Open on YouTube
Transcript 0:00 Okay, so the curtain has been pulled. Uh, we're officially starting. Thank you everyone for joining us today. Um, I'll just do a little bit of an introduction into the game, and then we'll just jump into playing. Uh, so my name is Rook. Um, I sort of developed this game or process. Um, and I developed this as a kind of game or game show for the commons, and it's 0:26 supposed to be a kind of playful process to balance scenarios and generate ideas and get to the heart of matters concerning alternative economies And while every time it's played, it's a little bit different. Um, it doesn't have to be, but, but it can. Um, and so also for this edition, we've customized it somewhat in terms of the playing fields that you see also on the, on the screen behind me. 0:56 Um, and these are essentially contested new economy buzzwords, and we have two teams fighting over essentially their meaning. Mm. And here we have the capitalist side, uh, with Peko, Ela, and Anja. Ooh. And we have the commoner side with Felix and Gregor and Muki. 1:22 Um, yeah, and well, they will be presenting challenges relevant to these fields, and they will be presenting interventions to counter those challenges. And in doing so, they'll be claiming these spaces for their teams. And you, the audience, will have a chance to participate in terms of judging in real time, uh, the storylines that they will pitch to, to do that capturing. 1:48 But you will also have a few other roles, um, because the players have to use these prompt cards, uh, as the basis for their stories to, to claim certain areas. And while these cards that we have here are based on, well, my own research and interviews, uh, but also, like, from the new book, From Commons to NFTs, um, as well as, uh, we consulted, uh, among players and, uh, yeah, 2:17 came up with a few additional cards. And we also kind of collaboratively set up, uh, the buzzwords and initiatives that correspond to them that we'll be playing with today. Um, but you as the audience also will have the chance to submit ideas for new challenges or new interventions. Um, and yeah, I will get these on my computer here, and I will write them 2:42 down on empty cards, and I will s-slide them in the decks so that if you have any ideas that you would like to bring in, uh, that's one way to bring them in. And the players will be, quote-unquote, "forced" to take up your idea and roll with it in a storyline or scenario. And we'll, we'll also kind of be modifying the game as we play it. 3:09 Um, also not all players are, you know, professional players or game changers or anything like that. Um, so we'll take this as a kind of, you know, public test and experiment. Um, we've also not, you know, had a version of this game played in such a setting. Um, yeah, uh, for this, I very much would like to thank the team at Axioma, uh, as well as Maya who's here with us, and, uh, Tamara, uh, 3:38 and the people at Ludia who helped create this version, uh, of the game. Um, yeah, and with that said, I think we can, um, get it rolling. I think, uh, bios you can read online, I suppose, uh, the audience for the players, and, and we'll just skip right into play and, and see what they're made of 4:06 So, uh, just a bit of context. Before we even start playing the game, capitalism has already captured, say, a few of these fields, which you see over here. There's six of them. Um, and given the situation, which, you know, we could argue reflects, uh, you know, the current moment, um, we'll give the commoners the chance to roll the dice first. 4:34 Thank you. Do I roll one or two dice? 4:36 You roll two. Right. You might get three at some point, but- 4:40 Okay Seven and- 4:45 Uh, no. So you choose one or the other, right? Oh, 4:48 right. 4:49 It's either house sharing platform, one, two, three, four, five, or a wild card. 4:56 Ooh. 4:57 Ah. But bear in mind, the wild card could benefit your team, but it could also benefit the other team. 5:04 Go to the wild card. No, no, 5:05 no, no. 5:06 Go to the wild 5:07 card. I'm taking the house sharing platform. 5:10 Yeah. So here we have a potential, like, uh, Airbnb versus Fairbnb type situation. Um, but given that this field has not been challenged yet, you're red. You're, you're the communist. 5:24 Yeah. 5:26 Very easy. That helps. But, but yeah. 5:29 Oh, okay. 5:32 He's like a communist. 5:34 Easy win. 5:37 And that's it. You just, we 5:38 just claim it. Yeah, because there, there was no capitalist challenge established yet, so we just claim this narrative for us. We don't need to, to place an intervention because we don't need to intervene against any existing narrative. 5:49 Okay. But you could at least say something. 5:53 Well, the 5:53 capitalist 5:54 could 5:54 say something. I, I, I mean, it's dubious that you just claim. I mean, with what power? 5:59 Says the capitalist. Well, you know, it's like the building's not used, so we take it. Right. 6:05 Okay. Yeah. Okay. You have a house sharing platform- No, we just squat it … consisting of apartments. 6:10 Just, just squat it, you know? 6:11 Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yes. We 6:12 squat 6:13 your building 6:14 because you weren't there. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's, it's, it's fine that you have this platform of a house with, with apartments. Yes. 6:22 Yeah, 6:22 we have it. It's a platform. Yes, yes. 6:24 Yeah, we like platforms, 6:25 you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah. We can take… We can turn your, uh, house into a platform, actually. 6:30 And we like sharing, too. Uh, well, I think it's a, it's a great methodology, so- 6:34 Yeah … 6:34 I'm, I'm happy with the choice. 6:36 Yeah. 6:36 Yeah, we'll just take the tax, like 6:37 10% 6:38 fee. Yeah. If you need any consultants, and you do need them. Come and try. 6:45 Oh, they are just full of shit. It's not fair. But it's, it's part of the game. It's a theater. 6:51 It's about packaging. 6:54 Um, so yeah, uh, unclaimed territory. You guys have one leg in, so to say, but capitalism can still pose challenges, and if they do, you will have to address them to, to have that field unlocked 7:11 So, okay, so should we actually place the pieces like this so people can see on the camera? Mm-hmm. So, yeah. Okay, so one of the guys. Ooh. So it's the same. It's the same. So we have a possibility to challenge that or to get a wild card. Ooh. What do you think? 7:32 I think 7:32 the risk is- The wild cards is, like, a 50/50 chance that it will benefit you or, or shoot you in the foot. Mm-hmm. 7:39 Should we take the 7:40 risk? 7:40 Well… 7:42 I mean, we could challenge 7:43 this. We- I, I feel like challenging the house sharing platform … yeah. Yeah, because I 7:46 know the wild card is awesome, the first one. 7:48 Mm. 7:49 How did you- So it's better to challenge Uh … than we can get it. 7:53 Uh, okay. Hmm. So it, it means that it's awesome for you, so, okay. So then w- we should probably… Are we okay with challenging? 8:02 Uh, I would challenge, 8:03 yeah. Yeah, 8:03 yeah. 8:04 Can you move our piece? 8:05 No. 8:06 Do we have to- 8:06 No, don't do 8:07 any work 8:07 for them. 8:08 No, they should do the work. Just testing, just testing. Like, sometimes there's sort of cultures that are ready to work for other people. They're sometimes easy to use. Okay. Um- 8:20 So, to be honest, um, you know, I, I really like the notion of sharing. 8:27 Yeah, let's, uh… And we have to use one of these, 8:31 so. Oh, ah, we have to use one of these, 8:33 I see. Uh, so if any one of us has- So which, whichever one … has a good one. 8:36 Yeah. 8:36 Uh, we can't tell what they are, but we can say, like- 8:40 Yeah 8:40 um. 8:42 And it needs to be for the house sharing platform. Okay. 8:45 Something relevant for this space. 8:47 Mm-hmm. I, I have one fairly good one Hmm. 8:56 I have two identical cards 8:59 Really? Yeah. Ah, yeah. Uh, it's possible 'cause we did a reprint. Uh, we can switch one for another 9:14 If you have one that really fits. 9:15 Yeah, yeah. 9:16 Yeah, I don't, I don't think mine fits. 9:18 Okay. Yeah, mine neither. 9:19 Okay. I'll, I put it here, and then I'll read it aloud. Probably hard to see on, on the screen exactly. So, so the challenge is peer-to-peer technology has gone from being a means to circumvent the attempted enforcement of scarcity and access control to instead become a means to radically advance new forms of scarcity and digital property 9:48 And do we have a minute or- 9:50 Yeah. Timer is on. 9:52 Oh, wait, it's not on yet. Like, I'm w- we're at- It's on. 9:56 You see? 9:57 Okay. So- Even if you build something towards distribution, it's ultimately also a question who owns that distribution. If you make an NFT platform, and then people can make money on it, it's ultimately a question who owns the platform itself. So here, um, if, say, people start approaching apartments and 10:26 houses in a different manner, this is actually good for us. It's, it's… They're doing the experiments for us. But there will be a time they need capital, when they need to renovate the place. They can do part of it in, in their own, but, but there's, there's a point and a place where, say, million euros is very, very useful. So, so essentially we're seeing that you're doing the hard work 10:50 of creating new communities, and we come in just bit by bit. Like, maybe we get 20%, maybe we get couple of votes in the, uh, field, plus the people we seed into the organization, um, uh, secretly in itself. So, so we're fine of you having it for now, but once it becomes 11:19 meaningful, we are there 11:25 Okay. Uh, so for this round, we'll do a classic, uh, rate Peko on, in terms of how much he convinced you or based on these three parameters that you see before you. Um, like, yeah, how convincing was his story? Uh, I think the instructions are on the leaflets. Uh, I hope you have Mentimeter open. Uh, but you can already… Yeah, there are some results coming in 11:55 30 seconds 11:57 Mm-hmm. 30 seconds I just hid the results, but they're still coming in just so you're not, uh, biased, uh, from the results that are already in Um, we'll give it another 10 seconds, uh, for you to vote. 12:14 I love the infiltration element. 12:15 What, sorry? 12:16 I love the infiltration element, how we infiltrate into the organizations bit by bit, taking over. 12:21 Yeah. This, this is, this is something that we're very skilled at. And money is very useful for infiltration- Yeah … because you can use it in so many ways. Um, like, n- now you can infiltrate to the voting by having this conversation- That's right … making arguments constantly, like it's just- Or 12:36 maybe, you know, have the Cambridge Analytica applied to all the participants before they even came here. 12:41 Yeah, yeah. That's, uh- Okay. 12:43 So it looks like a three, Paco. 12:46 I- I mean, it's- So… Like, a realistic estimate- I understand … assessment would be- 12:52 Mm-hmm … 12:53 that is- 12:54 Well, you have to roll one to three- 12:56 All right … 12:57 to plant that challenge success- successfully. 12:59 One to three. It should not go above three. 13:02 Mm-hmm. 13:02 Yeah. So, so three is, um, top level? 13:05 Yeah. Uh, one, two or three. 13:06 But I, 13:07 uh, okay. That means you succeeded. 13:08 Okay. Um, let's go. 13:12 A five. 13:13 Um. 13:14 You were- You did not succeed. 13:16 Yeah. 13:17 Yay. 13:19 I mean, sometimes there's luck. 13:21 Yeah. 13:22 You know, counters professionalism. 13:24 Yeah. Mm-hmm. 13:32 Me? 13:32 Yep One or a five 13:39 Or a five. So we should both of- What happens if we go here again? 13:43 Well, you can kind of lock that field in a certain sense. 13:47 But forever? 13:48 Um, not really. Uh, if the capitalists land on this field, which is co-optation, they can pick this one specifically and subvert it. 13:59 And then they will have two blue ones? 14:01 Um, no, but, but they will have a challenge there- Oh … and your primacy is kind of reversed. 14:08 Mm-hmm 14:11 On the other hand, one, two, three, four, five- 14:14 Yeah, 14:15 just go for, uh- You can take over co-ownership 14:19 … 14:19 take over. Let's, uh, let's go to the five. It's, uh, which one? This one. 14:28 Okay. So for now, no, no need- 14:30 Yeah … 14:31 to make stories. 14:32 No Right. Because that's obviously one of our narratives. 14:42 302 or 14:44 2 But, but we can also move that piece also, I guess. Like, we can move both from 14:49 start and, uh- Yeah, we, we can from the start? Or do, do… It's the blue one here But you have to 14:53 play 14:53 yours 14:54 Yeah, I know, but, but can we, can we take this? Uh, no, no. 14:57 You each have 14:58 one. 14:58 Oh, 14:58 okay. Ah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay. So I'm, I'm choosing this one then. No. 15:03 What is the three have? 15:05 Well, the three is, like, an intervention, and that's more for, like, when commoners land there, they can play an intervention somewhere on the board. Mm-hmm. And the same goes for that one. Mm-hmm. That one is like a challenge for your side. 15:19 So it doesn't make much sense to go there 15:21 now? No. 15:22 Okay. And it's also because we are trying to block them- Mm-hmm … from getting a whole area, like sharing. 15:28 Mm-hmm. 15:28 This would make sense- We should go there … uh, and, and, and- Yeah … take the… And I mean- Because 15:33 typically 15:33 behave. Yeah. And to be honest, it's just- Unblock. Yeah … like, this is, uh, realism because we own ride sharing, ride sharing anyway, so we should take it. Yeah. Like, this is more correcting the board, I would say. 15:46 Mm. 15:47 Okay. 15:47 Okay. So you have to consult your cards, 15:50 and- We are here at ride sharing platforms 16:01 place a challenge and go through with, with the narrative. We can just, you know- But- … take what is ours anyway. 16:10 I would just ask the players to speak up when making the story and, and also some, you know- Mm-hmm … yeller along the way. It is kind of a big space. Yeah. If it helps, you can also move in a little bit. Mm. But we'll do our parts. 16:25 Do you have any good ones? 16:27 Not for ride-sharing. Yeah, maybe. 16:31 We can always cheat. I can give you a card because it- Um… 16:37 You have a card that fits again? 16:38 Um, um, I mean, uh, I- 16:43 You're capitalists. None of the cards are good ones. 16:46 Um, no, but it's, it's what you make of the cards, isn't it? Yeah. Uh, I have a decent one, but not a good one. 16:56 I also have a decent one. 16:58 Maybe we 16:58 can- Ca- I mean, can we consult openly, or? No, 17:00 please make 17:01 sure. ' 17:01 Cause I have one. See the cards? 17:02 No. No, no, 17:03 no, no, no. 17:04 We can't see the cards. You cannot. Show the cards. You can absolutely not. 17:06 Oh. 17:07 Oh. No, 17:08 no, no, no, no. 17:10 Like, do take it. Do take it. 17:13 Yeah. Well, okay. Um, talking about ride-sharing platforms, we can discuss the platform aspect of it, but we can also discuss the more hidden, uh, aspect, and that's the labor perspective. And, um, so what I would like to challenge here is my card says, "Having a bullshit job and working for hours on end leaves little time to seek out, connect, or engage." So I, I put that here. 17:41 Um, and I think, um, the, the whole narrative of ride-sharing usually addresses the economy. It addresses the fact that people are getting together, sharing a ride, being more social. But let's look at it from a different perspective. Let's look at the people that actually rely on, on their job of, uh, taking others with them, of becoming, uh, an independent taxi driver. It's a pretty bullshit job. 18:10 Still they're engaged for our platforms. They have l- tons of stuff to do. They work eight to 10 hours a day, and they are taking off the streets, and at the same time they have really very limited time to, yeah, engage in any activist movement. Mm. Mm. So I think it's quite interesting from that perspective. 18:38 Um, resetting. Uh, one second. Resetting the results, and you can vote now for Ayla's storyline 19:01 Hidden results as they're coming in 19:12 How is it looking? Oh, okay. Solid three 19:19 It's nice that you're showing it sometimes, like, uh- 19:22 Um, 19:24 mm-hmm. 19:24 Mm-hmm. 19:25 Yeah, 19:25 no bias at all. 19:26 No bias. 19:27 Yeah. No 19:27 bias. 19:28 Yeah. Yeah, thanks for doing that. 19:30 Yeah, yeah. 19:30 Appreciate it. 19:31 Yeah. 19:34 Okay. 19:35 No money changed hands- No, no … at all with the Game 19:37 Keeper 19:37 in 19:38 between us. This is, he, he's totally free. 19:39 Yeah. 19:40 Okay, so we have a score of three again. 