leave so much time for their pleasure activities. 1:59:03 There will need to be farming going on, which we know is such a not time-demanding work, right? There's going to be low demand. 1:59:12 There's going to be a need for education, health care, child care, cleaning – all of these activities. 1:59:27 And except for doing and participating in all of that, you will also have, of course, so much time to pursue your passion or your joy tasks and activities. 1:59:40 This is a fake reality, this is a story that is being told, and the reality is that, at least in the system that we have, you can work in a job, you put in the hours, and you know how much time afterwards you are free to do whatever you want. 1:59:58 You don't have to go clean the street, somebody else cleans the street, that's their day job. So, yeah. 2:00:18 two it looks like a three from here uh so it's the blue dy over 2:00:32 Max: Everyone is welcome to stay after and help clean up tonight, if you want to put it into practice. 2:00:46 tough so the commoners get a turn 2:01:02 I like you guys were creating your own currencies you could have just made one in this time rather than complaining about all of our economic 2:01:10 activity you clearly 2:01:24 Laura: First of all, I just wanted to say that bullshit jobs are the ones that you create, so, you know. 2:01:30 But apart from that, the idea of a balanced job complex may sound pretty abstract, may sound utopian, but actually utopias only live in the realm of the abstract until someone makes them real or starts to bring them into people's minds. 2:01:50 And actually, what we've been doing is collaborating with our close friend Kim Stanley Robinson, as this card says, to develop the best post-capitalist fiction novel ever. And guess what? 2:02:06 It's based precisely on this idea of a balanced job complex and it tries to bring it more into the real world, into a storyline that actually makes sense and that we hope that you'll all enjoy. 2:02:18 Also, the publication is going to be Open Access, because we care about that. 2:02:41 that we've got a couple of sixes even yeah some people not convinced didn't read the book okay well a week five or a solid four it's it's difficult yeah we'll go with a four 2:03:09 Yael: There's clearly a lot of imagination here in the room, fantasy even … 2:03:31 five no one want no one knows what's to do with the balance job complex which no no surprise really okay so again we've had one turn and another so it's time for a random EV 2:03:49 event to happen uh it's your side 2:04:09 yeah a one it's a number one okay wild card yay it's a whole new set other set of cards and I welcome you to pick one of the three one of these might help you 2:04:23 one of these might help the other team while one yeah let's 2:04:32 Max: Oh, look at this new age nonsense! You want to put these guys in charge? All right, all right, cool, cool, cool, cool, cool. Yeah, do your thing, do your thing. Run your community by tarot card. 2:04:50 no good or bad uh oh the aliens have unmasked themselves and taken over the world strategic supplies by force so can't really see it but it's you know a 2:05:05 picture of essentially not Mark Zuckerberg um in a kind of robot SL Alan kind of you you know how he looks but just he's wearing like this sweat suit 2:05:18 type thing and yeah I really like this card by the way um but yeah the aliens have unmasked themselves and taken over the world's strategic supplies so you 2:05:28 guys get to take three of their cards three of their three of their cards like one one from like take it 2:05:42 Max: So we don't get to reclaim territories? 2:05:45 Right, because astrobiology tells us that there's a universal law to the universe of competition that guides the evolution of all life forms, whether terrestrial or extraterrestrial. We all know that … 2:06:27 I for one welcome our new alien masters. They're actually a lot like us. 2:06:43 each uh nothing just uh like extract them burn them from the other team okay so they have they're a bit more limited in their storytelling capacity so now 2:06:58 again it's the the capitalist turn and we're they're trying to take over Eco 2:07:12 Max: You know what, all three of us have actually spent a lot of time in Ecovillages, and when we're there, we're actually really A+ members. Like, I think all of us learned a lot actually from our time there. 2:07:24 We talk about it in our management retreats, and I think we all, you know, we're into it, and we actually think you also should have Ecovillages as well. 2:07:33 The reality though is that – yeah, so we can sponsor, definitely, yeah, yeah – but, you know, the thing is, like, an archipelago of isolated Ecovillages is not going to change this world. 2:07:47 It's a beautiful thing that people can do, and we actually feel and we submit to you humbly that, actually, within capitalism, it gives you the perfect opportunity to do that. 2:07:56 If you and a bunch of friends want to go and own land collectively and share it and have democracy and make a sustainable community, please do so. Set an example for the rest of the world. 2:08:05 But the reality is, and you need to admit this as much as anyone else, you're not going to be able to network that and scale up on a level that is actually going to be able to save this planet in the time that it needs to be saved. 