19:43 Mm-hmm. 19:43 Solid three. So one, one to three 19:48 Ah. So 19:49 four. 19:50 I'm sorry. Okay. This one. 19:55 I mean, this is obviously belongs to the commoners. 19:57 Yeah. It also, like, tells the story that the only way the commoners can win is by luck. 20:04 Mm-hmm. 20:04 Right? Incompetency- 20:05 True … 20:06 of the capitalists so far. 20:07 It's a total bullshit job. Yeah, yeah. They just come- What numbers do you want? … and put on this square. 20:11 Uh, we want, uh, a four. We want the four. We want the four and, uh- Two, four. Two and four. Yeah. Four or three. Four, three would be nice. Okay. 20:21 Monkeys like, "I got it." Yeah. Yeah. Cool. Like, he has influence. 20:24 So that means we can just- So three … like, place it anywhere? 20:27 Uh, yeah. That does mean that. 20:30 Yeah. Yeah. 20:31 I think- So if 20:31 I- 20:32 I think that conversation was suspicious. You were telling which numbers to have, and then you had the numbers. Yes. I'm just raising the point- But we know how it works … that you have weighted the dice. 20:40 I mean, it's not luck. 20:41 Yeah. Mm-hmm. 20:42 Right? Even when you throw the dice, it's still not luck. 20:45 Universal 20:45 odds. If you have weighted the dice- Mm … then it's not luck, yes. I would agree. 20:48 Mm. I haven't touched the dice before this moment- 20:51 Mm … I promise. 20:52 Um- So 20:52 what you can do now is choose a board… A, a field that's already occupied by capitalism that has a challenge, and you have a freebie kind of to address it with an intervention. Okay. So it's not guaranteed that you will get it, but you can pick, in this case, from all those six that already have a challenge with them. 21:14 Finally they have to work a bit. 21:17 Say, say again. 21:19 Finally they have to work a bit. There's some 21:20 work going on over there. Yeah, yeah. We work every day for the paycheck. Mm-hmm. Every day. 21:30 I will set a timer, and, you know, you'll have roughly a minute to decide which one and who will pitch or start pitching. 21:39 What's the problem with universal basic something? Oh, there is many problems with it. 21:43 Uh, the problem is that local initiatives are having a hard time connecting to broader social change movements. 21:51 Okay. I, I, I think I can handle that one. Okay. Go for it. So the intervention we're playing is Anticipedia, a library of capitalist and post-capitalist visions of the future from around the world. So, um, whenever you want people to do something, they need reasons to do that. And even though often people know what the right thing to do would be, they still lack the reasons or the opportunity to do so. 22:19 Now, here we obviously have the opportunity because we are trying to achieve the universal basic something. The question is whether or not we're going to be able to get people on board to pay the initial, to use capitalist language, price in order to be able to achieve this because obviously, since we don't have it today, we need to put in some work. And the best way to, uh, get people motivated to do the work is to talk 22:44 about them and to invite them to participate in this idea of how the future is going to look like, much like what we're doing here today. And we think that when it comes to, um, arguing for universal basic something, these types of Anticipedia, right? So visions of how a better future would look like are an immense positive impact on people's motivation. And, uh, yeah, obviously, when people are motivated, they win. So we win. 23:13 Can't argue with that That was a 23:14 very strong capitalistic 23:15 opinion No need for that, I suppose. Or 23:18 rather no need 23:19 to argue 23:21 Voting is now open for this storyline 23:37 Limited memory. We have, we have the data 23:46 So what do we need to throw then? Like a four would be nice. 23:51 Yeah, like a- 23:52 Okay, so it's seeming like a four. 23:55 Mm-hmm. 23:55 Or- So you have to roll one to four to claim that area. 24:03 Five. 24:03 It's a five. 24:04 Aha. It's a game of luck. Oh. Yes. It's really a game of luck. 24:08 Yeah. 24:09 Okay. No, I just don't want us, uh, to seem too obvious. 24:14 Right? 24:15 We don't want to demoralize you at the beginning of the game. 24:24 We throw the dice? Mm-hmm. 24:25 Yes. 24:27 What do we need? 24:29 Um… 24:31 Four or a wild card, or should we take some- 24:35 I, I mean, yeah 24:36 I think a wild card would be nice. 24:38 Okay. 24:38 Yeah. 24:39 Take the risk. 24:40 Let's go for it. Yeah. 24:41 Let's take some risk. Yeah. Okay. 24:44 Mm-hmm. 24:44 Wild card it is, huh? 24:45 Five and six. 24:46 Mm-hmm. 24:47 It's co- own- ownership for- 24:49 Or we challenge the- 24:50 wild card Yeah, challenge or wild card 24:56 I feel like we should- So far it was 24:57 successful … 24:58 yeah, maybe, maybe this one will be successful. Now- Yeah, 25:02 the co-ownership. 25:02 Yeah, the co-ownership. Yeah, the co- I think- Yeah … I'm confident we can do this. 25:05 Yeah. So we challenge that. Can you move, please? Please. Oh, I, 25:10 I know you can. 25:11 Um. 25:12 Yeah, 25:12 I might do it this low. 25:15 I've 25:15 seen you do it. All right 25:21 Maybe, maybe we can move the pieces, but we lock in some options when the… Yeah, 25:27 I mean, if they pay us, 25:28 yeah. Yeah. Like options for later, you know? Like, uh, "Can you move my piece 25:31 there?" So you've got about a minute to decide who will go first, and just to remind you, you can, uh, complement each other's stories within the timeframe. Mm-hmm. It doesn't have to be just one person who speaks. 25:44 We can complement them. Mm. But then we need to share the card. 25:47 Yeah. 25:48 Aha, so we can share… Uh, we can talk and, uh- Yeah, yeah … the three of us could talk in one 25:53 voice. Okay. Basically you're deciding who starts, and, and- Yeah … if you wanna take up the whole time, that- that's good if, you know, you have the material and you feel convince- convincing. 26:02 Yeah. 26:02 But- 26:03 Yeah … 26:04 if you, you know… 26:06 So we can build, uh, on top of the argument. On top of each other. Yeah, yeah. Okay. 26:09 Yeah. You don't 26:10 need new cards for that. 26:11 No, no. You just, you just use one card. You're just- 26:13 Okay … 26:14 giving more context to that from your own perspective. 26:16 I 26:17 might 26:17 have a cool one. 26:19 I, I don't have, so if 26:20 you have one. Um, but I would love to engage in a group discussion. 26:24 Yeah, let's 26:24 do it. Yeah, yeah. Let's see what 26:25 we 26:25 can 26:26 add. 26:26 All right. So I'm first gonna read out the challenge. 26:29 Mm-hmm. " 26:30 Philosophers, lawyers, and economists in the West have engaged in a kind of intellectual willing into existence of an- 26:36 Louder. " 26:37 Philosophers, lawyers, and economists in the West have engaged in a kind of intellectual willing into existence of an outside of capital that might exist elsewhere. The cosmology of the commons has felt constructed and abstract, never full." So what I'm thinking of co-ownership, looking at it from a legal perspective, it's a very complex, um, concept. Like co-owning means that you're basically sharing the cost, you're sharing the maintenance. 27:03 You have to think, um, of it in a sense of how all of the co-owners are going to approach the owned property. So just saying the co-ownership doesn't really mean anything. Like it's a very, very abstract concept. You have to be more concrete about it, and you have to present more, uh, concrete exa- examples to really know what the participants are going to be, uh, working on, what they're going to be engaging in, and what does that mean for their co-owned property. 27:32 Like just co-owning means that I'm… I have the responsibility, the liability to maintain it so that somebody else that co-owns it with me will be able to use it, will be able to share it with other people. But like just saying co-ownership is a very, very abstract form. So from the economy perspective, from a legal perspective even, you have to narrate the terms almost, and you have to think about what are going 27:56 to be the costs and how we're going to be splitting the costs as well. It's not just about the ownership, it's about all the rest of the things that come along with the ownership. So I kind of feel like the co-ownership concept, even though it's very nice, even though we kind of want to go in that, um, in that world, it's not full. It's not complete at all. 28:16 Mm-hmm. 28:18 So what do you guys think? 28:19 I, I might, I might, uh, have something to add to that and that's, uh, it's about the threshold of owning something at all, right? Because in order to be able to own something, you either have to have a certain amount of money or you have to have a certain age or, you know, privilege in order to, to be an owner at all. So my challenge here says, future generations and non-humans are excluded from established political processes. 28:47 So thinking of those that cannot afford to be a co-owner at all, and especially looking at the younger generations, I think that's yet another argument why co-ownership in itself is problematic. So I would add to that. 29:01 Yeah. Hereditary system. Okay. 29:03 Yeah. Well, it's … Ownership is just a … Ownership is, is kind of a capitalist bait and switch because on the one hand, capitalists argues that it's about ownership, ownership, but ownership is actually just a bunch of rights. Yeah. Like, owning a car is actually rights towards the car and owning a house is a different bunch of rights. Ownership doesn't really mean much as a concept. What matters is what's underneath. And if one talks about co-ownership, if you look at how 29:30 the international real estate is built up, it's all co-ownership of- 29:35 True … 29:36 this, uh, company, this, our company, owning this company's, operating on connection with this company. And the techniques used for co-ownership on the capitalist side, because it's about kind of right sharing between these different companies and meta companies, is way more advanced. Uh, and, and in this sense, like, capitalist side is already in the co-ownership game and has been there much longer than, uh, than at least 30:05 the new initiatives of the, um, let's say the lefty side of things. 30:13 Okay. So since you took three minutes this time, uh, we're actually gonna give the commoners a chance to rebuttal. 30:21 Yeah. 30:22 Mm-hmm. 30:22 Yeah. Yeah. And you the audience will be voting actually not how convinced are you by them, uh, from zero to six, but which team won your heart. And you guys will have, yeah, the same amount of time as they just, uh- Okay. took to, to reply. 30:39 Thank you. But hopefully 30:40 you don't need all of it. 30:41 I think we, we don't need that much of time. Uh, first of all, uh, thank you, Anya, for, uh, clearly laying out what we have to do and come to terms with, uh, to, um, consolidate our co-ownership. Um, Peko, uh, of course, I mean, capital has been playing this game for a while now. Mm-hmm. Uh, for a long while. But, uh, as, uh, all of you know, um, we have a new technology that makes it much 31:06 easier to go into much more granular, uh, co-ownership where the legal aspects are automated and thus not so much of an obstacle anymore as it used to be. We don't need to write contracts and engage lawyers for all of that. Um, and so finally actually the, the playing field is level and we can, um, easily compete with, um, the ways capital has been, uh, doing co-ownership for, well, centuries. 31:36 I have one thing to add. Even though capitalism has been around for a long time and it has influenced the way we own things, um, people owned things before capitalism for a much longer time than capitalism came to be. So the experience, amount of experience is totally on our side. Besides the fact that you just heard that you laid out your plan, so we know exactly what you can do. 32:01 Yeah. Listening to this actually I also, yeah, got a, got a thought. It's basically, you know, the capitalist definition of ownership is like a single player mode. Uh, so, uh, claiming that co-ownership doesn't work would be like claiming that, um, multiplayer games don't work, you know? So in that sense, it's just a challenge of governance. And we have Elinor Ostrom who won the Nobel Prize with like, we seem to, to understand rules which work. 32:27 So I don't see any problem why co-ownership wouldn't work, especially with the technology, uh, out there. 32:34 You're going to jail, folks. If you're not getting 32:37 the 32:37 words, 32:37 you're not- You have one noble … you're going 32:39 to 32:39 jail. We have several. 32:41 I, uh, 32:41 I've opened the vote. Call them. And you can choose one or the other team as the winner of this round. I will hide the results for now And here we have a question from the audience 33:12 No, 33:12 it's 33:12 okay. 33:13 Uh-huh. Uh-huh And this is, this was for you, Monkey, earlier that I'm anticipating. 33:23 Mm-hmm. 33:25 Um, humans are willing to work for free, so we don't need money. 33:32 Work for a vision. Um- A shared 33:34 vision. Okay. So it seems communism has indeed won this round, and, uh, your attempt here failed- 33:42 Mm … 33:43 unfortunately. But yeah, this, this might happen, right, if you take too much time. I'm looking for ways to give then the other team a level playing field. 33:52 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Time is money. 33:58 It is. 33:59 Interestingly, you had that, uh, interface already ready, 34:02 so- Yeah. 34:03 It's totally random … yeah, yeah. 34:05 Yeah. Yeah. 34:07 All right. We're going with an individual approach. Take too much time. 34:18 We like to play with open cards. Yes. It's- We're 34:21 very open in this. 34:22 Yeah. 34:23 Yeah, open source. 34:23 We embrace open as well. We can- Well, 34:26 if you want to share your comedy- We can 34:27 see it, by the way … Yeah, yeah, of course. But you can- You know You get a taste of it. That's Uh, 34:32 so whose turn was it? It's my turn. It, it was yours. Okay. Um… 34:38 203. We can either just take the Dao- We 34:42 started here … or- One, two … 34:43 we go and challenge. But I think take- No, no. Take the Dao. Take the Dao. Take, take the Dao. Take the Dao. No, the Dao. Um… It's also- We own the Dao. 34:52 Yeah, it's a good historical rep- representative. First you take the Dao, and then later we take it, just like it has happened Mm-hmm. Ju- 34:58 just like you did so far, 34:59 right? Yes. 35:01 Yeah. Do you need to start back? 35:04 Uh, were they both used? Pretty much, yeah. Yeah, 35:07 they were. 35:12 So it's, it's our side? 35:13 Well then. 35:15 Uh, 35:15 workloads. Let's see. Mm-hmm. 35:17 All right. So what do we get? We get four and one. But does it have to be now the piece we moved first, or? Your 35:25 piece. 35:26 Any piece? 35:26 Your piece. 35:27 Oh, my piece. Which one was yours? 35:28 So, yes. Like, each one of you has a piece. You should sort of memorize which shape it is, right? 35:33 Mm. I think we started with the house sharing platform. 35:35 Typical capitalist strategy of, of- 35:36 Mm-hmm. 35:37 So four and one. Sorry, Mr. Capitalist. So we could go back to ride sharing platform if we were- 35:41 Have another go. 35:42 We have another go, essentially. Mm-hmm. Or… 35:44 Two, three, four. 35:46 Or- 35:46 Or have another go here … 35:48 the g- So another go at ride sharing or another go at co-ownership. 35:51 Mm. 35:52 Mm. Mm, 35:53 mm. 35:53 And it depends a little on your cards as well, right? 35:55 Mm-hmm. 35:56 Yeah. 36:03 I th- I think if we play co-ownership, we are kind of probably pressing a point because they, now their audience feels the identity- No people captain is- … that they gave them a win, and if we challenge it, we're really challenging the audience. Yeah. Oh, for sure. So for the marketing perspective, uh, it's not a good thing. M- and whereas ride sharing is already kind of gone from the public consciousness. So if we challenge- Mm … that, that's much more on a fresh ground 36:26 because, like, it's on- it's been a few minutes, which is enough to move it from- Mm-hmm … public consciousness. 36:32 All right, so do we have a card? Hear what 36:34 he thinks about. 36:36 Well, we're being open and transparent. 36:37 Yeah, we're be- yeah, we're- Yeah … we're playing with open cards. Um- Like, uh- 36:42 Always playing with open cards … yeah. So you would opt for the ride sharing? 36:47 Yeah, between, because otherwise we go back 36:49 to 36:49 the 36:49 earlier one. Yeah, yeah, we go back to the second. Yeah. Okay. 36:52 So 36:52 ride 36:52 sharing it is. Ride sharing 36:53 platforms. 36:55 Mm-hmm. Does anybody have a good card for ride sharing? 36:59 I still hitchhike. 37:00 I'll give you 20 seconds more to decide 37:17 10 seconds 37:19 If they don't decide, they lose? 37:21 They forfeit. 37:23 I don't have a good 37:24 one- 37:25 Yeah … 37:26 for 37:26 ride sharing. 37:28 I may go with one. It's not the best one, but- Three, two- I think we 37:32 can go … one. All right, let's go. We can go. Go. 37:32 Yeah. All right, let's go. So the challenge is sustainability policy is dominated by a one-way future consisting only of growth. Now, when I think of ride sharing platform, the platform itself needs to be maintained. It needs to survive. It needs to be somehow online. Somebody needs to pay the cost for it being there, like the main servers. Everything needs to be there in place for everybody to use it, therefore it needs to get the money in. 38:02 And when we are talking about getting the money in, it's only about the growth. So having the ride sharing platform, it needs to grow somehow. It needs to get that profit. It needs to collect the fees. Meaning, how are we actually thinking about sustainability? It's actually more about, let's have that growth, let's have more rides, let's have more people working on the platform. Let's have, you know, more emissions by just having the rides. So it's not really the right approach towards how we take 38:30 care of the environment, how we take care of the ecology. It's more about just, let's grow, let's make more rides, let's make more jobs. So it kinda contradicts, um, the idea of having the communism approach, and it's far more actually going into the capitalistic, which I kinda like because, you know, it's all about the profit. But this is the challenge you're meeting. 38:54 Okay. If you stop with there, we have a regular vote now. 39:00 Okay. 39:01 Okay. Voting is open. How convinced is the audience of the storyline? Is this challenge 39:19 Relevant, realistic, imaginative 39:33 Who even needs a writer in platform? We have established places in cities to hitchhike and people just know by tradition. 39:41 And that's what you call a platform? 39:42 Oh, 39:43 yeah. That's what you call a platform? 39:45 Platform doesn't have to be online. Platform can be- 39:48 A dog. 39:50 That's also option. Yeah. See, see how restricted they are in their imagination. Hmm. It's already- 39:57 Yeah, we don't have to be online. We only use email, which is online. 40:02 I mean, platform is a, is a bunch of people getting together to do stuff. Hmm, yeah. And we can always make use of it- Mm-hmm … no matter whether it's digital or offline. 40:11 Okay. 40:11 We like both, right? 40:12 Yeah. So it's- And when you use email, then most of the emails are Gmail seems like you need a one or a 40:16 two to 40:16 make. Oh. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Go for it, Anya. It's not load 40:26 two … eager they are to get out of the right sharing. They, they really want out of the hands of the covenants. 40:31 Oh, no. 40:31 The- I'm trying to work out the average here. Is it three or two? 40:36 I mean, three because it's- 40:37 4.5 6.5, 7.4 divided by three is two… 40:45 7.4? 40:46 Yeah. I, I think that's- That's 40:48 under- Mm-hmm two point- 40:50 It's over 2.5? 40:51 No. 40:51 Yeah, it is. 40:52 I think so. 40:53 Mm-hmm. Yeah. Is it 7.4, did you get there? 40:54 7.4 divided by three. 40:56 That's… No. Oh, no. 7.5 by three is, uh, 2.5. No, it's 40:59 2.5. 41:00 So it is, it is- Okay. So it is a three … 41:02 2.4 41:02 something. But, yeah, it's three. Mm-hmm. Um, 41:03 because 2.5 conventionally goes to three. 41:06 But it's 2.4 something. 41:08 Yeah, you don't- 41:09 Aha. Okay. How- You need even to take a- How can we- How can we go for a small push? 41:14 Yeah. 41:14 There has to be some wiggle room for us. No. 41:18 Well, we still have- Better luck next time … the wiggle 41:21 room. 41:21 It's already on the board. Mm. 41:22 I think just hone, hone your narratives a little more and you'll get there. I think 41:27 we need to haunt the dice. 41:28 Yeah. 41:29 That's it. Let's do the… Keep the weight. 41:34 Okay. Oh, it's 41:35 me? It's your- 41:35 Yes. 41:36 Okay. 41:42 Mm-hmm. Okay No, no, um, 41:43 this, 41:44 this one. 41:44 Yeah. 41:44 Yeah. It's definitely very close. Okay. Five or six. One, two, three, four, five. 41:52 It's a lot. 41:52 Five we don't want, so six it is, no? Like five is they can co-opt 41:58 something. What, what happens if I count to five? 42:01 Uh, co-opt, like in principle, um, nothing happens. It's like if Team Capitalism lands on that field, like they can co-opt- 42:10 Okay. Okay, 42:10 so- … an initiative where you have something 42:12 Then, 42:12 uh, 42:13 then I go with six. Something. Go with six. Something, and the challenge there is that we basically lose ourselves in many different small scale struggles. 42:22 You- Mm. You're… Yeah, you're having a hard time connecting to broader change movements. 42:27 Yeah. Fragmentation. 42:29 Fragmentation. Okay 42:41 I think you should play my card 42:46 Well, all you need is to put it on and give a sentence, and then the others can- Yes … pick it up. Each 42:50 of us can- 42:51 Okay … 42:52 could say, "I have a good one. I'm gonna-" Yes. 42:55 Oh, okay. " 42:56 I'm gonna play," and then the, the others can chime in if, if we want to. 43:00 Sure. 43:00 Okay. Do, do you have a good one? 43:02 Yes. 43:02 Right. 43:03 It's, uh, futures festivals, pop-up spaces where diverse economic practices are co-created and performed. And the problem is, just to be sure, that marginalized local initiatives are having a hard time connecting to broader social change movements. So this is perfect, and Gregor is going to take it away. 43:20 Yeah, so it's, you know, like The Beatles said, "Come together." So, uh, I, I think there's not much, uh, to add. The more, uh, open the communication there is, the more we connect, the more we exchange the ideas, uh, the better we bring down the walls and, uh, we, uh, strengthen our unity. 43:41 I want to add also as, as we argued before- Just like Twitter. Thank you, Peko. It's not your turn. Just as we argued before, um, people coming together and shaping a shared vision, a grand vision of how all these different approaches to, to a different future, alternative future can be, uh, combined gives people huge energy and drive to actually work for these futures also for free. We don't need paychecks to do that. Thank you. Yeah, also raves. Also raves. 44:11 Oh, oh. No- I feel, I feel we should really challenge that. 44:14 Okay. 44:15 Voting is open. Yeah. It challenges itself. Like- 44:17 It cha- … 44:18 coming together just like Twitter builds unity. Mm. We have seen that. 44:22 No, but I'm saying he, you don't even have to 44:24 challenge. We're a festival. It's Twitter 44:28 festival. No, we, we at least give it the same chance. Mm. 44:28 You know, the capitalism kind of makes this a little bit quieter. We, we give it like… We bring it on the same footing. Maybe. 44:38 Okay. Mm. Go ahead. 44:44 Only a few people can afford- 44:46 Yeah … 44:48 to 44:48 get together. 44:49 Our, our futures festival is, uh, is for free obviously because we're all volunteering- 44:54 I'm sorry. This is- … for the festival … it's all a matter of privilege. Yeah. Yeah. Only privileged people can go there. Can volunteer. 45:00 Yeah. And also, it's for free and ob- obviously you get a space for it, and you can bring stuff to the festival for free. Like, you somehow magically conjure that stuff to be present. Next one. 45:13 You've got a three. Okay. One, two, or three wins it It's very unlucky both teams this time Yeah. 45:21 Hmm. Ready to turn the tables. You 45:24 think so? 45:27 All right. Uh. 45:29 All 45:29 right. 45:30 Who wants to throw? 45:31 You. 45:32 Okay, I'll throw. Four and two, and which piece is moving? 45:37 I think- 45:37 The right sharing, other piece … 45:39 I think mine is moving now. Yeah. 45:41 Yeah, the two heads. 45:42 Which piece is which? So where are we going? Are we going to the dao? 45:45 Oh, yeah, let's go to dao. Or wild card. Hmm. 45:47 Oh, yeah, the dao might be really nice. The 45:49 dao might be really, really nice. Yeah, it's, it really would reflect the dao history, which I think audience appreciates, like how- 45:54 Yeah the- Let's, let's go and 45:56 get the dao … red first and blue quite soon after 45:59 So here we are. 46:01 So cards. 46:02 So what do we have? Oh yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I think I have something. 46:14 Okay. Go for it. 46:15 But I would like you to- 46:17 Yeah 46:17 … 46:17 to jump on top. Taking part. I think what, what I really like about DAOs is the fact that, uh, that we live in a world of institutional fragmentation. There is no synergistic multi-sectory regulatory framework in sight. I really like that because that means, um, people can continue to play around with DAO. We're gonna have a lot of, um, chances to learn and to adapt strategies without 46:46 them being regulated by either nation states or other, um, yeah, I don't know, other groups, uh, of interest. And since this is really not, um, something I would anti- anticipate in the near future to have more regulations on DAO, I think it's a perfect playing field for us. 47:06 Mm. Yeah. Like, what are all the successful DAOs? They are financial organization. Financial organization or financial instruments. All the successful DAOs are essentially investment instruments, uh, in its- of themselves. And of course, they are then spaces that everybody can come in as long as they have the capita. Crypto is still capita because, like, you get crypto by having capita in the first place. 47:32 And I think finance side is very welcome to the idea that there is this new open investment targets that, because that's what they really are, because they have more capita to come in, which is why precisely almost all the DAOs that are out there being big are essentially not really different, different from the high scale finance that is happening in the traditional medium. It's the same action. 47:58 So turning well to finance, well then, the finance wins 48:03 Basically, if I understand, you like DAOs because you can evade regulations. 48:08 Yeah. It's a new financial instrument, and we have more money to put into any instrument, so yeah. 48:13 Well, when you think about the regulation as is right now, it's already Many more global stakeholders are actually creating the regulations that we see today. It's no longer just the nation states. It's no longer just- Mm … the regulators that we thought of before. It's quite often the corporations that i-i- Mm. If nothing else, they actually act from the lobbying side, from the- Mm shade. 48:34 So, so, so let me get that. 48:35 Just a moment. So Gregor kind of tricked you in going over two minutes- Aha … on your story. Aha. So- So now the, the team will have a chance to poke holes in your challenge once more. 48:46 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. 48:47 So- Okay. Let me get this straight. You argued that, um, on the one hand, basically you own regulations anyway, the field of getting regulation. As you said, co- corporations mainly now, uh, through institutions or, or just through lobbying, uh, get new, um, regulations in place. At the same time, you cherish DAOs and advertise for DAOs because they allow us all to leave that established field of regulations. Do you see, uh, the contradiction there? 49:15 No, be- because- Mm you misunderstood the argument. No. The argument is- Yeah … finance has been arguing for a long time of- But you- … removing all the regulation. That's the whole … That's why we made Brexit, is to have a place that- No … that has no regulation, because if you don't have regulation, money wins. 49:30 But your argument was premised on, on the false notion that all successful DAOs are only about financial instruments, which is obviously can only be true for a capitalist because you measure success in terms of money. But DAOs have had various effects across societies and countries, which people from other ideological standpoints would also argue have been very great successes if in nothing else, in creating actual change and disruption. 49:57 Which then has gathered money. Yeah, but we also measure DAOs by the amount of social interaction taking place, by the knowledge we gain in governance. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Uh, that's something we really cherish about DAOs. The, the monetary aspect, it's just like, it's just a tool that's being used. But what we challenge or what we like even more is really the social interaction. 50:19 So you just said you like the social interaction, but the question on the TV is what is a DAO? So my bet here would be that there is very little social interaction if people don't know what that is. 50:30 No, but it … The organization actually stands for the social interactions. It's the decentralized autonomous organization. Now, how you describe an organization depends on how you see the organization. But like, it's not 50:41 just a- I mean, just because you call it an organization, that doesn't mean anything yet. 50:44 Oh, for sure. Mm. Or a finance- It means that you have the liberty to describe and to interpret the way you want it. It's not a corporation necessarily. It's not an LLC. But you know, you have the liberty to define what the organization is that's- But it's, it's just 50:57 one dude doing code. It's not an organization even if he calls it an organization. Well, 51:01 it depends. A Bitcoin might be one of the best examples of a DAO. It's a smart contract, autonomous and decentralized. What else do you want? 51:08 You're, y- what you're doing now is the definition of moving the goalpost. You can't take DAO, which comes in direct opposition or succession to primary cryptocurrency technologies, and then say, "Oh, what we had 10 years ago was actually already a DAO." That's not how life works. 51:25 Well, well, it is precisely how life works. Definitions change. Like, in a way, DAO is just a term. It's, it- I don't think either they are really organizations. They are really just instruments in and of itself. Mm. And but if you look at where is the organization in crypto, then you can say Bitcoin is an organization, and it organizes people. Well, that's an organization of some sort. DAO is just a term that is traded here, but the key thing is that what 51:54 you can do with these instruments. And you said there's no social interaction. Actually, the finance said it's very interested in places where social interaction takes place in a form of finance. So there's a lot of interaction, mostly in, uh, financial terms, like where do we move our assets and what do we do with our assets? So it's financialization of the 52:15 world. A financial transaction can be a social interaction, but it doesn't have to be. For instance, all the bots trading, that's not a social interaction when it's just machines crunching numbers. 52:25 No, no, 52:25 but- Like, yes, people are doing coke in the same room, but they are doing coke, not trading. 52:30 Uh, yeah, but let's, let's be more specific what a social interaction is- Mm … because, I mean, it's … We learn a lot about people's preferences, uh, in DAOs, right? Mm. We, we understand better what they are ready to put their money in, and we understand better who has the power within DAOs. So for us, it's like a, it's a fantastic playing field to understand better the social dynamics of groups. 52:55 That's what you need DAOs for 52:57 Amongst other things. No. 52:59 And how would you multiplayer in the universe? We really need that. We need them as experiments, and when they come possibly impactful, then we can buy them. Because like, you can list how many- As anything in the 53:10 world potentially. 53:11 Yeah, like at least how many- In 53:13 your framework. 53:14 Yeah. Like, all the DAOs that have become big, you can trace down that okay, they were actually big amounts of money from BlackRock or whatever big financial player in itself that, that becomes the maker of the bigness. And e- even Ethereum now, a kind of mother or mothership of DAOs, is- is currently being more and more owned by traditional finance. Um, because it's becoming impactful, so we'll take it. 53:42 Look at the screen. So basically- No, save your words … 53:44 basically, I think- 53:45 Yeah, uh, yeah 53:45 Yeah. 53:46 Don't do extra work. Let's 53:47 save time. 53:48 The participants have spoken. Uh, I did like, you know, give more time also, 'cause it's- it's relevant to the topic of the conference. Yeah. And, uh, and yeah, it's sometimes nice to have a more in-depth discussion. Um, but it seems, yeah, Team Capitalism won this round. Was it you that you initially pitched a card, right? 