2:08:18 And we all see the hourglass – which has been taken off the table – running out. The reality is also that, if you admit it, these are Ecovillages for the wealthy and the privileged and the educated. 2:08:29 You're not at all concerned about the plight of the two-thirds of humanity who are not going to get to move to Ecovillages but are desperate for the resources that can, at this moment, only be provided by capitalism. 2:08:41 Beth: And with the locals providing the labor for the Ecovillages who might not get to get involved in the yoga retreat. 2:08:49 But, you know, it's like on one hand, it's creating jobs, but on the other hand, is it creating systemic change? 2:09:00 fantasy all right what do you think it's pretty 2:09:10 convincing we've got the signal and we've only got one more uh playing field uh in five minutes if we end in five minutes that's okay 2:09:25 yeah okay so it seemed like a four to 2:09:40 me a five where are the people calling for a 2:09:57 solid let's keep it this way and get it and get it going so yeah I'm sorry I'm sorry not as sorry as the rest of us are going to be when you're all in 2:10:07 your Eco Villages and the rest of us are frying so now it's your turn for the Eco Village and that will be the last 2:10:26 Ela: So we have the “Collaboration camps fostering synergies between grassroots initiatives and municipal government,” and this is something that we would like to bring to the table, because what we very often miss in Ecovillages – and we completely agree with your [the Capitalist’s] point – is that it's a very elitist movement and it’s people with money and resources, so we pretty much share your arguments, thanks for laying them out, but there is a component that we would like to propose for Ecovillages, and that is the level of municipal governance and people working with locals, not just with farming or whatever. 2:11:09 This is really about activating people at a local level and at the same time regulating what's going on there from a perspective of the law, of legal frameworks and forms of collective decision-making that are grounded in the spot with the people, and therefore we think it's essential to have this component in Ecovillages as well. 2:11:36 We didn't discuss that and I think you did it on purpose, because you like to derail the discussion to a point where it's again just about individual decisions. 2:11:45 What we would like to see here is a truly collective movement which is also strengthened by local policy-makers. That would be my point. Anything to add? 2:12:00 Philip: I think it's also a good moment to share the quietness and difference you're looking for when going to a place like an Ecovillage, and also helping the surroundings feed you with their experiences. 2:12:26 as actually I think we made a good case for why we should strong finish for the commoners please remember ala's yeah well articulated beginning and let's put 2:12:38 it up to a vote the last vote of the evening ones and fives again quite divided looks again like a three oh there's a six there even I think it's 2:12:59 it's a four it's a four I agree okay so the last red dye which I think it won't oh okay it's a two yes so an overwhelming Victory by the commoners 2:13:17 please give him a 2:13:27 Yael: So lucky that there's an art world where this reality can happen, isn't it nice … 2:13:36 okay thanks so much for joining this experiment and being part of it and and in co-creating well the end stage um the commoners yes one this time it's 2:13:48 actually through previous play playthroughs like it's really comes down to yeah the players the audience uh and it's yeah in in practice quite balanced 2:14:00 one time one wins one the other uh sometimes it's a tie but the point is really that yeah um we're here together and kind of discussing and kind of 2:14:11 embodying these yeah both what we think of as Alternatives and kind of trying to get into the other shoes play Devil's Advocates and well my idea is that you 2:14:24 know if we were to engage through these kinds of forms with these ideas that it will be a lot more difficult for say the capitalist to you know talk about say 2:14:34 Uber or Airbnb is you know the next sharing economy versus you know what you know the Heap of you know Alternatives beyond that um are being experimented 2:14:46 with around the world um and yeah with this kind of open concept where we can plug in our own ideas we can plug in our own cards prompts create stories around them it's 2:15:00 my hope that yeah this can be kind of down the line um a way for us to put together mingle these ideas engage in yeah um Collective World building and 2:15:14 also transpose that into the real world um and yeah hopefully change the game so thanks so much for joining today an absolute pleasure thank you again to all the 2:15:29 partners organizers Co organizers and sponsors yeah we'll see you next time which will be actually in Switzerland um at the beginning of November uh we'll have an exhibition 2:15:44 with the game alongside many other radical analog games games um yeah you can stay tuned on Futures scraft link tree um and yeah Elsewhere on the 2:15:56 channels of Partners probably Ooma but thank you so