54:08 You did. 54:10 I pitched a card. Yeah. 54:11 Yeah. 54:12 That is the one. 54:12 Yeah. 54:13 Yeah. 54:14 And it was for… DAOs. DAOs. 54:15 It was for DAOs. Yeah. 54:18 And then- Probably change this … do we get this? Yes. 54:20 And now we would like this to be changed. Thank you 54:29 The red one stays … 54:30 stays there or no? 54:31 Uh, yours stays there for now. 54:34 So this is, it, it belongs to no one kind of. 54:38 It, th- there's an active challenge on it, and if you land, you do have to address it. But once you do, you have kind of two tokens- Mm-hmm … not just one, 'cause you've al- already put in some effort. 54:48 Okay. I think it's time for a wild card. 54:51 Okay. 54:53 Wild card, please Or do you want to go down again? But you're red. Go down again. Oh, okay. 54:59 Yeah. You are- You take the white card. You want this one? 55:02 Yes. 55:03 Oh. 55:03 Yeah. Thank you. 55:05 Of course. You're welcome. 55:06 I will, I will read it out loud. Discord servers are down. Commoners need time to transition to a new and preferably open source communication platform. This means that for the next two turns, you can't complete each other's stories. Like, whoever pitches the intervention- That's okay … you're alone in pitching that intervention. Until you find the new- 55:31 This is- … Discord … this is just a way, uh, how we show our resilience. 55:35 Yes. Yes. 55:36 By being capitalists. 55:37 Yes. 55:37 By 55:37 being 55:38 decentralized. 55:38 Impro. By showing how we shine in decentralization. 55:43 I would call that isolation. Yeah. But I, I'm fine you calling it decentralized. Can I 55:50 win with other cards? I, first of all, I think I need a third card I want to have all my assets in place. Yeah. Thanks. I 56:01 get all of them. Yeah, I also think it's your 56:03 turn. Oh, yeah, it's your turn. Right. Okay. What do we 56:09 do? Which one? I'm on the co-work- co-ownership. 56:14 Yeah, this 56:14 one. Oh, what's that one? 56:19 Uh, it's jail. But if you go here, you're just visiting, just like Monopoly. Oh, 56:23 we're for sure not going to jail, huh? 56:25 No. One, two, three, four, five. 56:27 Well, it can 56:27 be fruitful to go to jail. Universal basic something. 56:30 So we can go to universal basic something. 56:32 You can pose another challenge there. 56:35 And then we get two? 56:36 Yeah. 56:37 Then we get a hold on that. 56:38 You basically lock in that position, and then you can o- Nice … if you land here, that's the only way to- To unlock … unlock that place. Mm-hmm. You play a Trojan horse. 56:47 Mm-hmm. 56:49 Well- 56:50 Yeah, then let's challenge, right? Unless we do have any business in jail. 56:57 Oh, you 56:57 do. 57:01 But you were the ones claiming that lawyers are not needed, so you're going to be- 57:05 This, this would be an owner's visit- … out of line … if we go to jail. 57:08 Yeah. But- Yeah. We were just visiting the commons. 57:10 Yeah. 57:11 And 57:11 stopping in that town. 57:12 As a lawyer, need to represent them, get some money across. Um, hmm. 57:18 Okay. So we have a moment to decide. Um, by the way, just a reminder for the audience that you can also in the comments or the Q&A, uh, in the Menti, um, submit other ideas for challenges and interventions, and I will write them down on cards and put them in the deck. So probably at some point- I would 57:43 say that universal basic 57:44 something is actually good during gameplay they will reach your card and have to play with it. It 57:48 seems almost 57:51 Why are they 57:52 looking at each other's 57:53 cards? Uh-huh. Mm. I know. 57:55 I 57:55 think that they will 57:56 play. 57:56 Because it's efficient and communicative. Yes. 57:59 I'm not sure if I fully understand 58:00 that card. Uh. 58:02 If we have … Let's look at the cards. Piko, do you have some- 58:06 No, I don't. Let's do play if you have playing. I should change one card. 58:10 We can change. Yeah, but one can imagine that capitalism is, you know, weak on solidarity. 58:16 We are simulating capitalism and our capability of playing slightly on the edges of the rules. 58:22 Do you have something? 58:23 Uh-huh. 58:24 Mm, 58:24 I'm not sure. 58:25 15 more seconds. Very generous How much you did bribe you Just play one 58:39 Mm. We could use this one 58:42 By the way, uh- 58:43 Challenging … 58:44 come on, guys The narrative Are we locked into this or can we exchange them? 58:47 Well No Well, they forfeit. Come on. Um, you mean the interventions? 58:50 Interventions, yes. You 58:51 go 58:51 for it and we'll combine powers. Yeah, yeah. Uh, well, yeah, you- Let's keep it under, I mean- As you use one, you get another. At, at this point there's no- 58:57 Okay … 58:57 option to do that. But a wi- Solidarity … one wild card is that you can actually- Yeah, yeah … see the first three and pick one which you like the most, and the others go in the bottom of the pile. 59:10 Yeah. So, uh, I think the question we want to ask is what is solidarity? And, uh, what is universal basic something? There is a, it's a very blurry, blurry space, and I don't think people have a clear idea of what it means, but everyone is kind of longing for it. So this in itself is very interesting. Um, we live in a world where we have a lot of fake news, alternative facts, 59:36 and social media conspiracies that lead to a fracturing of reality. So if we talk about universal basic something, we are basically touching down on people's, um, yeah, o- on a very romantic longing for everyone being equal. Um, but to be honest, uh, there are only few people that actually understand how it can be implemented and how it really plays out in the, in society at large, 1:00:04 and how it's going to impact the market. So, um, we kind of, uh, like, uh, this, this whole notion of the universal basic something because it's so… It's very, it's a very nice blur, and it's, uh, of course also allows us to implement, um, a number of really interesting initiatives and products that directly address that need. 1:00:30 So I think, um, for us, this is certainly a way to, um, continue investing and interacting. 1:00:40 Yeah. It's fake news that capitalists don't like, uh, universal basic anything. Like, it's actually, uh, many, many hardcore investment companies are, uh, lobbying for basic income. Um, one of the reasons is that because they have bought all the infrastr- infrastructure, like electric companies, by the way, and water companies, is that one of the things that the basic income does, it makes it sure that these kind of costs are being paid, and the v- and the value of these 1:01:09 companies raises significantly because they are essentially just money-making. Like, basic in- income is being paid. It's being, uh, piped into this basic needs, water, electric, gas, and then becomes just a surefire source of money. So they very much like the assurance of basic income as a, a good source of money for them. 1:01:31 Okay. Have to stop you there, um, and opening up the votes. Yeah 1:01:40 अच्छा। 1:01:50 Hiding results 1:02:01 Another 10 or so seconds 1:02:16 Okay. Pretty solid 1:02:18 Mm-hmm 1:02:19 That's still coming in 1:02:29 Seems like a four to me Four-ish. Four-ish. 1:02:37 Mm-hmm. 1:02:40 Okay. 1:02:40 So- 1:02:41 Will you do the honors? Yes. One to four. 1:02:43 Are you going … Okay, I do it. 1:02:45 Uh, one, one dice. Oh, just 1:02:47 one. Oh, sorry. Sorry. Okay. May the luck be on our side. Ugh. 1:02:55 It was not. 1:02:56 Damn. 1:02:57 The universe has spoken. Okay. Our turn. It's my 1:03:03 turn, I think. 1:03:04 Yeah, let me give it back 1:03:11 Two or two wild cards. Yeah Um, sure. 1:03:22 Reduces working time sounds good. Um, capitalism… No, communism. Mm. People have more time to co-create new economies. 1:03:31 Yeah, let me just- That 1:03:32 means it's good … and, 1:03:35 uh, yeah, this 1:03:36 is- Reduced working time … 1:03:37 this is the type of card it, it depends who picks it, and the one who picks it has a beneficial effect. Um, and in this case, communism ha- team has 30 more seconds to tell their story for three turns. 1:03:53 Uh-huh. 1:03:54 So you have a bit more time to argue your intervention 1:03:57 for 1:03:58 the next three. And one turn already 1:03:59 passed on our Discord breakdown? 1:04:02 Uh, no, it's from now. 1:04:04 But- 1:04:04 You haven't 1:04:05 spoken yet … uh, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. You, you haven't… No, that's still in effect, so- 1:04:10 But only for one more turn. It's only one more left. 1:04:11 Yeah, for one more round. For 1:04:13 one more. Yeah. Oh, for one more. Yeah, I was just too late. Okay. Getting, getting Discord soon back up. All right. 1:04:19 Which means that we get longer leftist monologues. Yes. 1:04:22 Mm-hmm. 1:04:23 Everything is… Everything in all this new again. Mm-hmm. Um- Four or two. And this was the… This one, I think. Yes. 1:04:39 So again, Dals? 1:04:40 Uh, we kind of have something on, already on. But the other one is wild card. 1:04:46 Yeah. Yeah, what would happen if we go to Dal now, and can we then lock in 1:04:50 if, if- Yeah, it's the same as we were discussing for that one. Yeah. 1:04:53 Okay. 1:04:53 Present and win new challenge, you lock in this thing. Yeah. 1:04:57 Okay. 1:04:58 I think we should go for the wild card though. He just wants to trap you into Dals. 1:05:03 I, I mean, we could also let the audience decide. Um- 1:05:08 Yeah 1:05:12 I mean, we could take a risk and just go to the wild card. Yeah. It's also more interesting. I think the DAO will anyway get… Whatever, whatever happens in the game, we'll, we'll get it. This is just a- I think so too … demonstration. 1:05:23 Yeah. 1:05:23 Yeah. So- Let's, 1:05:24 let's risk 1:05:24 it. Let's risk a 1:05:26 risk. Let's show our 1:05:26 confidence- Mm-hmm by going to wild card. 1:05:29 Okay. What goes up must come down. This hype cycle is over- … and the market is declared dead once again. So what happens is both team, both teams lose one die for two turns. Oh. Meaning that- Oh … you only have one die. 1:05:47 Mm-hmm. 1:05:47 We're going 1:05:48 to be rested. Well, the markets affect everybody. The markets affect everyone. 1:05:51 Yeah. 1:05:52 Well, we've been talking about DAOs a lot, having a- Yeah, mm. It's, uh… 1:05:56 All right. One is all we need. Four. So 1:06:03 at least- 1:06:04 Yes … 1:06:04 well. 1:06:05 So it's- Yeah, we just claim- I guess you have to- … ecovillages … mm-hmm. We claim the ecovillages. Yes. Yes. Obviously, they're ours. And, uh- And this goes away … the wild card… No, this one? 1:06:16 Yeah, this 1:06:17 one. The last, 1:06:17 yeah. 1:06:17 The Discord- Is it three now? … episode is over, yes. And it's 1:06:22 just two more. 1:06:23 And what about this? 1:06:24 Yeah. 1:06:24 Oh, 1:06:24 yeah. 1:06:25 I think that 1:06:25 one's- This is ours? 1:06:26 That's ours. What goes up- 1:06:28 For how long is this? 1:06:30 That one's for two turns. 1:06:32 Here we go. So one, two, or…? 1:06:35 No, no. That is for us. Like, each team 1:06:43 Which one is you? 1:06:46 I'm this one. Yeah. 1:06:47 Oh, another wild card. Another wild card. Let's go. Going wild now. 1:06:52 Uh, wash trade. You produce and buy your own NFTs in order to drive their price up, making a lot of money in the process. 1:07:01 Mm-hmm. 1:07:01 Well, it's like, you know, crypto has crashed, but, uh, like, like this- The NFCs sort of argument. 1:07:07 Well, like, like the, I don't know, withdrawing funds from FTX to go- Uh-huh. … buy llamas and 1:07:13 their houses. Yeah. Those are like the end of this 1:07:14 deck. So what this means for capitalism, since they drew it, is you establish the Lazy Llama Yacht 1:07:22 Club. 1:07:23 Your eco chamber has become more resilient. 1:07:25 Yes. 1:07:26 This means that whenever a card comes into play which would disable you from communicating or, like, everyone pitching the story together, this will enable you to actually counter that. Mm-hmm. 1:07:39 For once. It's like a- 1:07:41 For once, yeah. Oh. It's a whole card- Try free of that … that you can use, yeah. 1:07:44 That's a good one. 1:07:45 Uh-huh, so we can go back into communication. 1:07:48 Yeah. Mm-hmm. If you get a wild card that prevents you- 1:07:50 I 1:07:51 see … from doing that- Uh-huh … then you can veto it with that card. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Lazy llamas. I think that's- 1:07:56 Lazy llamas 1:07:57 That beats us, yeah. 1:07:58 The Lazy Llama Yacht Club. 1:08:00 Okay. 1:08:01 Good. Saving it says leisure everywhere. L- L-L-A-Y-C. Okay. As long as the CEC is not after us- … should be fine. 1:08:15 Uh-oh 1:08:15 Running. 1:08:16 On the edge. 1:08:17 One. Which one? So, uh, somebody please move, uh, the red two-headed- Go to prison You're 1:08:23 not going by yourself into prison. Go to 1:08:25 prison. What, what's happening now? 1:08:27 Oh, they're just visiting prison. Uh-huh. 'Cause that one is go to jail. 1:08:30 Uh-huh. 1:08:31 Alex. I want to consult my, uh, um, capitalist informants- 1:08:35 He went to visit at times 1:08:36 who have ended up in prison to know exactly what I need to do for everyone else when I visit prison. 1:08:43 You guys ready? 1:08:46 Mm-hmm. 1:08:49 Well, I guess I'm gonna go… Ah. 1:08:52 It's you. 1:08:52 Yeah. Oh, that's me. Yeah. Community currency. 1:08:54 Mm-hmm. 1:08:55 All right, let's claim that 1:08:56 one. We need to present a challenge. 1:08:58 For sure we need community currency, huh? Oh, I think I have a challenge that actually tracks results Local resilience 1:09:13 Go for it from my side 1:09:15 Then 1:09:15 it's like a challenge. Yeah, go for it. Yeah, yeah. Go for it. Yeah, go 1:09:18 for it. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. 1:09:19 Yeah. 1:09:19 All right. So we have a very straightforward challenge. People are too focused on local resilience rather than systemic drivers of global change, and I do believe that this is exactly what the community currency does. It focuses on the local narratives, on what the local communities need, rather than actually having an overview of how we are interconnected on this planet, how we share all the assets, how we do live in abundance or, you know, scarce resources that we need to take care of collectively. 1:09:50 So instead of really thinking about a collectivism, the common approach, um, it's rather building on the local needs, um, and disregarding all the rest of the world, basically. So having that local, uh, resilience and focus actually prevents us from doing something better for the world that we share and live in together. 1:10:11 Yeah, and community currency's like, actually if you think the end game, they are driving competition. Like if- Yeah … let's say all the communities would have a community currency, they would be in a competitive state. Because if you look at how you build a community currency, you have to kind of build business relations and so on, and you have to have to get this business to get bonus and so on. Like, if this city and that city would have a community currency, they are k- 1:10:34 kind of in a competitive state in itself. Like, alone, community currency- No it's community building. Sometimes it's struggling in- But together they would be just a bunch of companies in a way. Uh, and this is why, like, community currencies are, yeah, just another form of an economic enterprise. Uh, like, so we're not worried. We own it already. It's, it's like building enterprise models. 1:10:58 Yeah, and we are, we 1:10:59 are working- So it's you to see you're, you're struggling in with your own, uh, framework and the limitedness of your framework. But just in competition. 1:11:06 Um, that was like, what did that even mean? Like- … what was the struggle? 1:11:12 Yeah, that's it. 1:11:12 And, uh, please don't forget that we are already working on exchanges where you can exchange your comm- Mm your currency, uh, um, with other community currencies. So there's, I really see an emerging market here. 1:11:26 Yeah. 1:11:26 Be it as local as it is, but, you know- 1:11:31 I think you're afraid of 1:11:33 community currencies. 1:11:34 Mm-hmm. No, we s- we see it as a repetitive pattern. 1:11:37 Yeah. I, I find it interesting that you don't have an argument, just an opinion. 1:11:42 We agree, but- We have 1:11:43 arguments. We're just trying to respect the 1:11:44 rules. 1:11:45 Oh, yeah. 1:11:46 Voting is open for this round, and it's for the capitalists, but you're welcome to argue while the, uh, votes come in. And we have another, uh, question or comment Oh, yes Could be another intervention 1:12:14 Sounds like an echo village. 1:12:15 Okay, I'll take the time next round to write this on one of the cards, and we'll put it in the game 1:12:24 I mean, it has clearly been seen, like, with history and all that, uh, one global currency favors, uh, capitalism favors one global currency. I mean, you can speak about exchanges, yeah, like you think of the petrodollar, you know, and, like, all the guns being moved, uh, when this thing comes threatened. So, um- 1:12:43 I 1:12:43 mean, but the- Community currency empowers, uh, empowers local people. It's basically empowers, uh, a fairer distribution and, uh, self-management. It's kind of taking away the le- levers of control from capitalism. 1:12:56 Obviously, yeah, Fred tried to drive us back into- Yes … uh, the global narrative, um- 1:13:02 I 1:13:02 mean, 1:13:03 you cannot- 1:13:03 But, 1:13:03 but currencies don't exist in one layer. Like, having actual local currencies is building like local businesses- Well, you are right. But who was it that- … but that doesn't remove the fact that there can be a global currency underneath … that questions I mean, crypto is an example of this. There can be a 1:13:16 global currency. Also, also please do not forget that with most community currencies, they do not work without political incentivization. Mm. So that's, that's another thing. Um- 1:13:28 I would say, you know, I would go h- back to the WIR, you know. Have you heard of the WIR currency? 1:13:33 The WIR? 1:13:33 Yes. 1:13:34 Still active in Switzerland, you know. Yeah. So, and it's kinda, kinda it enables and gives like this inspiration and space for actually other currencies to be developed, and it started long before- D- yeah like early 20th century. 1:13:46 But this is good. Like, in itself, like, uh, these structures are in and of themselves building competitive spots, like, ultimately. The more they are, the more it becomes a competition. 1:13:58 But why do you think competition equals capitalism? 1:14:01 No, it doesn't necessarily. 1:14:03 Okay, but you keep presenting it as such. Every time you go and say, "Well, this is competition, so obviously it's capitalism," that's… No, I refuse. 1:14:10 But, I mean, think about it practically. If, if your city is suddenly thinking, "Oh, we need to get ahead, and let's, uh, negotiate with these businesses," whether that's capitalism or not doesn't really matter, but is it communism? No. Yes, 1:14:24 because we're in this together. 1:14:26 So then, uh, corporations are communism to you? 1:14:31 Yeah, obviously. 1:14:33 Okay, yeah, good. Then we are communists. I'm good. 1:14:36 That's, uh… Okay. 1:14:38 Throw the dice. 1:14:39 One, two, or three? 1:14:42 It's a six. It's a six. 1:14:43 Unlucky. 1:14:46 I think I can use two dice again. 1:14:48 Uh, yeah. I think 1:14:49 it's- That one is over … it's 1:14:51 over. 1:14:51 No, that, that one. That one is over. This one is also over, the time? Uh… Could be, like the… 1:14:58 Oh, yeah, sorry. Yeah 1:15:03 No, this one is better. This one was the one die. Al- 1:15:06 also the one for, 1:15:07 for- Oh, also. 1:15:08 Mm-hmm. 1:15:09 Okay. Six. Six it is. Um, one, two, three, four, five, six. 1:15:18 Mm. 1:15:19 Yes. Flame it. And we just take it, yeah. I mean- Again, the universe has spoken … we, we saw them fail miserably. 1:15:27 David. 1:15:28 Universe loves us. 1:15:32 Okay, who was 1:15:33 last? Putting the things into the right place, 1:15:35 I guess. Uh, Anya. 1:15:36 You are. Okay, so, so it's me. Two and two. So we are simulating the one die. And, um, and- Fairphone … I was this one. So we go to Fairphone. 1:15:48 Mm. 1:15:50 Good luck with that. 1:15:54 Okay. I have something 1:16:02 Mm. 1:16:03 I have a decent one. 1:16:05 Mm-hmm. That's 1:16:05 great. I 1:16:05 have nothing for Fairphone. 1:16:06 Yeah. 1:16:07 Okay. 1:16:08 Neither. 1:16:09 So Fairphone here can be looked as a higher topic. Like, what kind of ecosystems of phones that there are, and like the ecosystems of phones is maybe the most important battleground, uh, of where do you control people, where do you have the informations of people, um, they're more important than software. 1:16:36 This is, by the way, Firefox Foundation considered the biggest failing, and one of the reasons they tried to make a new ecosystem of phones is because of the importance for the future culture and its control. So- Fairphone, uh, that would be one company, but it's more this question of who owns the ecosystem in itself. And the key part of the current phones is too big to fail. 1:17:06 So the card is lobbying power and media's way of too big to fail companies and transnational conglomerates. The whole phone sy- ecosystem, talk about iPhone and particularly Android, is too big to fail, but in a more resil- resilient way than banks. They're too big to fail b- because they are very hard to remove. Um, like all of these functions of these phones, like Android phones 1:17:32 and iPhones, is making it harder and harder for you to remove y- from… Yourself from that. But it would be much harder to remove a lar- large sway of the population to another kind of an ecosystem. So we, in itself, we want to control the phones, and we have a bi- too big to fail strategy, and it's a very massive strategy with the massive amount of 1:17:59 money, not just by Google and Apple, but all the companies that connect to those ecosystems, and it's a key area for us, and that's why we want to control the 1:18:10 Fair- 1:18:11 So you're 1:18:11 just denying the existence of Fairphone. Okay. 1:18:13 Yes. So wasn't Nokia considered too big to fail? 1:18:16 Yeah. 1:18:17 Doesn't just innovation introduce new possibilities? 1:18:21 Well, first of all, we, uh, ignore Fairphone 1:18:24 because- So the little kids need to die in the lithium mines to make the batteries or should, should- Of 1:18:29 Fairphones? 1:18:30 No, with Fairphones, Fairphones, it's basically they do ethical, uh- Mining sourcing. These words mean nothing to him. 1:18:38 Okay. So first of all, we ignore Fairphone because one choose- adjust the amount of argument given to its size, and given that the size is like this, we ignore it. 1:18:48 You can't ignore Fairphone if it says 1:18:55 Fairphone. For us, it's a topic. How many Fairphones do you guys have? But like any politics, like you're talking- Are 1:19:02 there any Fairphones at the table? You 1:19:03 are talking politics 1:19:05 like- Because I would say communism owns Fairphones, not capitalism. And this is- 1:19:09 They're all micro percent of it, yes, yes. But like you're saying, you're approaching this like that is completely against like, let's say, a political debate. You say to a politician this and that, and then the whole politics is to answer something else. Um, to find a way how you move from whatever you asked me to the topics that I need to talk. 1:19:31 But I'm not going to let you move. 1:19:33 Um- 1:19:33 He's the annoying guy on TV that does- The question is, do you like people dying in mines just so you can browse the internet? 1:19:39 Um, we can definitely make a phone, and we do make some phones where you can make that choice, just not in Fairphone, but in, say, Android phones. Those do exist. And they're, by the way, bigger than Fairphone. 1:19:50 It's … Th- this argument sounds to me like high school kids saying, "I've got a girlfriend, but she goes to a different school." 1:19:57 The problem that you're actually having is that- … if you really want to compose and build all the components of a Fairphone, you will have to invest plenty of money into the research. They already 1:20:06 did. 1:20:06 No, no, so they already did, but- It- it's, it's like- What I'm trying to tell you is that- State of denial somebody already invested. 1:20:11 Literally. Yes. 1:20:12 Yes. And somebody already put the capital. It was a non- … non-profit organization from the Netherlands. Right. The non-profit, the non-profit doesn't mean there's no capital. Mm. The non-profit actually just means that somebody did not actually profit out of it. Right. That does not mean that there is not capital invested in it. Whenever you hear communist, just think we build stuff with sticky cells. There's 1:20:32 plenty of capital that has been inside of it, and that has been backing the whole idea. I know, but the idea of capitalism isn't that- The capitalism doesn't profit share … because you have capital, therefore it's capitalism. Capitalism means that just because you have capital- Mm-hmm … without putting in any work or any natural resources, you can get more capital out of it So we're perfectly fine with saying you need capital to do stuff. You need social capital, cultural capital, symbolic capital, et cetera. Exactly. 1:20:51 That does make you a 1:20:52 capitalist. 1:20:52 Yeah. 1:20:53 No, no, no, no. It absolutely does. What makes you a capitalist is believing that just because you have €100 on your bank account, you should have €110 on your bank account tomorrow. Whereas we say, "If you have €100 on your bank account, good for you. You have €100 on your bank account." But if you want an extra €10, you should do something for it. 1:21:12 We 1:21:12 absolutely 1:21:13 support 1:21:13 that. Yeah, we absolutely support your version of non-capitalism. You should be working for that €10, like- Yeah … everybody. 1:21:18 Is that right? 1:21:19 So, 1:21:20 yeah. 1:21:20 But also, I mean, let's, let's look at it from a design perspective. My question is, is, is the Fairphone actually delivering? Yes. Yeah, that's the- So that, that is the big question and then we are already working on feel-good phones anyways that allow people to, you know, to own a phone that is ethically sourced- Mm-hmm … without going through all the challenges that you have to do. 100% Because only- It's called modular … only p- o- only privileged 1:21:43 people can- Create a working- … can make- Feel-good … invest the time- 1:21:47 Mm … 1:21:47 uh, in order to get a live, a Fairphone to run. 1:21:50 Hmm. 1:21:50 And- No, that's 1:21:51 just 1:21:51 a lie … and we'll offer a shortcut on the market that make you feel really good about your product, uh, and still offering the, all the great, fantastic UX, UI, um, journey that you are, that you know from iPhones or similar devices. So I think there's a lot from us to take away and learn, but I do not believe in the success of the Fairphone and its capacity to really 1:22:17 We are completely- 1:22:18 State of denial, but audience has spoken. But, you know, reality doesn't go away if you close your eyes. Oh. 1:22:23 I mean, we are happy to include Fairphone in the market because it won't grow. Like, I mean, you can show the one phone, but that's a great sign of the situation of Fairphone 1:22:35 I mean, it's, it's a phone, it works, it's delivered to people, it sells, the company isn't going bust. All we need is time, right? So the first time Steve Jobs showed up with an iPhone, were you to make the argument- he's just holding a single iPhone in his hand, this is never gonna work, people would laugh you out the room. You're making the same argument 1:22:57 now. No, thi- this 1:22:57 was- 1:22:58 No, 1:22:58 that's- … a metaphor of the size of 1:22:59 Fairphone. That's… Uh, which is rather different. It's rather different. Like, yeah, yeah. Like, like actually, like part of the market resilience is to have other voices, and it's completely fine to have 5% or 10% of something that is counter to your interests- Ooh, I understand because it's a, it's a ventilation system. 1:23:17 You 1:23:17 need 1:23:18 Fairphone for greenwashing. 1:23:19 Yes. 1:23:20 Mm-hmm. Of course. 1:23:21 Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And we'll do our own- 1:23:23 But it, but it can be any other phone … greenwashing phone. We are doing it 1:23:25 right now. 1:23:25 Uh, we are working on a feelgood phone that just does the same as Fairphone does- Okay but it's much cheaper- Yes … and it has a much better support. Oh, great. It looks better. 1:23:34 Yeah. 1:23:34 And it's going to be- You just can't repair it. It's going… Yeah, you, of course you can't repair it. Yeah. I'm sorry. Yeah. Who has the time to repair their phones? Yeah, yeah. Probably only you, but- Then it doesn't feel 1:23:43 good 1:23:44 most people, ask the people in the room whether they have time to repair their phones. I, I don't think so. 1:23:49 Do you like buying new phones every year or so after the warranty is over? 1:23:55 It doesn't matter. If you keep on buying them, that's enough. 1:24:00 Or you buy a Fairphone. 1:24:03 We're fine including it because we don't think enough people will buy it that it will really matter. 1:24:08 That is the problem. Yeah. You recycle 1:24:09 the, the old phone better. I think we're going in circles now. 1:24:12 Yeah. Yeah. 1:24:12 But like if you- Yeah, yeah. 1:24:13 Yeah. 1:24:13 And I think, uh- 1:24:15 Five, six minutes would be the limit … votes have been, have been, uh, 1:24:17 casted. 1:24:17 Yeah. 1:24:18 Yeah. In the favor of communism. Yeah. Just to note that, you know, at the end you were very convincing, but I think most of the votes had, had gone in at that point already. 1:24:27 Mm-hmm. Yeah. Time is money, again. 1:24:31 That's a con 1:24:32 for 1:24:32 you. 1:24:35 You guys struggle 1:24:35 it It works. 1:24:39 That sounds 1:24:39 nice. 1:24:41 Over there. Okay. With the two. Some. Everything except the six ones. 1:24:46 Mm-hmm. 1:24:47 Yeah. 1:24:48 Ah, the police don't even care. Mm-hmm. 1:24:51 Okay. One or three. The workers council with homo economicus or ReFi is, uh, abused by virtue signaling scams. Okay 1:25:13 I'll be back in a minute. I should hear a story when I return back. 1:25:17 I would like to address, uh, toilet breaks. Yeah. 'Cause we don't like toilet breaks so much. Hm. But, uh, we know that workers take toilet breaks every now and then. 1:25:26 Do we need toilet breaks? Do we need toilet breaks? No. No? 1:25:28 Okay. We trained you. 1:25:29 We trained you. Yeah. You, you can go without. 1:25:32 Yeah. But- That's what, that's what the bottles are for. You drink, and then you use it. Yeah. 1:25:38 There might be a point though when- 1:25:40 So be careful with 1:25:41 the 1:25:41 drinks … when we will have 1:25:42 to take a toilet break. 1:25:43 Hm. 1:25:44 Yeah. But I'm, I'm, I'm curious how we're gonna handle it. 1:25:47 Well, 1:25:47 it's 1:25:48 always- Anytime you want to leave the table, you are free to leave the table. Hm. But, you know, like, if you leave the house, you lock the 1:25:54 main door. You are free to leave the table. Hm. 1:25:57 Yeah. It's good that you allow it 'cause you're not allowed to leave the table. 1:26:00 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we can do it, but the clock is ticking. 1:26:02 Hm. Yeah. 1:26:03 And time might work against our favor, so. 1:26:06 Until when do we play the game? 1:26:09 We shall see. I think we could do toilet breaks also, like if one person goes, leaves too, we can still play. Yeah, true. Yeah, yeah. Like, and we could delegate, like if it comes- Yeah … it's their turn once they're on the break, then they delegate. Yeah, 1:26:22 that's a good solution. Yeah. 1:26:22 We are very free to exchange power, as long as it stays on our side 1:26:32 Anybody want some cookies? French hearts We are so 1:26:34 good we can even go to 1:26:36 toilet 1:26:36 Should we break the rules and ask for audience comments? One 1:26:38 is with chocolate, one is with jam. 1:26:40 Nice. 1:26:42 Um- 1:26:42 It looks like an item of the game. 1:26:44 True. Okay. Should we make a price of… Oh, Robert's coming back, so it's hard to break the rules. I was thinking of making a price of a cookie for an audience comment. 1:26:54 Hmm, nice. 1:26:55 Like, audience comment would get a cookie 1:27:02 Into the dark side we 1:27:04 go Yeah. No decision yet? No. Uh, we need to decide. Are we playing 1:27:08 one? 1:27:08 They 1:27:08 need 1:27:08 to cheat 1:27:09 first. 1:27:10 We're playing one? 1:27:11 We're playing one? 1:27:12 For generative finance. 1:27:13 Uh, yes, we play one. We play one. Uh, come on, we- I have nothing. You- No, no, no. We, we, so we either go with this or with this one 1:27:35 Six, 1:27:36 five- Go with this one … four- 1:27:38 Okay … 1:27:38 three- 1:27:39 Give, give yours … two- Okay. Yeah. Okay. 1:27:40 One. 1:27:41 So that's it? Go on. Okay. So the intervention is, um, you present alternatives to neoliberal policies at discussion tables at the next climate negotiations. This is very timely. Uh, there's now the COP meeting again, and we see that it's not working. It's even so, so bad at it that even Greta doesn't show up. Mm. 1:28:07 Um, and, uh, essentially, uh, here, uh, here comes the, uh, REFI into play. Here it's, uh, where REFI basically p- uh, presents that it's a win-win situation, and, uh, it doesn't matter if we're capitalists or commoners, we still live in the same planet. And obviously, the policies right now are just being too capitalistic driven by self-agendas. And of course, because of that, the capitalism then is interested to discredit 1:28:37 the REFI movement and turn it into a meme. While presenting alternatives to it and showing there is a better way to do it, basically negates that and also leads to a better future 1:28:53 Okay Votes are open 1:29:05 How is ReFi not capitalistic? 1:29:07 I mean, it's essentially the most capitalistic side of crypto besides the default one, I think. 1:29:14 Right. 1:29:14 Yeah. It's like, let's take, uh, environmental conditions and put finance on it. 1:29:20 Right. 1:29:20 Mm. 1:29:22 But, but what is… what exactly would we consider as ReFi? I mean, carbon, uh, certificates, et cetera, is not ReFi, right? I mean, do we have, like, really good ReFi projects? 1:29:32 Exactly for this reason, there needs to be alternatives presented at these meetings, 'cause, uh, obviously the capitalist side is too much locked into, uh, its frame of thinking. 1:29:43 I mean, there's Toucan. 1:29:44 Consider carbon 1:29:44 credits not ReFi. But all of these projects that I think of, they are built on- They are, they are- the idea of capitalism actually- They are core to the capitalist economy … being the driving force- Exactly. Yeah … of them succeeding in this game. It's like capitalism reinvented. 1:29:56 Yeah. 1:29:57 Yeah. But it's still capitalism- Yeah … in its core. 1:29:59 Yeah. So how is Toucan protocol different then? Yeah. 1:30:02 It's- 1:30:02 Getting better 1:30:04 like they're tokenizing the carbon credits, sure, but it's not dr- different from the capitalist- It's 1:30:10 not really, 1:30:11 but- It, uh- 1:30:12 Ella, why don't you consider carbon projects ReFi? 1:30:16 It's not that they are not ReFi. 1:30:18 No, I was wondering, uh, out loud whether we can consider it as a ReFi project or not. I'm, I'm not even sure. I'm asking the question. 1:30:26 I mean, it's a capitalist project at 1:30:28 least. Yeah, 1:30:28 it's a capitalist project. I mean, it was proposed by finance side of things, like the whole carbon credits was- 1:30:39 above 3.5. I- It's like the average is- 1:30:42 No. 11 point… 1:30:44 I think, yeah, 11 point something divided by three is already four. 1:30:49 Yeah. 1:30:49 More than three. 1:30:51 Just roll the dice. It's gonna be fine. 1:30:53 Okay, can throw. Maybe it's… Yeah. Okay. 1:30:57 Hm. 1:30:58 Yes. 1:30:59 So now- Thank you … the, the blue ones lose the chit. 1:31:02 Um- Now there comes another. You add one to the- 1:31:06 Now it's both. 1:31:07 Up, 1:31:07 sorry. Okay. 1:31:08 No worries. 1:31:09 Like 1:31:09 this? 1:31:10 Yeah. 1:31:10 Yeah, it goes like 1:31:11 that. So it's, it's 1:31:12 not one to seven. But, but you, you can intervene once more to lock it in for yourself. Okay. 1:31:17 You'll need another cop. 1:31:19 But, but we do keep these because a- at some point we will have to close the game, and it's by counting these that we will decide the winner of 1:31:27 the team. But basically, if it's, if it's really about making a win, we have to make it until at least the second round to be able to lock in, right? 1:31:35 Mm. 1:31:36 No, we can also… Like, three of us can- 1:31:39 Yeah, we 1:31:39 can- Like, it, it depends what's this- … prevent 1:31:41 the, the locking of- … 1:31:42 the 1:31:42 state of the board … 1:31:42 those rounds. Yeah, to… Yeah. No, I'm, I mean to really make sure that, for instance, refi goes to the commoners. 1:31:48 Mm. 1:31:48 I mean, or another commoner comes up and kicks your butt. 1:31:52 Mm-hmm. Mm. 1:31:52 Okay. It could happen. Or we go here. But right now it's, it's like it's still open, right? Yeah. Yeah. 1:31:57 For us it's good to go the first turn, you know? Yeah. So we can… We have three spots to claim. Yeah, yeah. Okay. Who's next? 1:32:05 Who throws the dices? 1:32:07 Who is it? You. I think it's me. Yeah. Yeah, it's me. 1:32:11 It was you. 1:32:13 So we could go to Fairphone. 1:32:17 I, I… This one? 1:32:18 Oh, this one actually would be much better. 1:32:19 One, 1:32:19 eight. 1:32:19 Oh, yeah. I'm, I'm sorry. It would go here. I was, I was attracted here by the- Yeah. Jail or- Jail we don't go … or, or FabLab … or we go to 1:32:27 the FabLab. 1:32:27 Let's go FabLab. 1:32:28 That's nice. I think I have a, I have a good one here. Yeah. Yeah. So- Yeah, 1:32:33 I'm taking one burger. … 1:32:35 talking about the- Okay … about the FabLabs, um- 1:32:39 Can I get one more intervention? 1:32:49 Yeah, uh, I, I think I really-- we really like Fab Labs because they are a perfect, um, training ground for larger industrial solutions. And what my challenge here says that there is a capturing of innovation space, um, by design elites with stakes vested in the status quo. So, uh, what's actually happening very often, and I guess you have all seen it, that, uh, there, there's a lot of, uh, potential in Fab Labs and 1:33:19 other initiatives, but then we end up with, uh, the same UX/UI components. We end up with the same design, uh, uh, visions, and they are not really distinct from what we already have on the market. So in that sense, Fab Labs, to us, can really turn into a, a very profitable- Mm … training ground, and we don't even have to pay for it because all the solutions end up, um, in a very similar, uh, shape and form as the market already has. 1:33:49 So I think I'm all up for investing more into Fab Labs- Mm … but I'm also very conscious of bringing the right people into Fab Labs, making sure that we have exactly those people that understand design, that, uh, understand data, that understand people's needs. Yeah. And I have many good examples of Fab Labs like that. 1:34:12 Yeah, it's kind of rep- uh, repetition of our strategy towards open source, which is that, um, actually open source is a field that is then captured to capitalist products, like Android for example. It's open source, but it actually is now the biggest operating system in the world and highly in control of Google and partners in itself. And similarly, IBM is operating on open source. 1:34:36 Red Hat, which were used to be, uh, the, uh, Red Linux, uh, distribution, was sold for sixteen billion for IBM. I might w- don't remember the sum. Might be sixteen billion, might be twenty-two. Um, b- this is all capitalization of open source. So we see open source as a field which creates these things, and there can be this heart that is the open source, true open source. But for us, it's, it's a laboratory where people are developing things which we can then capture into products. 1:35:05 Same for Fab Labs, like they are a laboratory develop- to be develop things that we can capture into products, and we have more power in the product capturation. And it works for open source, it, so it will work for this as well. 1:35:20 Okay, that's within two minutes, so we're going with the classic, uh, vote, and voting is open 1:35:29 Makes so much sense. We need to start open source and then refinance it- Yeah … somehow so that it becomes sustainable. Eventually it becomes- 1:35:37 Yeah, but you know- So- Every, every big corporation has a FabLab. It can be ours and it can be co-opted. It's- Yeah. Yes … it's already, that's open innovation. 1:35:44 We can have our 1:35:45 own whatever. 1:35:45 Um. 1:35:46 Or let them fund FabLabs. 1:35:47 That's capitalism participating in the making of the open source. Let them fund FabLabs and create our 1:35:50 tools. 1:35:51 Yeah. It's almost like giving back to the society. We also have 1:35:53 that potential. 1:35:53 But still through the capitalism. Yeah. I mean, it's, 1:35:55 it's pure, uh, it's a ritual. Thank you very much. It's an open source ritual. 1:35:59 So can we- And, 1:35:59 and we 1:36:00 like to play it. Like, like JavaScript creating its 1:36:01 own domain. 1:36:01 Has been, has been restorative. Yeah. We see how that well worked, you know. But, um, it's good. We like, well, also like the, you know, 1:36:08 the crypto. Yeah. Just, just pour all resources into open source. Thank you very much. 1:36:12 Yeah. Yeah. We will because we'll 1:36:14 get more. Yeah. Do it. 1:36:15 Do 1:36:15 it. 1:36:15 We'll 1:36:15 cover 1:36:15 it. No, we'll get more back. Yeah, yeah. Like, like the case of, uh, Android, for example. 1:36:19 Yeah. 1:36:20 Like Linux has produced a lot of profit, a lot of profit, and more than Samsung and IBM has poured into it. They have poured a lot into Linux, but Linux has made way more profit. 1:36:35 Okay. It's over three, but it's not quite a four. So- So what do we do? Three… One, two, three. 1:36:41 We throw dice and 1:36:42 it has to be one, two, three. One, two, three. Yeah. You pitch the stories. One, two, or three gets you a lock in. It really is- … unlucky for everyone. 1:36:57 Yeah. We have to change that. So 1:37:04 Distribution 1:37:08 Okay, out of prison. 1:37:13 Is it- 1:37:14 No, we're not talking about Fab Labs. 1:37:17 And its community currency. Mm. We could just 1:37:18 lock that in. 1:37:19 Yeah. Yeah, let's lock 1:37:20 that in. Sure. 1:37:21 No, no. No, no. 1:37:23 Okay. 1:37:23 No. I don't want any of your capitalist- … fingers on it. 1:37:29 No corrupting of the workforce. 1:37:30 We have a transport tool that could- … give any use, uh, easily. 1:37:34 But, you know, roads take away the use value of your legs because they're so optimized for cars. So even though you say it's going to be easier- Mm … in the end, you're just taking away the value of my legs that my mother gave me, and I prefer to use the legs. 1:37:48 We call that transfer of value. Because the value is transferred to, to somewhere else. That's 1:37:53 amazing. To you. Yes. 1:38:01 Okay, do take over. 1:38:02 Oh. 1:38:04 It's your turn. 1:38:05 Yeah. Yeah. 1:38:05 Yeah, 1:38:06 we did. We did- Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, that's it. 1:38:07 I gave- 1:38:08 No, do they just take it over? Yeah. 1:38:10 Oh, yeah. They don't cha- It's not, uh, being challenged. It's not. Yeah. It's not 1:38:13 challenged yet. 1:38:14 Aha, okay. It's 1:38:15 obviously ours. 1:38:16 Yeah. 1:38:16 Aha. 1:38:16 Community currencies. 1:38:17 Yeah. 1:38:18 It's that easy. 1:38:19 For them- Yes … yeah, at the moment it is. But the moment they have a challenge, they're, you know, um- 1:38:25 Hmm, I'm not sure. I think we need a commission to- Mm … challenge the rules of the game. Mm. I 1:38:30 think, I think 1:38:31 it's clear that we own the community currencies. 1:38:35 We will- It's in the name … we'll get the NFTs for theirs. Kinda optimistic about it. 1:38:40 I think we like that you think it's clear that you own it. Mm-hmm. 1:38:44 Yeah. Yeah, yeah. It's like take one- She wasn't making 1:38:47 sense … 1:38:47 sacrifice the queen. 1:38:49 Oh. 1:38:50 All right, so we have three or five. Participatory budgeting or going to jail. No. So it's obviously participatory- No, 1:38:57 no, no No, no, 1:38:57 it's- 1:38:57 You are, you 1:38:58 are this … so ecovillage or- 1:39:00 Ecovillage. 1:39:01 Or this one. 1:39:02 What is 1:39:02 this? What is this one? 1:39:04 Uh, that one is- Can place a challenge somewhere … uh, yeah, you can place a challenge anywhere. Oh. I mean, that sounds fun. Uh, where, where the commoners have, like- 1:39:13 Mm-hmm … 1:39:14 something. So it could be ecovillage, could be co-ownership, could be house sharing platform. 1:39:19 Oh, okay. But it could also be here. 1:39:21 Or community currency. 1:39:22 Mm. Yeah, because this is, this is heavily challenged 1:39:29 I have another go at it 1:39:30 I feel like we have to bring back the s- the solidarity What do 1:39:34 we have, like, what cards, what cards do you have? Do you have something for solidarity? 1:39:38 I mean, we can bullshit through any card ultimately 1:39:41 Yeah, yeah, definitely 1:39:43 Do you have 1:39:43 It's all a question of narrative 1:39:50 So you wanna go with community currency? No? Or whichever? Hmm. 1:39:55 Yeah, we can go with community currency 1:40:00 You have something? I'm not sure I have something to contribute No, just, just one- 1:40:03 I, I think I have something- 1:40:05 Yeah … 1:40:05 I 1:40:06 could put out there 1:40:10 You go for it. 1:40:11 Shall we do it? Yeah, 1:40:12 yeah. Let's 1:40:12 do it. Yeah. 1:40:13 Okay. So basically, um, I'm- 1:40:17 Also, you need to move your things up 1:40:20 Yes. Okay Also, okay, now, now we have… Okay, sorry. I'm confused. We are not here? 1:40:29 No, 1:40:29 no. We're… Okay. We, we, we- You are there, but you can influence- Okay. 1:40:31 But we are challenging this one. It's a PowerPoint where we 1:40:33 can- It's a PowerPoint. 1:40:34 Okay. I would just maybe comment that here you already have claimed one field. This is not 1:40:39 a, this is not a necessarily useful comment. 1:40:41 Really, 1:40:42 really, 1:40:42 really. Yeah, but, but this is what I thought. 1:40:46 Like, because their goal is to capture whole narratives. 1:40:50 Yeah. 1:40:50 These. And these are the most challenged points. 1:40:52 Yeah, yeah, 1:40:53 exactly. These don't have challenges yet. 1:40:54 Yeah, yeah. 1:40:55 Yeah. 1:40:55 Uh-huh. 1:40:56 So. 1:40:57 Should we challenge this 1:40:59 one? Would this already count as one that we have? 1:41:01 No. No. 1:41:01 We need 1:41:02 to get rid of that. Oh, no. Yeah. 1:41:03 Okay. Should we go with ecovillages? 1:41:05 We need to recapture- 1:41:06 I mean, ecovillage would be a new topic, but do we have- 1:41:13 I don't have anything for- 1:41:14 I have, actually. Eco-village. 1:41:16 Yeah? Okay. 1:41:17 Yeah. 1:41:17 Then let's do it. 1:41:19 Okay, let's put, uh- 1:41:21 No, 1:41:21 it's still here, I guess. It's still here. We're just playing eco-village because it's- Oh, okay … yeah. 1:41:25 We could as well just go three. 1:41:27 Um. 1:41:27 Yeah, yeah, because we, we could go there, here. 1:41:29 Oh, yeah. 1:41:30 Yeah, 1:41:30 yeah. But it's fine. 1:41:31 It's 1:41:31 whichever. 1:41:32 No. 1:41:32 Yeah, yeah. I mean- If 1:41:33 this was chess, 1:41:34 you 1:41:34 wouldn't, you wouldn't be allowed to move. Yeah. That is 1:41:37 like chess. 1:41:38 We have many 1:41:38 more of those to play. Indeed. Indeed. Yeah. Okay, so eco-villages. Let's go. Let's read the card first. 1:41:44 Okay. " 1:41:44 Environmental action is being framed exclusively as an issue of consumer behavior change." So, well, I mean, you probably all know the story of the carbon footprint and, and British Petroleum, uh, putting originally, by the way, 20 million or so to establish the concept in itself. And of course, after that, they have put a lot more money, but, but think about this. 1:42:10 So you wanted to create something that is not advertisement, but essentially like psyops. You're doing misdirection. You want people to especially take a topic that is real, you're, you're guilty of something, but then use that as a basis that you think about a topic, like carbon, by your guilt first, that makes you not think about that actually the corporation side is doing way more, or industry side is doing way more carbon. 1:42:38 This was the reason why British Petroleum established the concept and developed it. Now, think about it. Like, you're a rich oil company. You put 20 million into something, and it gets this sort of massive cultural paradigm. Do you think we stop- Or do you think actually this psyops operation as a continuous avenue that has continued from there, therefore? 1:43:03 So for this, uh, the whole framing of environmental action, not just carbon footprint, is an area that we're working. It's, it's something that we nudge, move, uh, and put in different avenues. Some of them are outlets, like eco-villages. Because we know from intentional communities and so on that it's actually good to have places where people who disagree vehemently with capitalism, they can go outside of the system. 1:43:30 They can become a tight-knit community because then they communicate less outside, and they become like a safety valve in a pressure zone, and they become their own ways of letting out the gas in itself. So it's great that there are eco-villages. Like, people who are strongly minded and could have an effect on the status quo go outside of the status quo and have less effect on it. So we want eco-villages. Pr- plea- please create more of these, uh, safety valves that 1:43:58 we release some pressure on the current extraction of capitalism. Go ahead. 1:44:03 Done with your rambling? Can we reply? Um, 1:44:07 I would actually put this up on a vote as such. 1:44:11 Okay. 1:44:14 Yeah, and the voting is open. 1:44:16 Yeah, like, obviously they don't understand the concept and the interconnectedness of eco-villages as a community organizing course for wider movements. Um, like, if you see, think we are withdrawing to there and then just, uh, live our hermit life. 1:44:33 Okay. Uh, proof is in the pudding. When we see the movements, then you can talk. 1:44:37 When you see the movements, it's too late. 1:44:41 Well, that's when you get the information across. 1:44:43 Yeah. 1:44:43 I mean, if you don't see the movement, go for it and act individually and without any of the information. But the movement is actually showing you where you're going. You have to take it into account. 1:44:53 And there's a nice term that the kids use that characterize what you're saying, uh, which would be hopium. 1:45:00 Hopium? 1:45:01 Yeah. 1:45:02 Mm-hmm. 1:45:04 Not just copium. Hopium. 1:45:06 Hopium. 1:45:09 That looks like a four. Oh. 1:45:12 I have to excuse myself for a second. 1:45:14 Ah, it's a four. Let's go with four. 1:45:17 Went down a little bit. Now it's a three. 1:45:19 Um, you're really interested looking at the markets, though, when it does go down, huh? 1:45:28 To you, everything that has numbers and lines is a market, right? 1:45:32 Well, if it goes up and down, and it has value. Actually, it's your turn. 1:45:37 So are you buying votes? Is that what you're saying? 1:45:40 I… It was my card, but your turn. But- Okay. Sure … it may, I guess it's the same. 1:45:44 Oh, of course. 1:45:44 So what do we have, one to four? Four. 1:45:47 Is it four? Uh, 1:45:47 it's a three. 1:45:49 Yeah. 1:45:49 Ah. 1:45:50 Yeah. 6.6. 1:45:54 It's less than 3.5. 1:45:56 Okay. Yeah. Well, it is. Oh. 1:45:59 We succeeded. 1:46:00 You… We succeeded. What do we have? Eco villages. Eco 1:46:03 villages, yeah. Eco village. Uh, that goes cards. 1:46:05 And challenge. 1:46:06 Uh, environmental action. Yes. 1:46:08 And then one of these. 1:46:09 Yes, please. To run. 1:46:10 No. So- These are our points. 1:46:13 No, no, no. You need a blue one. 1:46:14 We need the blue one. Yeah, yeah, no, no. Go ahead. 1:46:15 No. We need the blue one. 1:46:17 We could make a black one. 1:46:19 Oh, nice. Yeah. 1:46:21 Okay. 1:46:23 This one's… 1:46:24 All right. 1:46:24 System one. I, um, the bullet. So it's the two, two and… Wild card or workers council. Okay. I'll just… Um, anyone have something for workers council? 1:46:34 Wild card. Wild card. 1:46:38 Wild card. 1:46:38 What's the problem of workers council from an economicus? 1:46:41 Mm. 1:46:43 So we said we're interested- It's a legit 1:46:44 problem 1:46:46 Don't have anything 1:46:49 Never ending stories about humans as self-interested gain maximizing agents 1:47:02 I would go for the wild 1:47:03 card We'll take the wild card. 1:47:04 Wild card. 1:47:06 That's what they think they're, they're buying us by small favors. Um, but we take the wild card. Choose 1:47:11 one. Oh. 1:47:13 Okay, that's good. The top 1:47:14 one. The 1:47:14 top 1:47:14 one 1:47:17 Innovation Olympiad. Commonism, a radical turn to local solution co-creation 1:47:27 Yeah. So here, um, I would like to include the audience a little bit in deciding what the effect will be. So we have two options. Um, either Team Commonism adds 30 seconds to their storytelling timer, or the players gets to pick a card from the, from the deck, uh, and add them to their hand So, um, or maybe this is… 1:47:56 I'll, I'll put this choice to the players for now. But, um, some of these wild cards, um, do come with two possible effects, and I'll extend the question to the audience which one- 1:48:07 Each of us can 1:48:08 pick one … but which one would you prefer in this case? We want, 1:48:10 we want to have cards. 1:48:11 Yes. One more card? 1:48:13 Each of us. 1:48:13 Okay. 1:48:14 Um- Go through the whole staple and pick. 1:48:16 No, it's, it's, it's one player only. 1:48:19 No, one player. 1:48:21 And we can choose who? 1:48:23 Maybe player one. One player gets an extra card, or you get 30 seconds extra for a round. 1:48:28 Extra card. Oh, card. Extra card, please. Um, 1:48:32 sorry. 1:48:35 Yeah, give them the challenge. 1:48:36 I cannot. True? 1:48:38 Uh, in this case you just pick one. Come on, that would be too easy, huh? Oh, no, sorry. This is one from the top three. Yeah. So you pick one. 1:48:46 Oh, too easy. Too easy. 1:48:50 And this is a submission from the audience, uh, but I can put on the full text here if you do choose that. 1:49:06 Oh, but we can continue- 1:49:07 Yeah … uh, 1:49:08 you know. 1:49:08 Should we- We're 1:49:09 not 1:49:09 hinging on- We throw while they're… Uh, who moved last? It was you. 1:49:14 Yeah. 1:49:15 From people. Yeah, I put- 1:49:16 No, no, from Azat There, but, um- Like, uh, just to… Six and one. Which one 1:49:20 are you? Fairphone. 1:49:21 Fairphone. 1:49:22 Fab Lab or- 1:49:24 Um … 1:49:25 um, what is this one? 1:49:27 Five, six. 1:49:27 That's the wheel of speculative fortune. 1:49:31 What does it do besides speculate the fortune? Sounds good. 1:49:35 Yeah. But- 1:49:36 Yes, 1:49:36 sounds like a good experience Yeah, we should probably risk it, 1:49:38 huh? Yeah. 1:49:38 But how, how does it work? 1:49:40 Well, there's a bit of chance involved. So, like- That's enough … one variation is that there's a 50/50 chance that either you will… You can, uh, uh, claim one area or they will claim an area. So if you get one to three, you can claim it. If, if you get four, five, six, they can claim it. 1:50:00 With a dice? 1:50:02 Yeah. 1:50:02 Well, so far we've been very lucky with one to three, so I wouldn't actually spin that wheel. 1:50:07 Yeah. Yeah. So I mean, and there are other choices, Fab Lab. 1:50:12 Yeah. 1:50:12 Do you have something? 1:50:13 Um- 1:50:14 You could lock it in. 1:50:17 But could we… Because we're entering, could we throw, like, one to four to kind of… I think the odds should favor the- 1:50:24 Mm … 1:50:25 the one who is entering. 1:50:26 Yeah. 1:50:26 Um, like- No … 1:50:28 it's a bit of negotiation here. 1:50:29 Yeah. It's a- Like, what is this? No. No. Well, well, I mean, your choice. Like, otherwise we're not picking it. You would get a chance. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Just a smaller chance. Well- Like- … 1:50:38 no It's 1:50:38 like at 1:50:38 least you have an option. 1:50:39 No. Yeah. 1:50:40 No. A smaller chance- The rules are non-negotiable … is the 1:50:43 advantage. Yeah. 1:50:44 Well, they, they sort of are. That 1:50:46 is- We have been 1:50:46 negotiating 1:50:47 them 1:50:47 from 1:50:48 the get-go. 1:50:48 That, that's our position. 1:50:49 I would just underline- Negotiable yeah, underline that you entered saying no without knowing what the discussion was, was about. And just as a portrait- We don't need to understand the content if we 1:50:58 know that it's, uh- I, I heard. I heard your suggestion. 1:51:00 So just because of the principle- So which card did you pick when you- On a principle basis, you will say no 1:51:04 you said I pick that one? You pick the community card. 1:51:06 Uh, we can go for Fab Lab. 1:51:08 It's the commoners spirit, right? 1:51:09 We can propose another challenge for the Fab Lab. 1:51:12 All right. 1:51:12 We lock it in. 1:51:13 Okay, we go and we- Or we 1:51:14 can 1:51:14 take the risk of- Or we go with a spin … we walk out of- 1:51:15 Should we take the risk because we've been incognito? 1:51:17 We might. 1:51:18 Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Let's take the risk for the- Let's, let's take the risk. What does the audience think? Do we go for risk of, uh- Yes … risk something? Risk? We take the 1:51:26 risk? 1:51:27 Yes. 1:51:27 Yeah? 1:51:28 Okay. 1:51:28 We'll take the risk then. 1:51:29 So then it's a big dice roll. It's 1:51:30 on you. 1:51:31 Yes. 1:51:32 One dice? 1:51:33 One dice. And then one- What is it? One, two, three, four- No … we win. One, two, 1:51:37 three, you win. 1:51:38 Um, 1:51:39 four, five, six, they- You didn't, you didn't specify and we didn't agree. 1:51:42 Um, okay. So- 1:51:44 One to three is them? Yes. 1:51:46 Yes. 1:51:47 But it's gonna be five anyway. 1:51:49 Yeah 1:51:51 I mean, let's- … two. Mm. De- deactivate. Um- 1:51:57 I forgot to push 1:51:57 the button. So we can take any area. 1:52:00 Yeah. 1:52:01 And just take it or argue 1:52:03 for it. Basically, you- 1:52:05 We could take 1:52:05 the workers' council … the idea was that you have a freebie, but still the, the challenge should make sense. 1:52:10 Okay. 1:52:10 Ah. So if we get the participatory budget, we have the participatory. 1:52:15 But what if we take a, say, a challenge area like co-ownership? Can we take this? 1:52:19 Mm, yeah, you can present a challenge anywhere. 1:52:23 Yeah, because, like, w- like, because we're really trying to block them to take- Right … one area, like collaborative internet. 1:52:29 Mm. The thing is you already have one here, and this one is completely up for grabs. 1:52:33 Yeah. That, that is true. 1:52:34 So tactically it would make sense- 1:52:35 Mm-hmm … to occupy this one and that one. I mean, to, to be honest, we should take a ride sharing platform because we already have it. It's, this is, like, false proof anyway. 1:52:40 Like I said, they really want the 1:52:41 rides. 1:52:41 Yeah. 1:52:42 Yeah. 1:52:43 But Uber makes so much sense. Like, everywhere you go- No, it doesn't … you just take one app, and you don't have to think about how to… Like, go to Bogota. You sit down, you open the app. So, no, actually- Thanks for 1:52:52 subsidizing a decade of, of ridesharing at least we take the, 1:52:53 at least we take the risk. Like, at least you have some identification verification, like- But you believe that- … you know, the reputation 1:52:58 is there … not thinking is a good idea. 1:53:00 Sorry? 1:53:00 You, you just said- No, it's a reality … "Everybody, you don't have to think." No. We think that thinking is good. Why would I say that? 1:53:06 Yeah, 1:53:06 think. We shouldn't- I think we shouldn't provide services that make people think less … 1:53:09 But th- but this is precisely your problem. We don't think it's a good idea. We think it's a reality. Yeah. And of course, we have a bunch of statistics which we believe. It's likely too much, but it's still more useful than your opinion, is that it happens to be a real- reality that people like thinking less than more- Mm especially when using apps. Mm. So- I don't 1:53:28 think that's correct. 1:53:29 Mm. 1:53:29 Well, you don't… Like, you have a subjective opinion, and it's great that you're working by subjective opinions for… And we're working with, well, clumsy statistics- Mm … but it's still more than a subjective opinion. 1:53:40 But as human beings, you, you have nothing but your own subjectivity. 1:53:44 I mean, you know, it's like my professor of statistics at college. He said, like, "There is a lie, there is a bigger lie, and then there's statistics." 1:53:53 And then- 1:53:53 And this is what you 1:53:54 are working on … then there is a personal opinion. Just ask, ask Trump. 1:53:57 Yes. 1:53:58 Like, there is a lie, bigger lie, statistics, and personal opinion. It's a missing layer. Um- 1:54:05 You are missing a player, but you do have a minute, in the interest of the audience, to- 1:54:09 So are we claiming ride sharing? Do you have a card for it? Let's include this kind 1:54:20 Yeah. Let's check. 1:54:22 Uh- Grab. Always looking for the holes. So I'm taking it. Market. 1:54:26 Covering a huge amount of distance. 1:54:28 No. 1:54:29 Hmm. 1:54:29 That's your market. 1:54:32 Do you have anything? 1:54:34 Um, okay, let's just play one because this is mostly proving that, uh, this is for us anyway. So, mm, so we're playing lack of deregulated spaces for inclu- uh, inclusive innovation and testing of community-led economies. 1:54:50 Mm-hmm. 1:54:50 And then mostly here is that the lack of these spaces is partly by design. Um, that in itself when a new field comes, like of course Uber didn't invent ridesharing, as did Airbnb didn't invent, uh, app sharing, and there were even apps before both, um, more on the communism side. But, uh, but then precisely the first thing that Uber does or Airbnb does is, 1:55:19 is not so much play for money, but take a bunch of money to play for power. So they lose a bunch of money because they're spending that money to claim power. Um, and, and that in itself is then limitation of the spaces for others. So there are many innovative ridesharing platforms on the communism side. Uh, but the play for power of like, do you have your ridesharing in this small city, and does it work there, and do you get people actually doing 1:55:48 the ridesharing is the key power. Not just political power, but social power. And, and this is a major limitation of the other innovation spaces, or you could call them competitors, and this is what we do all the time as exampled by Airbnb, uh, certainly exampled by Uber in itself. And it works 1:56:13 Okay, so we will put this up for a vote and the voting is open, but there will be a twist- Also, 1:56:19 yeah 1:56:19 to this round because it's the wheel 1:56:24 Oh, a twist? Are you… Is this a secret twist? 1:56:29 What was the 1:56:29 twist? What, what, what is the wheel? 1:56:33 Uh, yeah, the 1:56:35 wheel. Ah, yeah, here. Yeah, yeah, of course. Uh, mm-hmm. I missed that. 1:56:40 Oh, I wish I was here for the conversation. Lack of deregulated spaces. 1:56:44 Mm-hmm. 1:56:49 So you remember when they said 1:56:50 they- It was just the one minute … 1:56:53 they, 1:56:54 they just. 1:56:54 Yeah. 1:56:55 Yeah. What does that mean? Like, we need more- 1:56:58 No, we- the vote will decide. 1:57:00 No. 1:57:01 Oh. We'll see. 1:57:04 So you would do it as a DAO? 1:57:05 What, sorry? 1:57:06 You would do it as a DAO? I mean, with DAO you like the, the lack of deregulation. 1:57:12 N- no, DAOs are more, like, experimental ground, and ex- other people are doing the experiments for us, and then we buy in if they are successful, uh, as is happening right now. Um, DAOs or platforms like we're now buying Ethereum, um- Mm-hmm … by owning mot- most of its staking. Uh, like, we got a little bit behind. The Chinese bought, uh, or operate mo- most of the Bitcoin, which is more Chinese being ahead of the game. 1:57:40 Um, but that's remains to be seen where it ends up, but with Ethereum we're now, especially with the new move, it's, it's much more BlackRock, BlackRock, uh, is present for the staking, and the major infrastructure is now coming from the major financial operators 1:57:59 Okay. So, uh, the average is around three, but the twist that I mentioned is that you get a plus one- 1:58:06 Oh … 1:58:06 on the vote because you, you participated in and won the Wheel of Speculative Fortune. So it's- 1:58:13 Mm-hmm … 1:58:13 a little bit easier in this case- 1:58:15 So a four … 1:58:16 to co-op. A four. So it's a four. Mm-hmm. But still, it, it's a little bit up to chance. 1:58:21 Who- 1:58:22 I- 1:58:23 Who wants to throw? 1:58:24 Uh- You go for it. 1:58:25 Okay. 1:58:25 Yeah, do it. 1:58:26 It's just a dice. Four. It's a four. Oh. Yes. 1:58:29 Yeah. So, so 1:58:30 that- Nailed it … 1:58:31 yeah. 1:58:32 So- 1:58:37 Looks pretty good 1:58:38 Yeah. Looks authentic 1:58:40 We got the 1:58:40 platform Documents the time. 1:58:43 But it was obvious that we were gonna get the platform. 1:58:44 Yeah. 1:58:45 Come on. What are you going to do? So, 1:58:46 but, but in, in that case, it's like it's, it's, uh, uh, it's still of course disputed. That's why, that's why the cookies don't matter And in the end we'll see who gets to have the sharing. Yeah, yeah. So we need this extra round. 1:58:56 Essentially it's now very hard for them because the key thing, they think they're winning this area, winning this area, but they really want like one of topics, collaborative. Yes. And I would point out that they don't have a singular topic to their name. True. Yeah. Yeah. And we have crypto. Yeah. Which is… Well, okay. But 1:59:12 time is running out, so all we need to do now is as many red ones on the board. 1:59:16 Mm-hmm. 1:59:17 Mm-hmm. 1:59:18 Mm-hmm. 1:59:20 So me, right? 1:59:22 So what were you doing for the rest of the game? Yeah. 1:59:25 Trying to win holistic 1:59:27 form or- 1:59:28 Okay. 1:59:28 For you. One, one heaven. Are you 1:59:30 the blue? 1:59:31 No, I'm this one. Mm-hmm. So we take the three, right? Oh, 1:59:34 right. Confusing. Yeah. 1:59:37 Participatory budgeting. 1:59:40 Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. 1:59:41 Easy-peasy. 1:59:43 I listen to you. 1:59:44 Easy. 1:59:45 I would just note, note that in the end when we'll do the tally, like these ones that you… These ones are worth half a point, whereas these, where they had to argue for them, are worth one point. 1:59:56 'Cause we argue- But we were willing to argue. 1:59:58 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. 1:59:59 Yeah, but, but- We 2:00:00 just never got the chance. 2:00:01 But you… Yeah. 2:00:02 See, this is why it's good to negotiate the rules 2:00:04 of the 2:00:04 game. 2:00:04 Yeah. On the blue, on the ones where there's a red and the blue, the red one should count for one point as well, right? Because there was fight. Mm-hmm. For instance, here. 2:00:12 Yeah, yeah. In that case, it is. I'm just saying for those that you took without any challenge. Okay. I think 2:00:18 that's your piece. Let's move. Mm-hmm. 2:00:20 Then we this guy and we're good. 2:00:22 Yeah, yeah. 2:00:24 What does this one do? It's a Trojan 2:00:26 horse. Trojan horse. Yeah. So it subverts the whole situation. 2:00:29 So we take back the- It works both way? … sharing. 2:00:32 Uh, no, that one's for them. The 2:00:33 co-opt is 2:00:34 for you. 2:00:35 Mm-hmm. So yeah, it's, it's your turn. 2:00:38 Okay. 2:00:38 Yeah. Which one? The one- 2:00:41 Six and six. Now this is interesting. One, two, three, four, five. Back to the eco-village. The- That's called 2:00:50 the eco-village then 2:00:54 The eco village 2:00:56 I need one more card. 2:00:58 Mm-hmm. 2:00:59 I can deal them myself. Yeah. This is how it's supposed to get your hands on the tools of distribution 2:01:14 Well, maybe let's … Oh, do you have something that responds directly to that? 2:01:20 Mm. I'm thinking about it Mm. 2:01:24 Give me a second … on the topic. I, I have one Just to note for the audience, there are some refreshments over there, some water and some snacks, uh, in case you didn't, uh, notice. 2:01:33 I might have one that offers a little bit of a twist to the topic, and that's, um Okay, I'll read out the challenge. Yeah. "General displeasure with governance, stemming partly from economic inequality, leads to cascades of protest votes, creating a wave of dysfunctional nations." Now, this might not be at first glance connected to ecovillage, but I would like to talk about the potential of ecovillages to really engage in, um, building capacity 2:02:01 of protest, uh, against capitalism. 2:02:04 Mm. 2:02:04 And, uh, to me, as I, as I see the ecovillage, and you talked about it before- 2:02:09 Mm … 2:02:10 many intentional communities fail. Mm-hmm. You see them failing- Mm … because, uh, a lot of attention is going inward. And ecovillages have yet to prove their capacity of really networking and- Mm … um, to, to s- yeah, to sort of, um, bring about, um, social change in a way that really, uh, um, brings up new dimensions of, um, social coordination. Ecovillages still have to prove that. 2:02:38 I don't see it happening in the near future. So, uh, in that sense, and I, I just wanna connect to the previous argument, um, I think we really like ecovillages to be around. Uh, they are fantastic outlets. Um, and they also respond to people's needs of being together in intentional- Mm communities. But in the end, on the long run, they will not play a role in overt- overturning capitalism, because they won't be in a position to establish protest culture. 2:03:08 Mm. Yeah. Yeah. They're, they're like isolation tanks for the potentially damaging players. Uh, that we can send them to isolation tanks also outside of the game, or they send themselves. 2:03:19 Okay. So you're saying ecovillages don't have the capacity to bring that challenge up? Or 2:03:25 which 2:03:25 you want No, we're, we're making- The networking Yeah. People 2:03:26 get Yeah. To 2:03:26 respond … maybe To 2:03:27 respond to the challenge. 2:03:29 Yeah. 2:03:29 We are making a challenge. Yeah. That's our role here. 2:03:31 Yeah. 2:03:31 We're challenging the idea of ecovillages actually dismantling the capitalism. 2:03:36 But the challenge reads differently. 2:03:38 Mm. Well, actually- 2:03:40 It's for the audience to decide We'll, we'll let the audience decide. Uh, voting is open 2:03:49 Yeah, if it stems partly from economic inequality Challenges that 2:03:56 generally- 2:03:57 So this is something that I actually pretty strongly feel about. We went to Greece this summer- Results in 2:04:00 failing nations … 2:04:01 and people were talking about building eco villages in Greece and here in Slovenia. The way we ended up the conversation was more like, like this is very similar to the avocado consumerism. I mean, you know- Like people being obsessed over a concept- I just wanna push the whole scenario there … of eating avocado more and more. And then this changing the farming infrastructure and like- I don't… I think eco villages then stands for- … making societies only focus on one agricultural asset … 2:04:24 well, 2:04:25 ecological sustainability 2:04:26 and we see worldwide what that's about. And so I don't know how- And same goes with eco villages. Just focusing 2:04:27 on building the eco villages and not taking into account what actually happens in that local society. It's going to be a clash like it's consumerism 2.0 2:04:39 but on a local scale. Yeah, but the idea is just, you know, yeah. Yeah, and it's- I, I understand this point of view that if, um- Yeah failing states become easier to take advantage, right? I mean, there's the whole attention economy. So shouldn't they give some of the limits of their, um, kind of, or expression of their power to the poor? Like even the carbon footprint is an example of it. It's like creating a sort of kind of point of attention that serves 2:04:54 your needs in terms of like- Mm. people start with their own guilt. Similarly like, okay, if you make an avocado a point of attention, you're building an 2:05:02 economy. Failing states become easier to take. It's five minutes to end. Um. Okay. Three. It's a three. 2:05:05 It's a three. 2:05:06 It's a three. 2:05:08 Okay. Well then. Let's challenge our luck one more time. I don't believe 2:05:15 it. Yeah. I, I think we're just proving that even with super bad luck we'll win. Mm. It's 2:05:20 surprising. And with six points of a handicap, right? 2:05:24 Yeah. Mm-hmm. 2:05:26 And we only get half 2:05:27 more. Two, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, which means two thirds of the points you have on the board were gifted to you. I'm just saying. 2:05:35 But that's what it gets 2:05:36 you towards. Oh, don't you think 2:05:36 it's a picture of reality? Yeah, that's what 2:05:38 it gets. Okay, um, whose turn is it? Is it yours or is it mine? 2:05:41 It's mine I think. 2:05:42 What's that? 2:05:44 So I'm that guy. What do I need? I need a two, right? 2:05:48 For the wheel or what? 2:05:49 Yeah, or what are we doing? 2:05:50 Um, I think we could… 2:05:54 So a four and six. Sure nothing to go. Like 2:05:57 either go- Eco village … 2:05:58 we can go with workers council. Workers council. Oh, no. And… No, we don't win the four one. 2:06:02 Do we have something for workers council? Or eco village, we can lock in eco village. No. No, we can lock in refi. 2:06:09 Yeah. 2:06:10 Mm. Oh, yeah. I would like to see you locking in ReFi. 2:06:20 Mm-hmm. 2:06:22 Mm-hmm. I think I'm, I'm locking in ReFi. 2:06:25 Do, do you think you can lock in the Re- the ReFi? 2:06:27 Yeah. I'm locking for anything. And that would be, that would be responding to that challenge, right? 2:06:31 Okay. 2:06:32 Okay. So I would try with- You still know the challenge? I would try with this. This one 2:06:36 actually 2:06:36 goes all the way, right, mm-hmm? Ah, the old. This one goes all the 2:06:38 way. No, this one's the- 2:06:39 With, with the challenge that Re- no, with the ReFi challenge that's here. 2:06:42 Yeah, the cha- so 2:06:43 the- That, that it's a, uh- 2:06:45 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'll read out- Yeah … the challenge first. 2:06:47 Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. 2:06:49 So the challenge is that DeFi/ReFi becomes a meme in the crypto space. It is being abused by virtue signaling scams and Ponzis which leave honest projects permanently damaged. Then we've already placed our intervention that we, um, present alternatives to neoliberal policies at discussion tables at the next climate negotiations. Um, so this is the status quo. 2:07:15 Yeah, good luck. 2:07:16 Yeah. 2:07:16 Uh-huh. And, um, now we do acknowledge that you had some, um, attempts at derailing, uh, the whole field and, um, making the wider crypto field believe that, uh, ReFi is basically degens, uh, dressed up. Mm. Mm. Um, however- Mm-hmm … we come together at the ReFi Unconference, um, 2023 in, at the CryptoCom's Hub, uh, and have a hackathon that Now I'm reading. 2:07:46 Hackathon, a cross-disciplinary platform where members exchange ideas and develop projects that celebrate openness, open source, and open action. And the first thing we do is we come to terms, um, on how to evaluate projects in the space because we have seen some bad actors, uh, emerge. Um, and basically, our hackathon is, uh, geared towards a reconsolidation of, 2:08:10 um, honest and, um, um, honest and, um, regenerative projects to, um, consolidate the spirit that was actually driving the, the first ReFi projects and that you tried to derail with your scam artist allures. 2:08:32 So yeah, basically, you know, it's like your claim that, uh, ReFi is unicorn poop is basically being refuted, uh, by us actually developing the solution 2:08:46 Okay, it's within time, so it's up for a vote, which is open. 2:08:52 It's gonna be all sixes now because the audience wants us to 2:08:55 win. I, I would note that your whole speech was an advertisement. 2:09:01 Yeah. Mm-hmm. 2:09:02 For the, uh- … ReFi 2:09:04 conference. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So 2:09:06 actually even a financial advice. 2:09:09 No. 2:09:09 ReFi. No? 2:09:11 Mm. 2:09:11 I don't know. 2:09:12 There's nothing to gain but knowledge and friendships. 2:09:15 Mm. 2:09:16 That's how it starts. 2:09:18 Yeah. Most commoners- Price … are very skeptical of the ReFi space. 2:09:21 Mm. 2:09:23 I think. 2:09:24 Yeah, I, I think it's great for us that you're turning nature into a, a capital investment targets and finance 2:09:32 I mean, it's better 2:09:33 for the next generation forest tokens Let's 2:09:34 sound clever. Let's, let's- 2:09:35 Let's turn forest into tokens. Let's turn land into tokens, and let's look at 2:09:40 their value on a market … let's siphon off money, uh, from the financial, um, speculation on these tokens to build true 2:09:47 alternatives. 2:09:47 It's not- 2:09:47 Right … yeah, and it's not about- Also, it can be staked transforming forests into tokens. It's about creating a new marketplace where people are able to make money off of betting on things that are good for the planet. 2:10:00 Thank you. But the- That was a great pitch for the capitalism. 2:10:02 Yes, because the basic ru- rule of finance is that- … the larger pool you have, the more you win in investment. So you have 200 euros. You make a amazing investment. You make your money five times. So, so now you have, uh, uh, 2:10:21 like, 2:10:21 over 1,000, whatever the unit is. Now, here's a shitty investor who puts 1 million, and they only make, let's say- 2:10:32 But let's- … 2:10:33 10% of win … let's, 2:10:34 let's get this straight here … 2:10:34 they get 100,000. 2:10:36 Well, it is not- But he's speaking about ReFi being a meme, but you just made a case that it's not just a meme, that it's a 2:10:42 real thing. No, no, it's the case for him, like- Mm … to turn them tools to make money. Okay. Yes … but then as finance works- But- … whoever brings the most money wins the most. That's the 2:10:52 basic 2:10:53 ratio- But if we would have- … of finance … so it's not a meme. It's not a 2:10:55 meme … if people aren't being harmed. 2:10:57 Team, they want to drag us- No, it means that if- into endless debate. Uh, sorry … we have half an hour to win this over, so let's roll the dice and show them, uh- 2:11:03 Uh, actually, like, the, it 2:11:05 ends now. Ends now. It's- With no further- 2:11:08 Okay. He tried, he ends already. He 2:11:10 tried. So what do we need? We need a three. Or 2:11:12 four. Four. Four. We need a 2:11:13 one to four. It's, it's a pretty good, 2:11:16 uh- Easy. Easy … hmm. 2:11:18 It's, it's not gonna work. 2:11:19 Easy. It's not gonna work. 2:11:21 No. 2:11:22 Would've won on anything. We could've stayed silent. That, 2:11:25 I think that's, that's convincing us. Mm-hmm. So now they go, I guess. Like, their challenge has to be fulfilled. 2:11:30 Hmm, yeah. In that case- 2:11:32 Goodbye … 2:11:33 we can put away that. 2:11:33 This, this. And we lock it in. 2:11:35 Mm. Yeah. Looks like. 2:11:37 So 2:11:38 this is locked in. 2:11:39 Mm-hmm. 2:11:40 In order to win the whole regenerative thing- Then we have to- … they would also have to lock in this as well. 2:11:45 Yeah. 2:11:46 Mm-hmm. There's still an open challenge. Yeah. 2:11:48 Okay. 2:11:48 Still an open challenge, yeah. Well, it's… 2:11:50 Oh. 2:11:50 But the game is over now, or what? 2:11:52 Well, we've sort of run out of time. 2:11:54 Oh, really? They get one more turn, then we do. 2:11:57 Uh- That's okay … good day. Well- Yeah, 2:11:59 yeah, 2:11:59 because they started … well, let's dive in. Well, then let, let's even if out, even it out with the last one. No, I mean, if they 2:12:04 would've talked less- 2:12:05 Mm … they would've 2:12:06 gotten an extra turn. They were the team that ran over- … the time limit twice, so no. 2:12:11 And Julia wants 2:12:11 to say, like, she's not there. You, 2:12:13 you had a protest to rebuttal, 2:12:14 though. I mean, you were- That is true … the team that argued more. Like, we, we gave- 2:12:20 That's not true Because we come on the board and we just win the, the pieces, so obviously we are in that- There 2:12:26 was, there was some shady tactics, like- You're the ones 2:12:31 advertising your shady- I mean, I was surprised because you were- I mean, the only advertisement here was you not advertising. No, no, no. Uh, listen- So- … we have more data. We just have more evidence to share. Yeah, yeah. I think that's why we need more time. 2:12:39 Yeah. 2:12:39 And- Well, 2:12:40 tha- thanks for pointing out that it was indeed an advertisement. ReFi Unconference 2:12:49 Indeed. But, but a good one. But… 2:12:52 So 2:12:53 how much are these ones 2:12:54 worth? These are two points. Yes. This is half. This is three, four, five and a half points. 2:13:01 Ah. So we have… Too many. 2:13:03 One, 2:13:04 two, three, four- They have six before we even begin the game … 2:13:06 five, six. It's like the game is rigged, guys. 2:13:09 Mm-hmm. 2:13:10 Hmm. 2:13:11 Hmm. 2:13:12 Eight 2:13:12 and 12 now as well. We'll be back. 2:13:14 Yeah. See, there was a point to stall the time because then you get less turns, and because we're starting from a- Yeah bit of a, a upscale, so. 2:13:27 Like, I honestly thought we were playing too long. We should be faster than. 2:13:30 Yeah, I thought so too. Since it's the, uh, zen room workshop, I think. Ah. 2:13:35 Mm. Mm-hmm. 2:13:37 Well, I wouldn't mind being here, but I, I thought maybe it's also good to, you know, uh- 2:13:42 Stay realistic … 2:13:43 have a break. And if anyone wants to, you know, discuss or give feedback- Mm on the game, uh, you're more than welcome to. Mm. And we could just mingle a little bit- 2:13:52 Mm … 2:13:52 um, before, you know, moving on to the- 2:13:54 I want to say, uh- … 2:13:55 rest 2:13:55 of the program 2:13:56 … 2:13:56 great, 2:13:56 great progress on the game. Mm.